spinofflive
Image Tina Tiller
Image Tina Tiller

PoliticsNovember 25, 2022

WTF is a recession?

Image Tina Tiller
Image Tina Tiller

A global recession is predicted for 2023, but what does that mean and how will it affect Aotearoa?

This was first published in November 2022. On June 15, 2023, GDP data released for the first three months of 2023 showed a second quarter of negative economic growth and that New Zealand did dip into recession.

Over the last few decades New Zealand has experienced several recessions. There was a relatively brief one in 2020 as the economy reacted to the shock of the pandemic, but the last enduring recession was in 2008. An entire generation – anyone under 30 – hasn’t really ever experienced a recession. The Spinoff didn’t even exist in 2008. Facebook was a mere two years on from calling itself The Facebook. People still rented DVDs. Our current prime minister was first elected an MP towards the end of 2008 and our one of youngest MPs, Chlöe Swarbrick was 14 years old. 

The Reserve Bank is now forecasting that New Zealand will enter recession from mid-next year and that it may last for four quarters – a whole year.

What is a recession?

Technically a recession is when there are consecutive quarters of shrinking growth in the economy. Growth is measured using Gross Domestic Product or GDP, which is the total value of the goods and services produced in a country. It’s the widely accepted metric we use to measure the health of our economy. GDP announcements are made each quarter (every three months) by Statistics NZ. In 2020 we had two quarters (six months) of negative growth, which met the definition of a recession, but growth recovered in the following quarter. No two recessions are alike in their causes or impacts but we can cast back to 2008 to get a sense of what a recession looks like. 

What caused the 2008/2009 recession?

New Zealand experienced six quarters of recession in 2008 and 2009 prompted by the Global Financial Crisis (GFC). That means what we made and sold got less and less for almost two years. There were a swirl of contributing factors to the GFC but it was largely the result of the subprime mortgage crisis in the US and the debt crisis in Europe. Essentially a big speculative housing and debt bubble burst. In New Zealand, our banks remained stable but not all our financial institutions were immune. South Canterbury Finance, Hanover Finance and Bridgecorp Holdings collapsed, meaning many ordinary people who had invested in them lost their life savings. In total, between 2006 and 2012, 67 finance companies collapsed in New Zealand. It’s estimated between 150,000 – 200,000 people lost $3b as a result. There has been a large amount of reform since then to ensure that doesn’t happen again.

What happened?

Between April 2007 and April 2011 the real house price, adjusted for inflation, fell by 15.3% in New Zealand. The unemployment rate grew from 3.7% in December 2007 to 6.1% in December 2008. Younger people found it hard to get jobs. The number of working age people receiving an unemployment benefit grew from 18,000 in June 2008 to 62,000 by the end of June 2010. 

When we’re in a recession, people shop less, travel less and generally save more than usual – this is something Reserve Bank governor Adrian Orr explicitly asked us to do on Wednesday. The effect of that is that businesses lay off staff, and stop investing – which tends to feed on itself, as those laid off simply can’t spend as much as they used to.

Prime Minister Helen Clark on the 2008 election campaign trail (Photo: Sandra Mu/Getty Images)

Did it have a political impact?

Asking voters who could be trusted to lead the country through an economic crisis became a plank of the final days of the 2008 election campaign. “It’s time for strong and proven leadership” in an economic crisis became a key message for Labour. The electorate decided John Key and the National party were better placed to manage the country through, ending nine years of Labour government. New Zealanders don’t tend to give any government more than three terms in power but recessions and economic crises can prove to be a useful impetus for change. The forecast recession will inevitably have a bearing on next year’s election.

What about its real-world impact?

The recession of 2008/2009 had profound impacts on all kinds of businesses. The wind got knocked out of travel and tourism businesses for a while. The construction and property sector slumped. During the first quarter of 2009, car sales were down 40% from a year earlier. One in five used-car dealers closed down. In nine months, 100 hospitality businesses closed. Christmas parties in 2008 were often a BYO or DIY affair. 

