spinofflive
The insider whanau.
The insider whanau.

MediaOctober 10, 2024

Insider Insider: inside the NZ Herald’s insider empire 

The insider whanau.
The insider whanau.

Our new columnist, the Insider Insider, takes a peek inside the insiderest media operation of all time. 

The proliferation of insiderness at the New Zealand Herald appears unstoppable, with the unveiling this morning of Society Insider, by Ricardo Simich. It joins a bustling neighbourhood of insiders at the nation’s biggest and most insidery newspaper.

Other insiders debuted in the last year and a half include the Sports Insider, the Property Insider, the Beauty Insider and the Tech Insider. A Herald insider told the Spinoff Insider Insider: “We’ve never been insiderer.” 

The original insider – “daddy insider” to insiders – is, of course, the Media Insider. Launched in March 2023, the Media Insider promised “inside detail from the world of media”, and, boy, did it deliver. The Media Insider, also known as “pretty much the entire home page of nzherald.co.nz on Fridays”, written by Shayne Currie, has since spawned more insiders than an agoraphobia convention. “Shayne Currie” is understood to be a pseudonym.

There was once a Business Insider, but the last column published under that byline we can find was in February 2022. Insiders have offered conflicting explanations for the disappearance to the Insider Insider: the Business Insider was either a victim of insidercide (pushed off a cliff by the Media Insider); or the Business Insider was sacked after spending too long outdoors. 

“Shayne Currie” (Image: Tina Tiller)

It is unlikely the Society Insider will be the last insider to join the Insiderverse. The Herald’s parliamentary press gallery is understood to be deadlocked over whether to relaunch as the Baseball Insiders or the Waistline (beltway insiders). 

The Summer edition will be rebranded Inside a Shark and all coverage of songs for children bylined to the I Know an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Spider It Wiggled and Jiggled and Tickled Insider.

The opinion pages are set to be called the Broadsider, the comments threads rebranded as the Please Reconsider and the editorial as Insider GPT. 

Plans to launch a share market column, Trading Insider, are said to have been dropped.

Rival media outlets are furious about the ceaseless insider expansionism. A Stuff insider told the Insider Insider: “I bet they’re just like Tom Cruise and Matt Dillon from The Outsiders except at their desks with cups of tea and biscuits,” before garbling a series of inane slogans like, “Ideas don’t grow on trees and neither does money.” 

Patrick Gower said the growth of the insider kingdom was “really fucking good news”, before adding, “fuck,” and, “fuckfuck?”

fuck

There was no one available for comment from TVNZ owing to the state-owned broadcaster having been reduced to one employee, Weatherman Dan Corbett, left alone waving his hands on a YouTube channel, with every other output axed for lack of profitability.

An RNZ insider said they had not noticed the growth of the insider franchise because they were focused on developments in the P Diddy story. 

A Spinoff insider said it would not be responding because it had its head lodged inside its backside.

The Insider Insider is excited about the new Society Insider column, which is expected to cover a range of issues including child poverty, social mobility and community housing, standing as a bold repudiation to Margaret Thatcher’s proclamation that “there is no such thing as society”. It marks a departure for Simich, who previously helmed the Spy column, which focused on a range of issues in the state surveillance and national security space. 

As told to Toby Manhire

Keep going!
TVNZ’s Auckland studios (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)
TVNZ’s Auckland studios (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

OPINIONMediaOctober 7, 2024

Why TVNZ is right to shut down 1news.co.nz (with one major caveat)

TVNZ’s Auckland studios (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)
TVNZ’s Auckland studios (Photo by Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

It’s possible to view TVNZ shutting its news website as a retrenchment from digital. In fact, it’s the opposite, argues Duncan Greive.

