Who is the captain of the coalition, really?

19 Nov 2026
Opinion
Politics
WAITANGI, NEW ZEALAND FEBRUARY 5: Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, Winston Peters and David Seymour. Powhiri for parliamentarians at the Upper Treaty Grounds during the Waitangi 2026 commemorations, Waitangi, New Zealand on February 5, 2026. (Photo by Jason Dorday/New Zealand Herald via Getty Images)

Christopher Luxon, Winston Peters and David Seymour at Waitangi, 2026. (Photo: Jason Dorday/New Zealand Herald via Getty Images)

When Luxon is agreeing to disagree with his own government, something is seriously topsy-turvy.

New Zealand’s “agree to disagree” provision is a child of MMP, created so that parties in coalition governments can, exceptionally, stake out their differences when decisions need to be made that aren’t covered by their negotiated agreements. 

In practice, it means that a smaller party can assert their identity and values across the term, rather than getting swallowed up in the uniformity that cabinet collective responsibility demands. They can say: we don’t like this thing, and we’d like it to be known that we don’t like this thing, but we’re not going to collapse the government over it. 

What it is not designed for is the lead party of government. It is not a tool that you’d expect to see, say, the prime minister – the literal head of government – reach for. 

And yet, based on official information revealed by Stuff yesterday, that is what Christopher Luxon looks to have done, just outside the formality of cabinet. When Winston Peters insisted, in defiance of the advice from Foreign Affairs officials and National MPs, that New Zealand should abstain on a vote at the UN on a pandemic preparedness plan, the prime minister’s response was – according to Peters’ senior foreign affairs adviser – essentially to invoke that provision. 

The associate minister of health, Matt Doocey, and the prime minister’s office had, the adviser wrote in an email to the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, “indicated that while they accept Minister Peters’ prerogative to instruct MFAT to issue these voting instructions, National ministers hold a different view on how we should bе voting. That is, their preference would have been for a yes vote with an explanation of vote.”

He continued: “Accordingly, if this comes to a vote, then Minister Doocey / PMO would intend to make clear publicly that they argued for a different outcome should media approach them for comment. National has, in effect, agreed to disagree with the approach the MFA is taking to this issue.”

An adviser in Doocey’s office confirmed that, writing: “For completeness, National ministers have a different view and continue to support New Zealand voting in favour of the Declaration.”

This is remarkable. Topsy-turvy. At the UN, New Zealand swam against the tide of 153 countries that supported the non-binding pandemic plan, which emerged following the Covid crisis. Contrary to MFAT advice we stood alongside Paraguay in abstaining, while the US, Argentina and Israel voted against.

Peters had heard the counsel of his ministry officials – that abstaining would not be consistent with our stance on global health and foreign policy, and “would likely be interpreted as reduced support for international efforts on pandemic preparedness”. He was all about “sovereign decision making”, however. And he no doubt knew, too, that the vote was taking place during an election campaign in which he was actively courting the anti-vaxx constituency.

The prime minister didn’t want our vote to go that way. Nor did his fellow National ministers. So they agreed to disagree with their own government’s policy, as determined by Winston Peters. It was described at the time as a “captain’s call”, which is a deceptively devastating shorthand, when you think about what the word captain means.  

Luxon shrugged it off. “Really, it’s a decision for him as foreign minister and you’d have to ask him,” he told media, bizarrely. But really (really), it would have been uncomplicated for the prime minister to grab the issue by the collar, require that it be put to cabinet, set out his position (did I mention already that he is the prime minister?) and invite New Zealand First to, you know, invoke agree-to-disagree, should they so wish. 

Were this a lone example of dysfunction between the prime minister and foreign minister then it might be as inconsequential as Luxon would have us believe. But it fits a wider pattern across the term.

There was the decision not to recognise Palestinian statehood, which had every appearance of being a Winston Peters decision that Christopher Luxon muddled along with.

Then there was the US war on Iran, where Luxon’s approach was something more like agree-to-disintegrate. After Peters’ office released materials documenting the lead-up to the government stating its position, Luxon issued a statement that was uncharacteristically emphatic, condemning Peters for “putting politics ahead of the national interest”.

Peters’ response? “I understand international affairs. The prime minister's still in training wheels. That's what I say to that statement.” He told The Spinoff during the campaign: “The reason why those materials [emerged] was because the public was being misadvised as to the truth of the matter. And I wasn't going to stand back while the truth was somewhere else and it was in the documents.” 

The documents had suggested that Luxon wanted to echo Australian and Canadian positions by supporting – rather than "acknowledging" – the US actions. Asked during the campaign whether such a version of events was "completely a hoax", Luxon said: "Absolutely." When asked whether he had ever supported the US attacks on Iran, "even a little bit at the start", he answered, "no, never."

That may not be the end of it. "Against the record of history coming," Peters told The Spinoff last month, "we'll find out who is telling the truth or not."

Luxon’s challenges in achieving coalition discipline hardly need retreading. Think butter chicken tsunamis, kneepads, and Peters’ verbal assault on Lawrence Xu-Nan, which almost everyone condemned as racist. But if you thought the term just gone was the peak achievable level of a prime minister flailing in attempts to exert authority over his coalition partners, well, hold my Pepsi Max. Should the coalition return to power, as preliminary results suggest is likely, it will be with both New Zealand First and Act as stronger components. 

David Seymour, plainly infuriated at a sense of haughtiness on National’s part in, for example, ruling him out as finance minister, is already gearing up to wield a stronger hand. Voters had sent a message that “they want Act and New Zealand First to play a larger role and perhaps National to be a bit more of a team player this time”, he told Newstalk ZB. “And we'll certainly be making that point in negotiations.”

Today, Winston Peters is in Manila at the East Asia Summit, a caretaker foreign minister seemingly set on taking the job proper again. Christopher Luxon is in Shenzhen for Apec, as caretaker prime minister, keen to press the flesh with other leaders (and disavow any knowledge of Wayne Brown). But is Luxon the boss of Peters, or is it the other way around?

Toby Manhire

Toby Manhire

Toby Manhire is editor-at-large at The Spinoff. He loves to cast a pod, whether it's Gone By Lunchtime, At Large or Juggernaut. He is a former editor of The Spinoff and has worked as a journalist in NZ and the UK since the last millennium.

More about Toby Manhire
Keep going