We’re back for the fifth installment of Congratulations, She’s a Boy, following Wellington writer Felix Desmarais’ female-to-male transition. This month: the secret lives of guys.
Bro bro bro. Mate mate mate.
Buddy. Champ. Pal. Cobber.
Okay, maybe not ‘cobber’ in this century (though I think the word is due for a revival).
I ‘pass’ now. That is to say, 99.9% of the time the general population reads my appearance as that of a cisgender guy and genders me accordingly. Sir, fella, man.
I don’t really like the term ‘passing’ as I have mentioned before, since it implies a lie or a secret, but it’s less clumsy than ‘being read as a cis man’. So we’ll go with ‘pass’ for now.
Living (ostensibly) as a woman for 28-ish years, now being seen by the world as the man that I am provides me with a pretty unique insight into what it is like to experience the world as both. I think the contrast in my experiences says a lot about how we treat men and, perhaps most particularly, how we treat women. The only problem is that unless you experience it yourself, it’s really hard to pin down to others who don’t.
The cloud of bros
But I feel like the cloud of bros (not literally, I should be so lucky) I walk around in is symptomatic of the micro-friendlies I have been experiencing since starting pass. I say ‘micro-friendlies’ in contrast to the microaggressions women are often on the receiving end of. In almost direct contrast to my experience as a woman, there are now tiny little affirmations every day of my existence in the world.
Before you click away, lost cis bro-dude who’s found himself reading this on the toilet, consider that you’re so used to life as a man that you’d be completely blind to the metaphorical doors that swing open for you constantly. You’re unaware of a lot of these in the same way I have the unique position of being hyper-aware of them because I’m not used to it.
It’s not just being called bro or mate or bud all the time, though that is one of the most overt things men do to affirm one another’s existence. But it’s not really about the word ‘bro’, it’s about the friendliness, the positivity, the, well, brotherhood. Sure, men call women ‘bro’ sometimes, and sometimes women use it too, but don’t tell me men call women bro (or something similarly affectionate) with the same frequency as they do other men. Again, ‘bro’ is symbolic, but to me it balances on the tip of that iceberg of male privilege.
OWWWWWWH HE SAID IT. The big P. Even more shocking, the big M. P.
Bro, bro. Male privilege exists. Trust me, it exists.
It’s so difficult to quantify that you’re just going to have to take my testimony (as I’ve no testes to swear this oath on, so you’ll have to accept my ovaries instead. My…. ovarimony? How seminal. Oh, shit).
And you know what? You shouldn’t actually need a trans guy to confirm what women have been saying for centuries. The idea that it takes a man’s words to make people believe women’s: would that be irony? After Alanis I just don’t know anymore.
I am He Man and I have the power (of male privilege)
The thing for me, now, is that I have to learn how to navigate this world now that I pass. How to take my male privilege and use it to empower the less privileged.
Pre-transition, I imagined myself in a men’s locker room when the age old locker room topic of grabbing pussies reared its mons pubis. I would draw up to my full height of 5’5’’, balance on my size 7 feet best I could, puff out my surgically modified chest, red blood cells rushing to my testosterone enhanced musculature.
“No,” I would say in a booming voice that would make Patrick Stewart sound prepubescent. “No, we do not grab pussies. We do not speak of grabbing pussies, except to ask consent to grab a pussy, ideally when the owner of the pussy has raised the subject themselves. THERE SHALL BE NO PUSSY GRABBING ON MY WATCH!”
That’s how it was going to go. I wasn’t so prepared for the grey areas.
A grey area
The other day, a guy at work was behaving a little oddly.
“Sorry bro – I’m out of it. My girlfriend cheated on me.”
He’s my colleague who I don’t know well, so this was a little unusual. But I get it, we’re all human and your partner cheating on you is a pretty crappy experience.
“Oh man, that sucks.”
“Yeah, women suck eh.”
In one split second, I think all of these things at once:
- Omg I pass so well this cis (I presume) man has deigned to share this slice of misogyny with me!
- Oosh, I used to be a woman.
- Well, I wasn’t ever a woman but I’ve experienced life as one.
- You don’t need to check yourself in your own brain yo.
- Not all women suck. Oh god is there such a thing as #notallwomen? The guy got cheated on, is now the time?
- He’s my colleague, whatever I say has to be diplomatic.
- That being said, as a feminist and cis-passing trans man it’s important to me that I speak up when I encounter misogyny
- Is this misogyny though? I mean he does mean women generally can suck, or rather that romantic relationships are emotionally difficult.
- Haha, fuck you’re a nerd.
- Oh god this silence is getting a little too long. Just say something.
- If it gets awkward he might suspect!
- Suspect is a problematic word to use in this case, Felix.
- Again, your brain is not the place to worry about semantics mate.
- Oh god now I’m mate-ing myself
- Lol, mating myself.
- But he might think I’m trans though
- No he won’t, cis people do not think ‘in trans’.
- Lol, ‘think in trans’ you should put that in your column.
- Ooh this will be a good topic for my column.
- Just say something sympathetic for the love of…
*Weakly* “Uh, well, I’m sure they’re not all bad…”
He didn’t respond. He was on his phone. I’m not even sure he was listening.
By the way, this is what my chest looks like now. Three months post op on the 7th of Feb, and on the 26th of January I passed seven months on testosterone. There’s a voice update on my Instagram. #Influencer.
*Obviously my experiences, as either a man or a woman, are not universal, and of course I’m conscious of the fact that in both cases I have been a white middle class person.
Read the previous entries in Congratulations, She’s A Boy here.
Throw Me the Ball: On Common Microaggressions Toward Women by Olivia Arredondo, 2017
You Kind of Have To Prove It: Gender Microaggressions within the Lived Experiences of Women in Engineering by Crystal Diaz-Espinoza, 2015
This section is made possible by Simplicity, the online nonprofit KiwiSaver plan that only charges members what it costs, nothing more. Simplicity is New Zealand’s fastest growing KiwiSaver scheme, saving its 10,500 plus investors more than $3.5 million annually. Simplicity donates 15% of management revenue to charity and has no investments in tobacco, nuclear weapons or landmines. It takes two minutes to join.
The Spinoff Weekly compiles the best stories of the week – an essential guide to modern life in New Zealand, emailed out on Monday evenings.