NEWCASTLE UPON TYNE, ENGLAND - OCTOBER 09: Ben Smith of the New Zealand All Blacks breaks through to score the first try during the 2015 Rugby World Cup Pool C match between New Zealand and Tonga at St James' Park on October 9, 2015 in Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom. (Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images)

Want to help Pacific Island rugby? Follow rugby league and give players the power to choose

The success of Tonga and Fiji in the Rugby League World Cup is a marker of what might happen if clubs gained more power in rugby, writes Jamie Wall.

In a week where World Rugby revealed a bit more of its agenda than it probably wanted to, the controversy of the awarding of the 2023 World Cup to France has overshadowed the real problem in the game.

Yes, the cup got awarded to France because there’s more money to be made there than Ireland and South Africa. At best it’s pragmatic, at worst it’s cynical – but everyone can agree that it’s obvious that international rugby needs more money rather than less.

Ireland will whinge long and hard about the decision. South Africa will feel somewhat bemused, given that they were more or less told it was theirs to lose just a fortnight ago. So it’s likely we’ve only just started hearing the recriminations about how it all went down.

But it shouldn’t cloud the much more important financial situation that’s affecting the have nots of the rugby world. The Samoan Rugby Union has declared bankruptcy and the national team members are relying on public handouts to simply make it through their tour of the UK. It’s the latest in an ongoing saga – and if it seems like it’s been going for years now, it’s because it has.

Conversely, there’s been some serious rumblings about the future of the game in the Pacific – albeit through a different code. The Rugby League World Cup has been tipped on its head thanks to a stacked Tongan side taking out the Kiwis in pool play, thanks in no small part by the defection of star Kiwi lock Jason Taumalolo. The New Zealand side were subsequently eliminated from the tournament after a loss to Fiji side led by superstar and former Kangaroo Jarryd Hayne. 

Taumalolo has recently signed the NRL’s largest ever contract, with the North Queensland Cowboys, worth AUD$10m over the next decade. He is set, and doesn’t need the lure of national or State of Origin selection to guarantee his financial future. Due in part to an acrimonious relationship with Kiwi coach Davis Kidwell, Taumalolo chose to play for Tonga – strengthening a team already boosted by the inclusion of Andrew Fifita in similar circumstances.

League, unlike union in this part of the world, is run by the clubs. It often makes the international game seem like a bit of a farce, given that the eligibility laws also allow players to switch allegiance seemingly at will.

However, is it necessarily a terrible thing that the Tongan league team are now world beaters thanks to a few players deciding that they’d rather play for them than the traditional superpowers? And isn’t that what those critical of the All Blacks and other nations taking Pacific Island eligible players want?

Is it finally time to admit that the perceived strength of rugby union is also, for nations like Tonga, Samoa and Fiji, probably its biggest weakness? The events surrounding Samoa’s financial woes reveal that strength only benefits the ones at the top of the pile. The solution may be the one thing that NZ Rugby dreads the most: opening the borders on eligibility, and decentralising teams to allow them to contract more foreign players.

It’s this switch of power that would make the difference to Pacific Island players, not just relaxing eligibility rules. Because really, would it change too much by letting former All Blacks and others go back and play for the islands? All they would have is top heavy teams and the same threadbare approach that would mean promising players based in Europe would most likely stay there for the test window. Sustainability is the key here, not just some quick fix that presumes that former All Blacks are just going to swoop in and save Samoan rugby.

It’s the union equivalents of Taumalolo that need to be making the switch, players who are at the peak of their powers, rather than guys in their thirties who have been playing in Europe. Once they have the money and security, then they can start to make the choice to play for the islands.

Then World Rugby can start doing something about the revenue sharing model. Because we could all forgive them for the debacle over the hosting rights for the World Cup – and even their thinly veiled reasoning that it will make them a ton more money – if that money actually goes to who needs it.


This story originally ran on RugbyPass.com – the premier destination for rugby fans in Asia, streaming International Test Matches including The Rugby Championship, Super Rugby and more to your device wherever you are in Asia.

The Spinoff Longform Fund is dedicated to facilitating investigative journalism. Our focus is on supporting in-depth reporting on important New Zealand stories. Your donation will help us sustain this most resource-intensive form of journalism, ensuring that the most complex and important stories still get told.

Related:


The Spinoff is made possible by the generous support of the following organisations.
Please help us by supporting them.