The BulletinOctober 3, 2019

The Bulletin: Early childhood teachers fed up with low pay


Good morning, and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: Early childhood educators plan action to raise pay, many councils reporting low election turnout, and Defence Industry forum cancelled.

A new phase of industrial action in the education sector looms, with early childhood teachers calling for a huge pay jolt. Radio NZ reports it was one of the major outcomes of the NZEI union conference held over the course of this week. The immediate demand was for an 11% pay rise, aimed at closing the gap with kindergarten and primary school teachers, which Stuff reports has started to blow out particularly with kindergarten teachers. And they’re not going to be quiet about it either – a week of action is planned for November to highlight the issue.

The situation for early childhood teachers is very different to that of the primary and secondary teachers who went on strike this year. Both the latter two workforces are heavily unionised, while among early childhood teachers union membership rates are very low – about 4,000 out of a workforce of 30,000. As well as that, they’re employed independently of the government, which means those not covered by a collective agreement have a much more difficult time of negotiating with their employer. The union says that a better collective agreement for early childhood teachers would set a minimum pay rate for the industry, and have launched a website aimed at bringing in the voices of those who aren’t unionised.

For all of this to happen, much more government funding would have to be put towards subsidising Early Childhood Education. Stuff reports minister Chris Hipkins has been front-footing this, saying at the start of the week that raising ECE pay was his “top priority” going into the next Budget, so it is almost certain there will be some increase on the way. Such a move would fit very neatly with the government’s wider wellbeing framework, because of the importance of the earliest years of a kid’s life in their future development. But the total cost of bringing early childhood teachers up to parity with kindergarten teachers has been estimated at $1.7 billion, and it’s hard to imagine that sort of money could be found. If it isn’t, the response from a workforce that feels undervalued could be one of absolute fury.

Just quickly, a brief word from Duncan Greive, managing editor of The Spinoff:

“Like most media companies, we’re operating in a deeply challenging market. Google and Facebook own digital advertising in New Zealand, and while we are blessed with some great commercial partners, we rely on our readers to help fund our journalism. So if you love The Bulletin, and want to support it and The Spinoff, please join The Spinoff Members. You can pay what you like, but for just $8 a month you’ll also get a FREE copy of our first book, out in a month. Every member makes a huge difference to our scope and viability. Thanks for your time, and support.”

Lots of councils around the country are reporting lower turnout in local elections, compared to the same time last election. The Wairarapa Times-Age reports it’s happening in their patch, as does the Manawatū Standard in Palmerston North, and the NZ Herald in Auckland. It isn’t yet known if this is simply because of less regular postal services, or if turnout around the country genuinely will be lower than 2016. Just in case, here’s a reminder about how you, yes you reading this right now, can get your vote in on time.

The Defence Industry Association forum (also known by critics as the Weapons Expo) has been canned this year, reports Radio NZ. In part, the cancellation was blamed on protesters, who were particularly prominent in Palmerston North last year. Protesters say they’re thrilled with the outcome, while the DIA says they’ll instead be heading to smaller, more targeted events.

Hundreds of staff at the University of Auckland have signed a letter denouncing a lack of action against white supremacist posters on campus, reports The Spinoff. They say the posters are at odds with both Te Tiriti, and human decency. Vice-chancellor Stuart McCutcheon has defended his handling of the incident, saying that he was trying to balance rights of free speech “and the rights of people not to be upset by things.” The full letter can be read here.

Youths, take note: You’re running the risk of losing your hearing by listening to headphones too loud. Newshub have reported that more than a third of Year 9s in New Zealand have abnormal hearing, with many of them listening to music at volumes that exceeds World Health Organisation recommendations. The alarming stats haven’t previously been widely known about, because compulsory screening for hearing loss only happens for pre-schoolers.

