Surprise! The High Court finds pay equity amendment discriminated against women

20 Nov 2026
Politics
Uploaded Image

‘A historic victory for union members and women everywhere.’ (Design: Archi Banal/The Spinoff)

The High Court has declared the Government’s 2025 amendment of the Equal Pay Act inconsistent with the Bill of Rights, finding it discriminated against women and was driven principally by a desire to save money, Henry Oliver writes in today’s excerpt from The Bulletin.

To receive The Bulletin in full each weekday, sign up here.

The High Court has ruled that the government acted unlawfully when it amended the Equal Pay Act last year, finding the changes discriminated against women, breaching the Bill of Rights Act, and were motivated mainly by a wish to save money rather than to fix a system that was failing. Justice Paul Radich’s declaration, released yesterday and reported by the Herald’s Ethan Manera, follows a challenge brought by unions representing teachers, nurses, public servants and other educators.

The amendments, passed under urgency in May 2025, ended 33 live pay equity claims covering about 180,000 workers – most of them women in female-dominated sectors including care, disability, education, health and social services. They also made it harder, and in some cases impossible, for similar claims to be brought in future. (For an explainer in video form, watch this from Now You Know.) The government claims the changes saved an estimated $12.8 billion over four years. (If you want to know more about how the amendments came about, read Kirsty Johnston’s RNZ report from March.)

The Herald reports the judgment found “nothing tangible in the relevant materials to support the proposition that the previous system was not working as it should”, and that “the documents, viewed as a whole, show that the main driver was fiscal.” Less discriminatory ways of achieving the savings existed, the court found. 

But, it’s important to note, the ruling does not invalidate the law or restore the claims. And the government could still appeal.

What happens now?

Workplace relations minister Brooke van Velden, who led the reforms, told The Post’s Harriet Laughton that the decision on an appeal rests with the attorney-general. Attorney-general Chris Bishop, finance minister Nicola Willis and the prime minister’s office all deferred to Van Velden (all three are technically no longer MPs but are acting in caretaker roles) who noted the government is operating in caretaker mode, so must consult the opposition before major decisions.

A Labour spokesperson said the party would not agree to any appeal. Labour has committed to passing pay equity legislation within 100 days of taking office, with a first settlement for care and support workers by next year’s budget. The Opportunity Party (which, I assume, will be hearing a lot from both National and Labour) said it campaigned on restoring the original scheme.

Van Velden said officials were considering the judgment carefully and that she was limited in what she could say. “This government is committed to a well-functioning pay equity regime,” she said. “We didn’t think the previous legislative regime got the settings right.” She said claims could still be identified and addressed under the current law.

‘An indictment’

Professor Marilyn Waring, who chaired the “People’s Select Committee on Pay Equity”, set up to hear submissions which were denied a hearing due to the amendments, told RNZ the issue would be an issue for incoming MPs on two fronts: the declaration of inconsistency requires a parliamentary debate, and a petition held over pending the court case must now be dealt with.

Under the procedure Waring outlined, if there is no appeal the attorney-general must report the declaration to parliament within six days. It would then go to a select committee, which may call for submissions, followed by a general debate and an official Government response within six months.

Waring called the ruling “an indictment” of the government. “It’s been such a clear decision that this was all about the money, and money that was not saved anyway,” she said. She also drew a link to workforce pressures: “You can't talk on one side about having to have strategic plans around, for example a health workforce, when two-thirds of all your rest home workers are migrants.”

‘A historic victory’

Lisa Marriner, an aged care health care assistant and NZNO delegate, told RNZ the decision vindicated workers whose claims were cancelled without notice. She wants the next government to reinstate the former system and consider compensation: “A lot of the preparatory work for our claim had already been done before all the 33 claims were cancelled.” Plunket nurse Hannah Cook said the union had tested the replacement law by raising claims for Plunket, Hospice and Bupa nurses, only for Health New Zealand to block them.

PSA national secretary Fleur Fitzsimons called it a “ground-breaking historic decision” and said the next Government must restore “real pay equity legislation, and the pay equity claims as a priority”.

PPTA president Chris Abercrombie said Luxon (who, at the time, said arguments against the reforms were “disingenuous” and “scaremongering”) owed women an apology, and that any party seeking to govern must take the judgment seriously. TEU national secretary Amy Ross said it validated what unions had argued since the changes: “This is a historic victory for union members and women everywhere.”

Henry Oliver

Henry Oliver

Henry Oliver writes The Bulletin. He was previously The Spinoff's music editor, the editor of Metro, a bar owner, intellectual property lawyer, and bass player.

More about Henry Oliver
Keep going