McDonald’s had a great year in 2009

Some business categories thrive in recessions. We ate a lot of McDonalds in 2009, with the company having one of their best years in New Zealand. The fancy “Angus” burger was introduced to add some gourmet stylings to our growing appetite for cheaper food. Small cosmetics like lipsticks sold well, as did men’s underwear. Electric toothbrush companies were all smiles as people shelled out a little to avoid spending a lot on trips to the dentist.

If you worked in the performing arts, there was a lot of talk of “recession-proof” programming. People still needed cheering up right? But what did they want to see? Harking back to the cabaret of post-WW1 Weimar Republic Germany, The Sexy Recession Cabaret debuted in Auckland in 2009, starring a rotating cast of people like Keisha Castle-Hughes, Jennifer Ward-Lealand and Michael Hurst. People also turned to free activities. During the first two months of 2009, contraceptive sales grew 10%. 

The cause of the forecast recession in 2023 is not financial system collapse but inflation, and the measures being taken to fight it. It’s being deliberately engineered by the Reserve Bank.

The Reserve Bank has deliberately engineered this?!

Yes. Essentially the economy is running very hot. Inflation is proving hard to beat and one of primary mandates of the Reserve Bank is to keep the rate of inflation between 1-3%. Inflation is simply the term used to describe the rise of prices for goods and services. It means money loses its value, resulting in consequences like a higher cost of living. It’s usually the result of too much money being available to purchase too few goods and services, or because demand in the economy is outpacing supply. 

The Reserve Bank is using the rather blunt tool of lifting the Official Cash Rate (OCR) to try and cool spending. Increasing the OCR lifts home loan interest rates. That adds interest repayment costs to households which the Reserve Bank hopes will reduce household spending. People spend less and businesses have to drop their prices to stay competitive, which should hopefully see inflation drop. There is some talk that if we don’t get this situation under control, we could end up with stagflation.

‘If you value The Spinoff and the perspectives we share, support our work by donating today.’
Anna Rawhiti-Connell
— Senior writer

Stag-what?

A portmanteau of the words stagnant and inflation, it refers to the situation where the economy is struggling to grow and, at the same time, there is high inflation and high unemployment. It creates a paradoxical situation that isn’t supposed to happen with economies. It’s a stubborn stain that requires more than a light spritz of stain remover. Essentially you want to try and kill stagflation with fire. 

Sounds bad…

It’s not a super relaxing scenario, no. The impact of the forecast recession will disproportionately affect those already struggling with the cost of living and those who’ve bought houses in the last couple of years – when interest rates were admittedly extremely low but prices were high. There is some good-ish news in that this forecast recession is expected to be shallow. We have high levels of employment and are described by boffins as “well-placed” to weather what happens next year. But every recession is different – the only thing certain is that it will be painful.


For more on the economy, follow Bernard Hickey’s When the Facts Change on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or your favourite podcast provider.

Keep going!
Chlöe Swarbrick with Kiri Allan on the campaign trail in 2017; and in 2022. (Image: Tina Tiller)
Chlöe Swarbrick with Kiri Allan on the campaign trail in 2017; and in 2022. (Image: Tina Tiller)

PoliticsNovember 25, 2022

‘I’m very effectively annoying’: Chlöe Swarbrick on five years as an MP

Chlöe Swarbrick with Kiri Allan on the campaign trail in 2017; and in 2022. (Image: Tina Tiller)
Chlöe Swarbrick with Kiri Allan on the campaign trail in 2017; and in 2022. (Image: Tina Tiller)

Yes, politics remains broken. But there is a privilege in being a parliamentarian, and a way to make it work, says the Green MP.

The Spinoff’s coverage of politics hinges on the support of members – if you can, please make a contribution here.

Since her election to parliament in 2017, Chlöe Swarbrick has had moments of disillusionment and wondering whether she has had enough. “It sounds flippant to say it happens every week. But it genuinely does,” she said. “There are definitely some days where it feels a lot tougher.”

Elected first on the Greens’ party list and then, in 2020, pulling off the extraordinary feat of winning the Auckland Central seat, Swarbrick has gained attention in Aotearoa and abroad for her frankness, her one-liners and policy achievements against the odds. 


Follow Gone By Lunchtime on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or your favourite podcast provider.


