Wayne Brown said democracy has had its day, so the US ambassador called him a boomer

19 Nov 2026
Politics
Henry (2250 x 1350 px) - 33

Ok, comrade (Design: The Spinoff)

Wayne Brown’s remarks after a China trip have drawn sharp responses from the US ambassador and his own councillors, Henry Oliver writes in today’s excerpt from The Bulletin.

To receive The Bulletin in full each weekday, sign up here.

Two days ago, in an interview with Stuff’s Zane Small, Auckland mayor Wayne Brown said he was in China while the election played out and couldn’t make sense of what was happening at home. He pointed to the US midterms and said Europe hadn’t had a good election in years. China, he argued, has centrally managed capitalism that lets companies fail. Democracy, he said, “had its day”. 

And if that wasn’t enough, yesterday The Post’s Jonathan Killick reported that in a separate interview with Chinese state media he also suggested New Zealand sell its Five Eyes seat to Japan.

By yesterday morning, Brown’s pro-China position had softened somewhat. Brown told the Herald’s Lane Nichols that his target wasn’t democracy as a whole, just New Zealand’s version of democracy, which he said had been “gamed”. He said he wasn’t proposing a massive change to how we elect people, only that we copy what works. He told RNZ’s Morning Report that MMP is “not working well” and it’s time to try something else. He told The Post he was simply “speaking to the fact that MMP isn’t perfect”.

Comrade Brown?

Brown’s own councillors weren’t buying the clarification. The Post reports that Albany councillor John Watson asked what had turned the mayor into a cheerleader for Beijing, saying “all that’s missing is his pom-poms.” Watson went on to ask whether Brown’s position had been compromised, and whether ratepayers should fund any more China trips.

Brown rejected the suggestion, telling The Post the idea he’d been captured was laughable and xenophobic. “China is one of New Zealand’s largest trading partners, and it’s usual for me, as the mayor of our largest city, to visit our sister cities over there,” he said, promising a full report on the trip, with costings and an itinerary, by the end of the month. Manurewa-Papakura’s Daniel Newman said he’d clearly enjoyed the trip too much. Alf Filipaina and Shane Henderson both defended democracy, with Henderson noting it’s how he got his job.

(As an aside: I’d love to link here to Hayden Donnell’s 2023 article for Metro which inspired this cover picturing the mayor in the iconic style of Che Guevara, but unfortunately the website is down so all links are broken.)

‘Ok, Boomer!’

US ambassador Jared Novelly was blunter. As reported by Stuff, his statement opened with a “boomer” jab at Brown’s age, then suggested the mayor lacked the intelligence for an intelligence briefing. It also likened democracy to Auckland traffic: messy, but nobody wants to scrap the lights.

Novelly told Stuff that Brown owed an apology to the US, New Zealanders, Five Eyes partners and Japan, and should “start by apologising to the Age of Enlightenment”. He said he had no problem being called undiplomatic, as he comes from a business background. Stuff pointed out to Novelly that Brown, 80, is two months younger than Donald Trump, to which he replied he did not think Trump would be offended by the name: “I don't think it's an offensive term. I think it basically is segmenting that you were born at a particular time.”

Fair response, wrong channel?

As reported by RNZ this morning, Waikato University’s Al Gillespie, an international law expert, said there was merit in Novelly’s criticism and that it was fair. But an ambassador speaks for his country, he said, so the complaint should have gone through diplomatic channels. 

Gillespie said both US and Chinese ambassadors are increasingly willing to enter into New Zealand’s domestic affairs, and that we expect the same restraint we show others, citing the sacking of Phil Goff as high commissioner in London, over comments about Trump, as proof New Zealand takes its own obligations seriously. “We (New Zealand) try very hard not to say undue things about other countries when New Zealand's got interests, that would be offensive, or interfere and we just need the same respect.”

Henry Oliver

Henry Oliver

Henry Oliver writes The Bulletin. He was previously The Spinoff's music editor, the editor of Metro, a bar owner, intellectual property lawyer, and bass player.

More about Henry Oliver
Keep going