Hamish McKenzie on the media, Substack, and getting a ‘rigorous Musking’
Elon Musk, billionaire, and Hamish McKenzie, 'oathbreaker'.
What better publicity for your new book than getting called a ‘total piece of shit’ by the world’s richest man?
“No one should ever trust Hamish ‘Oathbreaker’ McKenzie. Total piece of shit.”
That was the considered view of Elon Musk when approached recently by Vanity Fair for a comment on How to Save the Media, the new book by Hamish McKenzie.
To which McKenzie, the New Zealand writer and co-founder of Substack, shot back: “Can I use this as a blurb for the book?”
The two men’s paths first crossed around 2013. McKenzie, then a reporter at a small tech publication called Pando Daily, had written a few pieces about Musk. A publisher invited him to tackle a book about this “fascinating and important character”. When McKenzie approached him, Musk had a counter-offer: come work for Tesla as an in–house writer.
McKenzie left after a year or so, and picked up again on the book idea. Musk didn’t like that. The book, Musk today charges, “grossly and deliberately violated his Tesla NDA”. McKenzie sees it differently. “That was just a fantasy thing he's made up to comfort himself, I think,” he told The Spinoff in an interview for At Large with Toby Manhire.
Still, Musk’s diatribe was “a nice gift”, promotionally speaking at least. “Very generous of him.”
In How to Save the Media, published this week, McKenzie chronicles a number of his other interactions with the world’s richest man. His 2022 acquisition of Twitter – now X – delivered a “Musk bump” to Substack. The newsletter-based service that McKenzie co-founded five years earlier had as part of its raison d’etre an alternative to the polarising invective that social media tended to incentivise.
When he got wind that Substack was launching “a Twitter-like feed in Substack called Substack Notes”, which some called a potential “Twitter killer”, Musk made a bid to buy the company. It wasn’t the first time Twitter had tried to acquire Substack. But as it was in the Jack Dorsey era, the answer was no. And so began another round of “rigorous Musking”. McKenzie recalled: “Elon got all upset and started declaring war.”
These days, Substack is a powerhouse in its own right, with the most recent capital raise valuing the company at a stonking NZ $1.8bn. McKenzie says he’s optimistic about the future of the media, and while he is clear that Sustack (which he originally fought to call “Monograph”) is only part of a wider constellation of innovations that offer hope, if How to Save the Media were a question, Substack would be a good chunk of his answer.
By the most recent accounting, he said, “there are more than 5 million paid subscriptions…. There's tens of thousands of writers making good money on the platform. Tens of millions of very active subscribers engaged with these publications. So I think it's a good fledgling ecosystem of quality media, but it's still got a long way to go in terms of scale because, you know, it's a baby compared to the size of YouTube or something like that.”
At the end of 2023, Substack faced a range of criticisms, including from high-profile users, about the high bar it sets on moderation. The Atlantic ran a feature with the singeing headline, “Substack has a Nazi problem”.
Since then, and following a number of exits, major New Zealander writers among them, had they moved to reassess the approach to moderation? “We haven't changed anything in the Substack content policy or rules. Our belief is that these problems that bedevilled the world as a result of the poor incentive system of social media are not well solved by increasingly heavy-handed content moderation or censorship,” he said.
“In fact, we think that some of those problems are made much worse because they erode trust. When there's overreach or mistakes, those moves erode trust. But the better approach to addressing those problems is to fix it at the root level, to fix it at the system design level, to create a set of incentives that reward different types of behaviour and cultural outcomes, and that insight has held true through Substack's history over the years.”
He added: “It doesn't mean everything's perfect or that some bad people can't see bad things on the platform. Some of that does happen, but in aggregate, the platform's quality has held up. People have their own experiences that they select into, and publishers have the protection of freedom of expression and freedom of the press. But as the ecosystem evolves and as the product evolves, we can give people more tools to control their own experiences and set the terms of their own experiences.”
At one point in the book, McKenzie recounts a conversation with Tina Brown, the legendary British editor of Vanity Fair and the New Yorker. She had suggested to him that, like her, he had the perspective of an “outsider”. Has being a guy from Central Otago in the US media maelstrom been a help or a hindrance?
“A big advantage,” said McKenzie, noting that his co-founders, Chris Best and Jairaj Sethi, are Canadian. “There are certainly some challenges, like you have to adapt to American culture and American business culture and the technology industry culture, but America is also very welcoming. It doesn't look like it on the news sometimes. But it's very welcoming of outsiders, especially those who have the ambition to build something.”
He was also “an outsider in the media industry in America”, he said, having “worked at some fringy publications”. That had “helped create enough distance that I could observe the system as it's working, and not be as vulnerable to the peer pressure effects. In New York media, for example, was very insular and clicky, and I got to look at that in a way that allowed me to take a more disruptive lens without fear of losing all my friends.”
In How to Save the Media, McKenzie describes missing New Zealand, and his friends here. Does he see this place in his future? “New Zealand is definitely in my future,” said McKenzie – whose New Zealand adjacent interests include an investment in Lume, a startup that seeks to do for musicians what Substack has for writers (and the brainchild of Spinoff founder Duncan Greive).
“I don't know how or when I can relocate to New Zealand permanently, but my goal is to keep increasing the part of my life that is occupied with New Zealand-related matters, so I'm going to increase my connection to New Zealand. I want to be in service in any way I can to New Zealand. I've got all my, you know, most of my important relationships are in New Zealand, so I'll try and just add more and more New Zealand to the plate.”
Service? Was he hinting at politics. “No! No, that sounds like an even more miserable existence than being a founder. Not that my existence is miserable as a founder, but stressful.”
Toby Manhire
Toby Manhire is editor-at-large at The Spinoff. He loves to cast a pod, whether it's Gone By Lunchtime, At Large or Juggernaut. He is a former editor of The Spinoff and has worked as a journalist in NZ and the UK since the last millennium.