You first: RNZ staff want the redundancies to start in management
Journalists at RNZ want the job cuts to start with their managers. (Image: The Spinoff/Tina Tiller)
'The people that are going to get laid off aren’t on $100,000 salaries. It’s the people that are on $100,000 plus that fucked it.'
It was 3.30pm on a Monday and Paul Thompson looked like he was fronting a hostage video. RNZ’s chief executive was by himself in a dimly lit room wearing what staff say was a face like thunder as he waited for people to sign into an organisation-wide Teams call. In a departure from normal practice, all staff mics were automatically set to mute. As Thompson started reading out a prepared statement, the root of his unhappiness became apparent. RNZ had somehow unwittingly recorded an $11.8 million financial deficit in the year to March, about 25 times the amount it forecast just a month prior. Workers listened with increasing incredulity. “With every line, the same question pops into your mind: how? Just how? How!?” one says.
Thompson’s matter-of-fact statement opened a chasm between upper management and staff. The numbers were eye-watering. Its finance department had wrongly recorded $2m from a land sale as income in its budget. Staff costs, which included $1.4m in redundancy payments, were $3.2m over budget. Running costs were $6.4m over budget, with the organisation racking up big overruns getting its new Auckland office in the TVNZ building ready for staff to move into in June. It would later be revealed that as these costs were piling up, RNZ’s board signed off on an unlawful $5m overdraft. Somehow few of these issues were flagged by anyone, including the organisation’s audit and risk committee, though its former chair Jane Wrightson insists she raised the requirement to get government approval for the $5m overdraft.
Now the organisation is saying it’s going to have to cut 58, or one in six, of its staff, up from the 18 it had previously planned due to a funding cut. There’s no word yet on where those losses will come from, but the workers who sit below the strata of management responsible for this apparent bacchanal of financial bungling fear a good portion will be shorn from their ranks. They are, to put it lightly, extremely pissed off. “There are people with actual quantifiable outputs who contribute to the station and its various arms who will definitely lose their jobs under this current proposal,” says one of the six RNZ staff who spoke to The Spinoff on condition of anonymity. “But there are people whose job titles are essentially meaningless who are earning a lot of money that I think will scrape through this unharmed.”
That sense of unfairness is at the heart of staff frustration. One of the people involved in the errors – chief financial officer Hilary Parker – walked off the job in October. Thompson has said he takes responsibility for the financial blunders and left the organisation on Monday, six weeks early. Staff acknowledge that the chief executive’s departure represents a degree of accountability. “It's something. It was obviously the right thing to do,” one says.
But they are concerned that some other high ups, who seemed to have ignored or missed the errors, won’t suffer consequences. Workers spoken to by The Spinoff universally say they want any future cuts to focus on management. “The bigger concern is the rest of the executive and wider executive and human resources in my opinion. Where were the checks and balances? You can't just put the blame on Hilary,” one senior RNZ staffer says. “It’s a tragedy and those involved should be ashamed, and they should resign.”
There’s little confidence that those resignations will be forthcoming. Instead, workers suspect redundancies will disproportionately hit lower income staff. “The discrepancy between those top earners and junior reporters, for example, there's just a vast gulf. But we all know who's looking like they're losing their jobs,” says one. “The people that are going to get laid off aren’t on $100,000 salaries. It’s the people that are on $100,000 plus that fucked it,” says another.
To them, that represents a gross injustice. RNZ has been able to generate growing listenership and record web traffic in recent months. Now many of the staff that contributed to those gains, including presenters, producers and news teams, fear their jobs are going to be on the chopping block thanks to what they believe should be fireable mistakes from people above their paygrade and outside their departments. “If me or any of the many people on my level at work had lost, let's say $11,000, we would be gone immediately. We'd be let go. The fact that this is 11 million, and there's just going to be no consequences? I'm just so mad,” says one.
That anger isn’t just over the money their bosses accidentally lost. It’s also over what staff see as a lack of communication, accountability and answers. Workers feel like the senior leadership team is hiding from them. Perhaps even literally. Thompson still hasn’t been willingly interviewed outside of being doorstopped at the entrance to the RNZ building by Checkpoint host Lisa Owen in a terse exchange that ended abruptly. One staff member says that after his Teams call, Thompson went to work in a corner of the Auckland office. “No-one knew where he was.”
There are still so many details staff want about RNZ's blunders. “Who, what, where, why and how. We won’t get answers to those basic questions for a while,” says one worker. “One plus one equals two, usually. Unless you count the beans at RNZ. Then it’s 12,000,000.” Some staffers suspect Parker is being made into a scapegoat for wider failings. Though they appreciate that an investigation is being carried out, they feel they’re owed more transparency from the board and senior management given it’s their jobs on the line. "I think we all feel not just betrayed, but deceived, or at least intentionally kept in the dark,” says one staffer. “I still don't know specifically why [Parker] stood down, and I still don't know specifically how a fuck up of this magnitude came about. So being kept in the dark like that is incredibly frustrating."
It’s that question again, the one from Thompson’s first all-staff meeting: how? It’s not one RNZ is willing to answer in full right now. Its statement to The Spinoff says an upcoming review will establish why internal financial reporting didn’t accurately reflect RNZ’s position and look at the adequacy of its “financial controls, escalation, assurance and governance arrangements”.
Neither will the organisation commit to focusing its impending job cuts on management most responsible for the financial errors. “The reduction in RNZ’s staffing is about making RNZ financially sustainable,” its statement says. “Decisions made around the reductions necessary at RNZ are guided by RNZ’s charter and the needs of audiences.”
No matter how the coming weeks play out, staff are concerned they will mark the death knell for what one calls “the last place of refuge”. Commercial media is famously in the midst of a multi-decade economic collapse and its workers are under relentless pressure to generate clicks and subscriptions to stave off economic doom. For a lot of journalists, RNZ has been a bastion where they’ve had comparative freedom to carry out more fulfilling reporting. They believe that’s now at risk, not just due to this ongoing financial disaster, but because it plays into stereotypes about public media being profligate with money while eroding the trust of their government funders. “As a public institution, making sure that your finances aren’t in the shit is just a prerogative. We can’t be irresponsible with the money that the public gives us,” one says.
Some fear a dire future as RNZ deals with its unexpected loss under what may be a less-than-sympathetic National-led government. Prime minister Chris Luxon and outgoing broadcasting minister Paul Goldsmith have already ruled out a bailout for the organisation and staff see the possibility of this catastrophe setting off a lengthy period of managed decline. “They’ll cut and cut and cut back all parts of the organisation until there’s nothing but bare bones left and RNZ will be again reduced to a listless skeleton limping along on chronic underfunding for another decade or longer,” one worker says. “Not only will that ruin careers but it will ruin all the positive gains made in the last few years – and those who suffer most will be the public.”
That’s a grim picture, and not one that RNZ's workers drew themselves. The organisation's senior management are due to present a restructuring plan to the organisation’s board in December. If there’s one thing all the workers want to see, it’s for some of those managers’ own roles to be on the list they present. At the least, they don’t want to see them getting potential $60,000 bonuses or pay raises twice workers are getting. “They made this mess,” one says. “I would love to see senior management fall on their swords, take some sort of responsibility.”
Hayden Donnell
Hayden Donnell is a senior writer for The Spinoff. He previously worked at RNZ, TVNZ and the New Zealand Herald, alongside other media companies that have since closed down or been renamed. His primary passions are local politics and the Big Fresh animatronic fruit and veggies.