spinofflive
New World
New World Thorndon staff say life in the Wellington supermarket is stressful. (Photo: Getty Images; additional design by Tina Tiller)

BusinessFebruary 22, 2022

Supermarket staff on serving protesters: ‘It’s scary … I just don’t want to go in there’

New World
New World Thorndon staff say life in the Wellington supermarket is stressful. (Photo: Getty Images; additional design by Tina Tiller)

As maskless, likely unvaccinated protesters swarm their store, New World Thorndon staff say they’re scared and not being supported by management.

A few days after the parliamentary protests began, Carrie* arrived at New World Thorndon to begin her work day. Once there, she was given the task of door duty, whereby staff stand at the front entrance and check customers adhere to the store’s Covid-19 policies. She’s young, employed part-time, is immunosuppressed and suffers from asthma. Getting Covid-19 would not be good for her. “I’m likely to be hospitalised if I get it,” she says.

Yet, with the supermarket just a five-minute walk from the Beehive, protesters gathered at parliament have quickly become regulars, using their nearest supermarket to stock up on supplies and alcohol. With omicron case numbers rising, working door duty puts Carrie in close proximity to unmasked, potentially unvaccinated people. “It’s nerve-racking,” she says. “I’m not the most anxious person [but] this definitely makes me anxious.”

Tension has been high at Thorndon New World since the protests began two weeks ago. Two staff members with customer-facing roles told The Spinoff protesters arrive at the supermarket to shop in groups of three or more, and can be loud and aggressive. Anger also comes from masked customers who want to know why unmasked protesters are being allowed to shop alongside them. Shoppers confront staff and each other, at checkouts and in the aisles, debating mask rules, vaccine statuses and exemptions.

Confusion over the rules hasn’t been cleared up by store management, those staff members claim. Both say communication has been lacking. For Carrie, it affects her ability to do her job. “I had no idea whether or not I was supposed to force people to wear masks, or force them to show me an exemption, because I’ve heard so many different things,” she says. “When I did ask someone for an exemption and they got angry at me, the workplace was like, ‘Yeah, you weren’t meant to ask them that, you’re not meant to press on about it.’”

New World Thorndown is a few hundred metres up the road from parliament (Photo: Google Streetv View)

Emma Wooster, Foodstuffs’ Corporate Affairs Manager, called it a “horrible and stressful situation”. In a statement, she said store’s management were doing “absolutely everything within their control” to manage recent escalations in abuse. “While the full-time security on the door at New World Thorndon are present at all times and doing all within their control, it’s still distressing for our team members and regular customers to witness, or be around this unacceptable behaviour.”

Wooster said denying protesters entry to the store was against Ministry of Health guidelines. “One of the biggest challenges is our teams, or external security staff, can ask customers if they’re able to wear a mask, but in line with MoH guidelines we have to accept claimed exemptions at face value without verification,” she said. “We absolutely accept there are some customers who’re legitimately exempt, and they need to shop safely too. ”

Despite the presence of security, Carrie says any staff member can be asked to have a turn on the door. She remembers a conversation with two co-workers, aged 16 and 17, who told her: “I don’t like being put on the door. It’s scary.” Without advice from management, Carrie says she’s developed her own techniques to de-escalate interactions with protesters angry at being asked to wear a mask. “I don’t give into it. I don’t feed into it. I calmly talk to them. I try not to let people know I’m against the protests because it’s not worth it. You don’t know when you give your opinion if they’re going to flip out on you.”

Sometimes, though, those situations get out of hand. When two protesters told her, “Take off your mask – I want to see your pretty smile,” she immediately moved to stand closer to co-workers. Speaking an hour before her next shift, Carrie is hesitant about returning to the supermarket, and has considered quitting. On her previous shift, she’d been “bombarded by a few nasty people” and felt drained afterwards. “I literally just wanted to cry when I got home,” she says. “This is the first shift that I’m dreading. It’s scary … I just don’t want to go in there.”

Protesters from the parliament occupation have become regulars at the supermarket (Photo: Birgit Krippner/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

Craig* also used to look forward to going to work. “Now it’s just more of this crap. It’s just another day of people without masks coming in and me being yelled at by people with masks thinking that they shouldn’t be allowed to break the rules,” he says. “We are the ones that get the brunt of it … we are the ones that have to deal with people going batshit crazy at us.”

Like Carrie, he blames management for refusing to enforce the store’s mask policy. New World Thorndon’s hired guards, hired after the protest began, are toothless, he says. “Security is … asking people to wear a mask and sanitise, but that’s all they can do. If someone says, ‘No,’ they can ask to see an exemption. More often than not, people go, ‘No, don’t have one,’ and walk into the store. At that point, they can’t do anything to stop them. The majority of security I’ve spoken to don’t know why they’re there.” 