But, in keeping with fellow 2017 first-time candidate diarists Kiri Allan and Erica Stanford, who gathered together this month for a special Spinoff Members event, she has always felt like an outsider in the halls of parliament. “I hate so much of the system and the institution that we’re inside of. In the chamber, climate change doesn’t exist, poverty doesn’t exist. And everyone’s just delivering Shakespearean soliloquies based on how long their whip has told them to talk for. That feels very disenchanting. But then you go out, particularly into the electorate, and you engage with people, and you solve some problems, and you get some proof of concept. And you mobilise people and you give some people some hope, and you can build on that. And that’s the stuff which kind of reenergises me.”

While still fundamentally believing, as she suggested in the documentary OK Chlöe, that “politics is fucked”, she has come to see something else. “There are parts of it that I genuinely do love, and that is the problem-solving stuff … And it also feels, I guess, as I get older, ‘more mature’, that it’s just so petty to complain about it in that way. It is such a privilege to do this job. So I’m still navigating all that stuff. I still do get very cynical and very disenchanted. But the way that I’ve kind of framed up that I do my job now is that I’m very effectively annoying. I’m very good at picking an issue and running with it and finding every single possible avenue to keep that issue alive,” said Swarbrick, banging the desk for emphasis. “And in doing that there’s some kind of sense of success that you feel in being creative.”

Chlöe Swarbrick, Kiri Allan, Eric Stanford and Toby Manhire at the Candidate Diarists Reunion event.

Swarbrick’s political journey began in 2016, at the age of 22, with a run for the Auckland mayoralty. She finished third, but in the process won over a number of cynics and attracted the attention of political parties in Wellington. Was there a bidding war? “A few different political parties approached and I spoke to a few different people but went with the Greens because, despite them not being able to guarantee a place, it was the alignment of values,” she said. “And I guess, also the ability just be straight up about the things that I wanted to do … I think that in a party smaller than two historical big ones, that is a little bit more freedom, sometimes to express stuff, to shake some shit up.”

The 2017 campaign was a painful one for the Greens, as co-leader Metiria Turei was assailed over an admission in a speech that she had lied to Winz years earlier to make ends meet as a solo mother. With six weeks to go to election day, Turei resigned. “It was emotional,” said Swarbrick. “We had 50-odd people in our office in Auckland Central. And we were all tuned in to the 6 o’clock news. And that happened. And then we all kind of cried. We were like, yeah, we can’t do phone calling any more.”

She drew on “conversations with Meyt during that process. There was one thing she said that stuck in my mind, which was: ‘no one person is bigger than the kaupapa’. You know, you have to keep moving forward. If we have a movement that lives or dies on the shoulders of one person, that’s not a sustainable movement … So it was gnarly. And I don’t know if I’ve still necessarily worked through all of that trauma. It was a hardcore campaign.”

‘Profound example of injustice and illogic’

Swarbrick has been outspoken on drug reform across the last five years. She became the most articulate political voice in favour of a yes vote in the ill-fated cannabis legalisation referendum. She fought hard for changes to allow people to have illegal drugs tested legally. Most recently she has successfully pushed the government to tighten up rules relating to the sale of a legal drug, alcohol. 

“I didn’t come into parliament to talk about drugs,” said Swarbrick. “But I’ve ended up doing a lot of that.” She inherited the medicinal cannabis member’s bill from Julie-Anne Genter when she became a minister, and continued to focus on drug laws, “the most profound example of injustice and illogic and anti-evidence legislation on our statute books.”

‘If you regularly enjoy The Spinoff, and want it to continue, become a member today.’
Toby Manhire
— Editor-at-large

She said: “I think it’s very easy to forget, particularly with the flashpoint of the 2020 referendum, just how much work has been done over the last five years on this issue, with amendments to the [Misuse of Drugs Act].”

All taken together, “I feel like that’s helped to reframe the discussion around drugs, and we’re in a different place than we ever have been. And hopefully, right in time for us to look at some commitments from all political parties for the Misuse of Drugs Act 1975 to be binned.” 

See also: Kiri Allan and Erica Stanford.


Follow our politics podcast Gone By Lunchtime on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or your favourite podcast provider.

But wait there's more!