TelevisionMade possible by

Does Sensing Murder have the corniest dramatic reconstructions on television?

Alex Casey compares the dramatic re-enactments of Sensing Murder to fellow bad creep show Celebrity Ghost Stories, to find the true winner in the art of the corny reconstruction.

The dramatic recreation remains the hokiest thing to ever grace the creepy TV genre from Sensing Murder to Celebrity Ghost Stories, consistently bad and funny no matter the crime or the ghost. Unfortunately, I fear they are a lost art, with the terrible return episode of Sensing Murder pouring top ghost dollar into the re-enactment department. How very dare they eschew the Dutch tilts and Wilhelm screams for this nice-looking situation.

Sure, slicker re-enactments means that the 1970s cat eye makeup looks absolutely killer, but I fear that dramatic recreations are losing their corny charm in this era of so-called peak TV, all fancy grading and Wes Anderson framing. I revisited old episodes of Sensing Murder and its spiritual descendant Celebrity Ghost Stories to find the top corn dog of the spooky recreation world.

I have broken down my judgement criteria into five essential elements, comparing this episode of Sensing Murder on the left with this episode of Celebrity Ghost Stories on the right.

1) PET ACTING

The cat of Sensing Murder vs the dog of Celebrity Ghost Stories is a battle for the ages. Look at this good dog in Celebrity Ghost Stories, standing stock still at the door when confronted with a ghost within Joan Rivers’ apartment. You can feel the fear. Likewise, the Sensing Murder cat does some exquisite stunt work when dropped from inside a dressing gown, and has cute eyes that legit look like buttons. Cat wins.

2) USE OF EERIE BLUE LIGHT

We all know that blue de ba de da be da is the colour of death, which is why these shows dial the blue cellophane up to 11 and cover every light in sight to create a moody, oceanic scene. I will award the Eiffel 65 award for Blue Commitment to Celebrity Ghost Stories for suggesting the moon is blue, and giving fake Joan Rivers a blue poncho to boot.

3) WIG USAGE

As good as Sensing Murder’s emo mop is, nothing is better than a blonde wig from Look Sharp chucked on a Joan Rivers impersonator. No amount of Vaseline on the lens can hide just how cheap that wig is. Five stars.

4) CHILLING MISE EN SCENE

Some art department intern at Celebrity Ghost Stories had a field day doing this weird pained ghost tagging, but is completely overshadowed by Sensing Murder’s exquisite framing. Look past the terrible moustache to a reflection of true horror, a homage to The Ring that deepens the shot and alludes to the killer’s identity. Beautiful.

5) CORNY LINES OF DIALOGUE

If we are going corn in the purest sense of the word, anything that has ever been uttered on Sensing Murder is 100% overruled by Joan Rivers talking about how she covered her apartment in cornflour in order to catch the ghost of her dead landlord. Congratulations, Celebrity Ghost Stories, you really are the best of the worst.


Read the rest of our Sensing Murder coverage here, and click below to watch Celebrity Ghost Stories on Lightbox

This content, like all television coverage we do at The Spinoff, is brought to you thanks to the excellent folk at Lightbox. Do us and yourself a favour by clicking here to start a FREE 30 day trial of this truly wonderful service.

The Spinoff Longform Fund is dedicated to facilitating investigative journalism. Our focus is on supporting in-depth reporting on important New Zealand stories. Your donation will help us sustain this most resource-intensive form of journalism, ensuring that the most complex and important stories still get told.