That means staff are being blamed for the store’s policy. “The confrontation I had with a customer the other day was him basically arguing that it’s not right. I told him, ‘Sorry sir, there’s nothing I can do.’ He said, ‘Yes there is, there’s a mask mandate, kick them out.’ I said, ‘I can’t do that.’ He cut me off and said: ‘Yes there is. Do it.’ I’m getting blamed personally for not doing anything about it.”

New World Thorndon isn’t the only business struggling with fallout from the ongoing anti-mandate protest. Down the road, the Backbencher pub across from parliament has been forced to close, while the owner of another small business told RNZ turnover had dropped drastically since protesters arrived. Rahaul Arona, the owner of vape store Shosha, told Stuff he felt intimidated by protesters entering his store.“They were asking: ‘Why are you wearing a mask? Why did you get the vaccine?'”

At New World, more complaints seem to be coming from masked shoppers over the maskless protesters. “They’re the ones following the rules and they see other people not following the rules. They are understandably upset and they take it out on us,” Craig says. Dealing with that tension all day is exhausting. When he’s addressed his concerns with management, he’s been told to ask a manager for help when it happens. In the heat of an argument, there’s no time. “They want to yell at you there and then.” 

Craig’s accepted that going into work as the protest continues to gather steam means he’s likely to be exposed to Covid-19. “I’m genuinely expecting I’ll probably get it any time soon,” he says. His coping method? “When I get home I have a shower and a very big drink.” He knows it isn’t healthy, but it’s his way to forget about the events of the day. “I don’t think of work or the people there or the stuff I have to deal with. It’s my solitude from potentially getting sick for two weeks or having my co-workers laid up in bed because some dickhead couldn’t put on a mask for 10 minutes while they’re in a supermarket.”

*Names have been changed and identifying details withheld to protect privacy.

Keep going!
a mock up of a house with slightly mottled plastic walls
SaveBoard cladding lines the interior of Zero Waste Bistro in New York City – one of the many companies trying to address plastic waste (Photo: Supplied; additional design: Tina Tiller)

BusinessFebruary 20, 2022

The Hamilton startup transforming coffee cups and soft plastics into gib board

a mock up of a house with slightly mottled plastic walls
SaveBoard cladding lines the interior of Zero Waste Bistro in New York City – one of the many companies trying to address plastic waste (Photo: Supplied; additional design: Tina Tiller)

SaveBoard has the backing of a major logistics company and is selling into a market short on in-demand building supplies. But even its CEO says the low-carbon building materials startup can’t save the industry.

For the last 10 weeks, every two-and-a-half minutes a factory in the Hamilton suburb of Te Rapa has been churning out building materials made from the sorts of plastic waste that our food, drinks, packages and mail come in.

Operating a working week of five eight-hour days at the start of late 2020, production in January ramped up to three 24-hour days a week. But SaveBoard hasn’t gone “full throttle straightaway”, says chief executive Paul Charteris; current output is half the factory’s 200,000-board capacity. “It’s a balancing act, matching production with demand. We’re getting close.”

It can’t have come at a better time. The building materials manufacturer produces a low-carbon alternative to plasterboard, more commonly known in Aotearoa as gib board. It’s a product in hot demand, yet supply is strained. Last week, Winstone Wallboards, New Zealand’s only manufacturer and largest marketer of gib plasterboard, announced a freeze on all new orders for July 2022 deliveries onwards. Instead, gib will be made available through an “allocation model”. A backlog of orders, and the resultant longer lead times, caused by last year’s lockdown was the explanation.

Even if SaveBoard were to reach full capacity, transforming 4,000 tonnes of plastic waste, it would occupy only about 2% of a market dominated by Winstone’s 94% market share. Still, the global pandemic has wreaked havoc with global supply chains, shipping costs and building materials, and SaveBoard is benefiting from the disruption. The company has been contacted daily by builders, developers and homeowners eager for alternative wall-lining products, says Charteris. While the startup is helping relieve some stress, it won’t be much, he concedes. “We can probably do about 600 houses a year but there’s 40,000-plus consented at the moment. We can’t save the building industry, but we can add capacity that doesn’t exist.”

SaveBoard CEO Paul Charteris (Photo: Supplied)

SaveBoard may be a minnow but it’s got some serious backing from food packaging manufacturer Tetra Pak, sustainability and landfill solutions consultancy Closed Loop and logistics company Freightways. That last investor, Freightways, might raise an eyebrow – it’s perhaps best known for the portfolio of package and mail businesses it owns, including flagship courier brand New Zealand Couriers, with its red and yellow livery and lightning bolt logo. So why would it care about building materials? It turns out that for about 15 years, Freightways has traded at the edge of the waste industry – secure document destruction, e-waste recycling and even the disposal of medical waste.

