Why did a US film crew secretly document NZ’s election?
George Cheung, a podcaster and documentary maker with More Equitable Democracy. (Image: YouTube)
American podcaster and documentary maker George Cheung reveals why he spent the past two weeks in New Zealand.
Just after 10pm on election night, Green Party co-leaders Marama Davidson and Chlöe Swarbrick arrived at their election night headquarters to celebrate a record-breaking result.
More than 50 media representatives swarmed to capture the grinning pair at the entrance of the inner-city Auckland church St Matthew-in-the-City – including dozens of local journalists and several Australian TV crews.
But The Spinoff heard whispers of another film crew there that night, one with a host who had travelled much further to see how our tense, tight election might play out.
Once the election night drama died down, we asked around, received an email address, then a phone number, and finally we had a name: George Cheung.
The US-based Cheung is the director for the non-profit advocacy group More Equitable Democracy, a “racial justice organisation working to advance racial equity through electoral reform”. As part of his work with the group, Cheung hosts a podcast and Youtube documentary series called Democracy World Tour that explores how other countries elect their governments.
Part travel show, part political education series, Cheung has already toured sites of unrest in Brazil, interviewed political journalists in Germany and explored Australia’s compulsory voting system.
Now, it was New Zealand’s turn.
When The Spinoff contacted Cheung last week, he agreed to talk, but under strict conditions: we couldn’t publish anything until he and his crew had safely returned home.
They left the country on Monday, which is why we are running our story today.
Cheung told us that when he heard an MMP election was coming up in New Zealand, he wanted to experience it for himself.
So, he arrived on November 2 with two film crews and a support team of dozens, then began filming as our election unfolded, and continues to unfold: the results are still being counted and won’t be tallied until November 27. The forming of a coalition could take much longer.
It’s this kind of MMP election, a two-tick system with multiple parties vying for votes that often relies on coalition agreements to form governments, that Cheung wanted to learn more about. “We [the United States of America] have the same legacy first-past-the-post system that you all got rid of about 30 years ago,” he said, a reference to New Zealand’s 1993 referendum that led to MMP being introduced in 1996.
In particular, Cheung had closely followed the rapid ascent of the Opportunity Party into a potential position of power. “We are really interested in how smaller parties adapt and contest for seats,” he said. He got to ask party leader Qiulae Wong about this himself when he chanced upon her at a promotional event at Waitematā Station in downtown Auckland.
On election night, he had crew members stationed at all the major party events, and took up his own spot with the Green Party.
Cheung admitted he was interested in presenting MMP electoral systems to audiences back home, suggesting it as a potential replacement for America’s thorny, controversial and incredibly complicated first-past-the-post (FPP) system, which often swings back and forth between the Democrats and the Republicans and leaves little room for minor parties.
He believed winner-take-all elections were no longer the right fit for American elections, pointing at redistricting battles, the end of the Voting Rights Act, and the current administration as reasons why.
“We've never had a deep discussion about whether the British first-past-the-post system still fits us,” he said. “We've just accepted it as a given and never really had an opportunity to say, ‘If we were to start from scratch, what electoral system would we actually pick?’”
Cheung picked the perfect election to showcase MMP, warts and all. After multiple strategies to engineer an overhang, an open letter has been signed by some of the country's leading constitutional experts calling for a select committee inquiry into reform.
When Cheung spoke to us, he had spent several days in Rotorua, “going deep on the Treaty of Waitangi, and spending time on a marae”. He was on his way to Wellington, and had pulled over for a break to take in the sights at Tongariro National Park.
Cheung’s coverage of the New Zealand election will result in a full-length podcast series and a YouTube documentary, but it may take months to see the light of day – potentially even longer than normal because we won’t know the outcome for quite some time.
Asked for his prediction about which way things might swing once the special votes were counted, Cheung would only say that he wished he could stick around for longer to see how it plays out for himself. “Sadly, we cannot stay forever,” he said, “as much as some of us would like to”.
Chris Schulz
Chris Schulz is a contributing writer at The Spinoff. He's an award-winning journalist from Tāmaki Makaurau who has spent 25 years working for local publications. His specialties include live events, pop culture, infrastructure and Aotearoa music.