But seriously youths, take note of the name ACN, and be very very wary of it. Reporting for The Spinoff, Cameron Wilkinson reports it’s the newest multi-level marketing scam to hit these shores, promising naive people a world of independence and riches, and then trapping them into a business model in which there’s basically no chance of enriching anyone but ACN’s bosses. Keep an eye out for your friends as well, lest they be sucked in.

Here’s two very interesting pieces to share from some of the local government blogs I like to follow. The first is from The Traffic Jam, based in Wellington, which has quite literally gone through every transport vote undertaken by the City Council over the last term and counted who voted for more pro-car policies, and who didn’t. And the second is from Greater Auckland, and is a tribute to the work of departing General Manager of the Auckland Design Office Ludo Campbell-Reid. Including the pieces here isn’t necessarily an endorsement of the points made – rather what I want to do is highlight the fine work of these sites in keeping an eye on those who work for the public.

The Bulletin is The Spinoff’s acclaimed, free daily curated digest of all the most important stories from around New Zealand delivered directly to your inbox each morning.

Sign up now


Right now on The Spinoff: Tina Ngata has looked at the ‘Doctrine of Discovery’, and how it lead to the dispossession and oppression of indigenous people around the world. National’s Todd McClay argues that the withdrawal of Jetstar from several regions shows why business confidence matters. Alice Neville writes about a partnership between food producers and The Aunties to deliver food to families affected by domestic violence. Toby Morris draws about the Spend My Super campaign, encouraging well-off retirees to donate money if they don’t need it.

And Hayden Donnell is coming close to the end of his long odyssey through the ocean of local government elections. The strain is really showing in this piece about a wild ratepayer focused meeting in Auckland. But there are faint hints of something almost like hope in this profile of Louise Hutt, a 26 year old mayoral candidate trying to reshape Hamilton’s local politics. Keep going Hayden, you’re almost there.

For a feature today, an in-depth look at the country’s pest control goals, and the immense amount of work that will be required to achieve them. The NZ Herald’s science reporter Jamie Morton has looked ahead to the end-point of the Predator-Free 2050 programme, and found that surviving pockets of possums, stoats and rats have the potential to spread again very quickly if the programme ever relents. But as this excerpt shows, getting rid of those last pockets will be hugely expensive and require innovative thinking:

In a world-first approach, Jones and his team plan to hone in on what makes some pest animals resistant to current control methods, so they can develop new technology to beat them.

Animal personality, he explained, was emerging as one of the most important concepts in behavioural ecology.

“This programme will be the first application of personality in pest animal management,” he said.

Boxer Joseph Parker has been forced to pull out of an important bout with Derek Chisora, reports the NZ Herald. The reason given by Parker’s camp is illness, suspected to have been caused by a spider bite. They’re hoping to quickly get it rescheduled, because for Parker it could well be one of the last chances to move himself back into real contention for a title fight. He has only fought once this year, after his career trajectory was thrown off by losses to Anthony Joshua and Dillian Whyte.

And unsurprisingly, the All Blacks beat Canada last night. Here’s the highlights – there were some cool tries at least. Also, all three Barrett brothers crossed the line, which is something you’ll definitely need to remember for pub quizzes in the coming years.

That’s it for The Bulletin. If you liked what you read, and know other people who would find it useful, pass on this signup form to them. And if you want to support the work we do at The Spinoff, please check out our membership programme.

Want to read The Bulletin in full? Click here to subscribe and join over 36,000 New Zealanders who start each weekday with the biggest stories in politics, business, media and culture.  

The Bulletin is made possible by Z Energy, proudly supporting local news that matters.

 Check out how they’re delivering New Zealand an alternative fuel future.

Mad Chapman, Editor
Aotearoa continues to adapt to a new reality and The Spinoff is right there, sorting fact from fiction to bring you the latest updates and biggest stories. Help us continue this coverage, and so much more, by supporting The Spinoff Members.Madeleine Chapman, EditorJoin Members

Get The Spinoff
in your inbox