Now it’s turned its eye to plastic. After all, coffee cups and discarded milk cartons still need to be picked up, processed and delivered before they are shredded and turned into plasterboard, says Freightways chief executive Mark Troughear. “The idea that you can build something 100% out of rubbish, here in Aotearoa, and get it into the hands of customers – we’ve had a massive amount of interest. About 300 potential customers have approached us since the initiative has been up and running.”

Initial interest might be there but part of the difficulty that upcycled building materials face is wider market acceptance; their success or failure depends on effective marketing against tried and tested products. Consumers do prefer low-carbon products as long as they’re cost-competitive with traditional materials, says Graham Burke, an executive director of the New Zealand Construction Industry Council (NZCIC), the peak association made up of bodies representing everyone involved in constructing a building. And if all else is equal and supply can comfortably satisfy demand, success wouldn’t be too hard to achieve. But: “If the client doesn’t want the product and designers aren’t going to specify it, then construction businesses can’t incorporate them.”

It’s a hard sell, and SaveBoard has anticipated the task. Under a heading entitled “Not perfect”, its website reads: “If you are seeking perfection, then SaveBoard is not for you. Use a brand-new product that hasn’t been used to give you a flawless finish or look.” Even its CEO notes the product has a “natural texture” compared with gib’s “perfect flat finish”. Burke says New Zealanders are accustomed to clean, “monolithic” interior finishes and some short-term resistance to products that have lines, creases, press marks and veins in the finished surface is expected. On the other hand, when it comes to building roofs, the ability of substrate board to help drain away water and remain durable is far more important than aesthetics. It may prove to be easier for SaveBoard to find customers for its roofing substrate product.

Similar technology in the US has more than a decade of use, including by electric vehicles manufacturer Tesla for the membrane roof substrate of its giant 200,000-square-metre “Gigafactory 1” plant in Nevada. Some 336,000kg of embodied carbon emissions were saved compared with substrate made from plywood. But SaveBoard isn’t a silver bullet, and Charteris recognises as much. A hundred more companies doing innovative work in different areas are needed to make a real difference, he says. “We’re still a drop in the ocean relative to the amount of waste.”

Shredded plastic waste is upcycled into construction board (Photo: Supplied)

About 252,000 tonnes of plastic waste, or 8%, is dumped in landfills every year. Building a house and demolishing a building is more wasteful, with that waste making up between 40% and 50% of rubbish tips. At least half of it could be diverted if it was sorted though. As for greenhouse gas emissions, buildings are directly and indirectly responsible for up to a fifth of New Zealand’s emissions. Globally, construction makes up a third of the world’s overall waste, built from roughly half of the 100 billion tonnes of raw material extracted from the planet.

SaveBoard claims its products are not only low-carbon (less than 90% compared with traditional materials) but zero water, glues, chemicals or formaldehydes are used in the upcycling process. There’s no “green premium” added to the price tag – the business says products cost about the same or below equivalent traditional materials. Bulk orders are cut to length, eliminating unnecessary waste, and the processing factory at Te Rapa can recycle any offcuts into future products.

That circularity appeals to NZCIC’s Burke, whose first impressions are positive. SaveBoard is the kind of innovative solution that’s needed to help Aotearoa reach net-zero carbon emissions by 2050, he says. Yet, while the building and construction sector is onboard with the government’s ambitious climate change goal, it’s in the early stages of acquiring the knowledge and skills to build low-carbon, energy-efficient buildings. And, at a granular level, builders are still trying to figure out “where they can add their bit”.

Andrew Eagles, the chief executive of the New Zealand Green Building Council (NZGBC), wants the country’s processes and structures to drive the construction of greener buildings. “For instance, maybe half your development contribution costs are reduced or there’s a faster consenting process,” he says. “If we’re intelligent, let’s flip things to reward people who are building better, lower-carbon homes and buildings.”

A boardroom kitted out with SaveBoard’s exposed internal lining (Photo: Supplied)

NZGBC is the leading sustainable building not-for-profit in Aotearoa, offering green construction standards “Green Star” for commercial buildings and “Homestar” for houses. Five years ago, 500 homes were being built consistent with the “Homestar” rating tool, a mark of quality assurance that measures a home’s performance and environmental impact – similar to the energy ratings that appear on washing machines. In the last six months, 5,000 homes have been built accordingly, and that number could multiply by 20 this year. Eagles says New Zealanders – from consumers to corporates like Countdown, Fisher & Paykel Healthcare and Genesis Energy – are increasingly demanding cleaner, greener buildings. “We may see a switch from green products being the norm and dropping the ‘green’ tag to non-green products being labelled as something like ‘grey’ products.”

For all the buzz that sustainability generates, SaveBoard’s Charteris is slowly going about the task of winning people over. The current heightened demand for plasterboard alternatives may make him nervous – “we could sell out tomorrow” – but short-term client satisfaction mustn’t be a one-off, he says. The startup wants enduring customer relationships – the kind that construct homes and buildings out of upcycled coffee cups, used beverage cartons and soft plastics.

But wait there's more!