Guyon Espiner on TVNZ ditching an ‘utterly vital role in New Zealand's democracy’
'Flabbergasted': Guyon Espiner on At Large with Toby Manhire.
The political editor position is critical, says someone who held it for six years.
“I was stunned. I nearly fell off my chair.”
That was the reaction of Guyon Espiner, upon reading today’s news that TVNZ is proposing to disestablish the role of political editor.
Espiner, who worked for the state-owned broadcaster in the position – one of the most senior journalistic jobs in the country – for six years from 2006, said he was “flabbergasted” at the thought that such a “pivotal and critical role in New Zealand journalism” might be axed.
Shayne Currie reported today that changes proposed for the TVNZ newsroom included scrapping both the Indepth news team and the political editor position. TVNZ did not respond to questions about the political editor role from the Herald, with a spokesperson saying: “We’re seeking feedback so won’t be commenting on the details of the proposal.”
The role has been empty since May, when Maiki Sherman resigned, saying her position was “untenable”.
Political coverage in the election campaign was shared between Jack Tame and Tova O’Brien in Auckland and the parliamentary press gallery team of Benedict Collins, Tom Day and Sophie Trigger, but the expectation – including in the newsroom – was that an appointment would follow shortly afterwards.
As well as Espiner and Sherman, the political editor honours board at TVNZ includes Richard Harman, Linda Clark, Mark Sainsbury, Corin Dann and Jessica Mutch-McKay.
The role is a critical and multi-faceted one, said Espiner. “You are the chief political correspondent, commentator, political expert, voice of the political coverage. It's a role where not only are you live on television most nights, explaining and analysing what has happened, you are also overseeing and editing the work of the other staff,” he said.
“You’re a sort of managing director, I suppose, in some way. You oversee all the political coverage, you commission the polls and and grapple with that data … You deploy your staff to whatever political conferences or meetings are going on and decide what to cover and how to cover it.”
The breadth of the job is huge. “You deal with the incoming calls from the prime minister at quarter to six when you're wandering out to the forecourt of parliament, complaining that this simply isn't a story, and try to bat that away.”
The political editor also provided a "buffer" between political leaders who were "bugging you all the time" and the wider TVNZ organisation. It makes for “an incredibly all-consuming role”, he said, “and, I think, an utterly vital role in New Zealand's democracy, actually".
“The idea that you wouldn't have that sort of role? I'm still trying to get my head around it.”
'The main feeling was shock'
In today’s At Large episode, Espiner also discusses the impact of last week’s bombshell news about RNZ, where he has worked for the last 12 years as an investigative journalist and host of some of its biggest programmes.
The revelations of an $11.8m deficit, incurred across several parts of the organisation, and the dozens of job losses it will deliver, had been explosive and painful, he said.
“The main feeling was shock. I mean, we had heard rumours. We obviously knew that the chief financial officer had resigned suddenly, and there was a bit of news sort of leeching out that there were some IEDs on the road there, but not at the scale that was revealed.”
Asked which questions RNZ employees would be looking to be answered by the independent review that has been promised, Espiner said: “How were those things missed? How did the board miss it? How did the audit and risk committee miss it? How did the senior management miss those things? I think those are the key questions that you keep hearing around the corridors at RNZ. How how did this happen?”
Morale had been “pretty strong at RNZ recently”, he said. “I hope that can hold, and that optimism can hold while this thing is sorted through. But when you see a story like this develop, you do wonder where it's going to lead. There's no doubt it's taken a hit on morale. There's been shock. And now, anxiety about where job cuts are going to fall.”
Toby Manhire
Toby Manhire is editor-at-large at The Spinoff. He loves to cast a pod, whether it's Gone By Lunchtime, At Large or Juggernaut. He is a former editor of The Spinoff and has worked as a journalist in NZ and the UK since the last millennium.