Forty-six experts call for urgent select committee inquiry into MMP
Two ticks? (Design: The Spinoff)
An open letter with signatories including a former prime minister, a former Electoral Commission chair and the head of the 2012 MMP review is calling on the new parliament to fix the voting system’s vulnerability to engineered overhangs, Henry Oliver asks in today’s excerpt from The Bulletin.
To receive The Bulletin in full each weekday, sign up here.
Forty-six electoral experts have signed an open letter urging the new parliament to change the voting system, arguing that this election has shown MMP’s central promise of proportionality can be broken – and that unless the rules are fixed, future campaigns will compete to break them further.
The letter, titled “Keep the ‘P’ in MMP”, is led by Otago law professor Andrew Geddis, political scientist Lara Greaves and writer Max Rashbrooke, the Herald’s Jamie Ensor reports. Signatories include former prime minister Geoffrey Palmer, who chaired the 2023 independent electoral review; Deborah Hart, former Electoral Commission chair; Hugh Williams, who chaired the 2012 MMP review; and the principal research officer from the 1986 Royal Commission that recommended MMP.
Addressed to members of the new parliament, it calls on all parties to commit to adjusting the system’s settings “to safeguard proportionality”. The Post's Harriet Laughton reports the letter describes a “breakdown, both accidental and deliberately engineered, in the purpose of the party and electorate votes” on a scale not seen in MMP’s three decades.
As it stands, National won 42 electorates on a 29.2% party vote, entitling it to 35 seats – a seven-seat overhang. Te Pāti Māori won five electorates on 0.57% of the party vote, a four-seat overhang. Labour, with slightly more party votes at 29.4%, holds 36 seats. Parliament grows from 120 to 131. “These are not proportional outcomes and they give more power to some voters over others,” the letter says.
Deliberate vs organic
Geddis told RNZ’s Russell Palmer that Te Pāti Māori’s four seats came from a deliberate campaign to win influence beyond its entitlement, while National’s seven were "more like an organic result of the National Party continuing to do reasonably well in individual electorates, while its party vote fell off.”
But the combined effect, Geddis argued, undermines why New Zealand adopted MMP. He pointed to 1978 and 1981, when National governed despite Labour winning more votes, as “one of the reasons we actually shifted to MMP”.
“The overhang could well deliver the same outcome, where you have three parties that have a majority of the seats in the House, but receive fewer votes across the country than the other four parties in Parliament,” he said. “Not really the way democracy is supposed to work, and it’s definitely not the way MMP was supposed to work.”
The letter calls it a risk of future elections becoming “an arms race of who can best shepherd their voters” to engineer an overhang, noting “we have seen this happen overseas”. It suggests parties could run sitting electorate MPs as independents to multiply the effect.
The options
Four fixes are floated, each with trade-offs and each requiring public input:
- More list seats, fewer electorates – raising the share of list MPs so proportionality can be restored within Parliament.
- A single vote – merging party and electorate votes negating split-vote tactics.
- A German-style cap – allowing one or two overhangs per party but requiring enough party votes to cover the electorate wins.
- Party-vote-based voting strength – MPs keep their seats, but voting power in the House reflects party vote rather than MP count.
The German cap has an obvious problem: electorate winners with the lowest vote shares lose their seats, leaving constituencies unrepresented. “Good luck telling the voters of, well, you know, most of the North Island, you don't have an elected Māori MP anymore,” Geddis said.
Swapping one ‘complete dog’ for another?
The authors were pointed about the campaign behind the National overhang. Harry Mowbray, who ran Split Your Vote, has called MMP a “complete dog” for empowering minority voices — yet favours a supplementary member system that is markedly less proportional.
“There’s an irony there,” Rashbrooke told RNZ, “that some of the people who are trying to engineer a situation where MMP becomes less proportional, and then argue that’s a weakness in the system, are also people who want an electoral system that is much less proportional than MMP.”
A panel beater designing intersections
Geddis acknowledged the awkwardness of asking politicians to redesign the system that elected them (“like allowing panel beaters to design intersections”) but argued a select committee was the practical route. “If we get a parliamentary select committee doing the thinking about it, it’ll help MPs come to realise what the best solution is.”
The letter warns that if overhangs become established, “it is likely to lead to voters becoming disillusioned, lower trust in our democracy, and Kiwis feeling that the system is rigged.” It wants a narrow inquiry reporting back by mid-2027, in time for changes before the next election.
“We urge all parties in the new Parliament to work together urgently to address this new vulnerability,” it says, “so that we can keep the ‘P’ in MMP.”
Henry Oliver
Henry Oliver writes The Bulletin. He was previously The Spinoff's music editor, the editor of Metro, a bar owner, intellectual property lawyer, and bass player.