Has there ever been a year like 2024 for news about the news? First Newshub fell, then TVNZ killed two of its most popular current affairs shows, then Stuff started making ThreeNews. Just last week, Google made public its intention to shut down news on its platforms should a contentious bill pass. Now TVNZ is proposing to shut down 1news.co.nz from early 2025 – should that eventuate, New Zealand will have lost two of its five most-read news sites in less than 12 months.

Some will view this as a catastrophic failure of management by TVNZ. 1news.co.nz attracts a monthly audience of roughly 1m, and over the past couple of years it has developed a distinct tonal identity. There’s strong longform writing from some of its flagship journalists, a robust opinion section and the kind of quizzes and newsletters which are found on many news sites. Its platform is well-designed, fast and easy to navigate. It is a very good news site.

Still, the decision has a fundamental logic. 1news.co.nz’s core output is text-based news. There are two huge incumbents in that space in Stuff and the NZ Herald, with RNZ seemingly having taken over third place. There is no prospect of TVNZ running any of them down without massive investment – and the whole point of this exercise is to find a huge $30m in savings or new revenue. 1news.co.nz also requires journalists and editors skilled in creating and publishing text-based news – even granted a level of multi-skilled personnel, this inevitably means some degree of duplication alongside the core video team.

TVNZ reporting on the news

The site also likely makes a relatively trivial sum for TVNZ – it’s focused on text-driven stories wrapped with display advertising, and doesn’t indulge in the autoplay shenanigans of other text-driven sites, meaning its video impressions will be limited. There is no good reason to believe that will meaningfully change in years to come. The best strategy for funding text-based news sites is audience revenue – yet because TVNZ’s digital news offering is not powerfully differentiated from the much larger sites, it’s hard to see how a paywall or membership model could work.

Perhaps the most powerful argument in favour of the move is to look at TVNZ as a whole. The whole point of TVNZ is that it’s #1 everywhere it goes – the biggest audiences, the most famous stars, the category defining leader in video news. Its 6pm bulletin is the single biggest news product in the market – websites might have bigger audiences overall, but not all at once like 6pm. Having the distant 4th-ranked news site just doesn’t fit with the brand. With Newshub exiting the market, it has an opportunity to dominate video news more profoundly than at any point since the arrival of TV3 more than 30 years ago.

To do that, it needs to radically change the way it presents news on TVNZ+. It has made strides there – it currently gives prominent position to John Campbell’s new true crime series, and recently introduced individual stories to its core carousel. Ultimately it can lead to a bulletin which is always live – updated throughout the day and evening. There’s even the prospect of a live digital news FAST (free ad-supported) channel, composed of its news, current affairs and documentary offerings, interspersed with news analysis, talk and regular bulletins. All creating more valuable video ad inventory.

That is only possible if the newsroom has a total purity of focus, one which is tightly aligned with the digital content strategy of the company as a whole. Losing the standalone website hurts in the short term, and is brutal for the staff who’ve worked so hard to make it such a strong product in recent years. But TVNZ admitting that it’s a video-first organisation makes a huge amount of sense. All its sales staff live to sell video ads. All its content delivery is built around surfacing video. Sadly for me, a writer, the whole internet is increasingly driven by video – so if that’s what you’re great at, why wouldn’t you commit all of your energy to it?

It is manifestly the right call. But there is one group outside TVNZ who will be rightly infuriated by this move. Six months ago we went through the same process, with the end result that the core video teams which created Sunday and Fair Go left the building, while Re:News was significantly downsized. In the 1news.co.nz era, that made sense, to an extent. In a TVNZ+ News era, it’s tragic. Sunday made impactful longform current affairs video. Fair Go made wildly popular consumer advocacy video. Re:News made smartly targeted youth focused video.

All of these products should have been taonga for any video news operation. They’re the teeth, the brand, the differentiator which stops your news product becoming overwhelmed by 2-4m packages, and gives you something deeper. Something your competition can’t match. So while this is a hard decision with an undeniable argument underneath it, there’s still a deep sadness associated with it – both for those impacted today, and those needlessly abandoned earlier this year.