Revealed: Why Olivia Dean’s NZ fans were left hanging for 40 minutes
Oliva Dean at the Western Springs Bowl. (Image: Supplied)
'It decided to have an issue at the biggest show she'd ever played ... and they fixed it. And they went to go walk back out on stage and it fucked up again.'
Four songs into her record-breaking Auckland show, Olivia Dean stopped, smiled sweetly, told the 43,000 fans in front of her there was a small technical problem and promised she’d be back in two minutes. It was 9.22pm.
Fifteen minutes later, Western Springs Bowl venue partner Campbell Smith was beamed onto the big screens, warning the problem was going to take a little longer to fix. “We’ll be back with the show in five minutes,” he promised.
Dean finally returned at 10.03pm, making liars out of the pair of them. All told, it took 41 minutes to fix the glitch that derailed the UK soul singer’s performance that night, causing public transport issues and risking an Auckland Council fine for breaking the 11pm curfew.
News sites spent several days unpacking the issues that affected Dean’s otherwise delightful show in a newly revamped venue that night, referring to the problem as “unforeseen technical difficulties,” “sound issues” and a “technical disruption”.
But what really happened?
The Spinoff can now reveal the problem came from not one but two failures of equipment supplied by Dean’s touring team that happened 22 minutes into her performance, shortly after she’d finished her fourth song, ‘Close Up’.
An on-stage mixing desk supplying sound to Dean and her band through their in-ear monitors failed, explains David Benge, head of touring New Zealand at TEG Live. “They control-alt-deleted it and it got back up and it was ready to go in about five minutes,” he says.
That’s when the second problem occurred. “They were about to walk back on stage and it [crashed] again.”
To fix the issue, engineers abandoned the faulty equipment and rerouted audio through a second console, the one used to balance the sound fans hear. “To do the bigger, more robust back-up fix … was going to take longer,” says Benge.
Dean’s show was upgraded from Spark Arena to the $2.5 million renovated Bowl, breaking the record as her biggest ever headlining show. She told fans it was the first time she’d experienced a problem like this.
Benge agrees it was a one-off, random event. “It’s the same console they used for all of the Australian shows,” he says. “It decided to have an issue at the biggest show she'd ever played in the history of her career anywhere in the world. And they fixed it. And they went to go walk back out on stage and it fucked up again.”
The explanation comes as Auckland Stadiums reveals the feedback received from 1,725 ticketholders about that night – and the issues they’ll be attempting to fix before an upcoming performance by the Foo Fighters, and February’s Laneway festival.
Despite the night’s big glitch, feedback from the survey about the revamped Bowl and released exclusively to The Spinoff was overwhelmingly positive, says Auckland Stadiums director James Parkinson.
Overall satisfaction charted at 80%, 77% reported feeling safe and relaxed inside the venue, and 51% of fans came from outside of Auckland. This, says Parkinson, proves the Bowl is set to play a big role in Auckland’s stadium infrastructure. “It fits that niche,” he says.
He agrees a smaller test performance to iron out any kinks would have been ideal, but tight timeframes didn’t allow for it. “We had over 40,000 people in the venue who were able to enjoy that show,” he says. “Fundamentally, that would not have happened had Western Springs Bowl not been available.”
Feedback also shows improvements are needed in other areas. Parkinson points to improved lighting and better signage about walkways and exits. Some punters in the Bowl’s terraced sections reported being told not to sit down, and communication about those rules needs to be increased, he says.
The biggest complaints were about public transport options after Dean’s show. These issues were exacerbated by the 41-minute delay, says Parkinson. “The delay then meant that by the time people exited the venue, a number of those scheduled services had already concluded,” he says.
Options are being discussed so this is less of a problem at future shows. “We've not had cause for a delay like that before, so I'm certainly hoping it's not going to be something that repeats itself in any hurry [but] we do believe that we can – even should – further improve.”
Despite the opening night drama, Parkinson says the Bowl is already a major hit with promoters wanting to book it for shows. He calls the number of concerts pencilled in for next summer’s run “phenomenal”. “It’s not just the volume either, it is the diversity of content,” he says. “It’s good to be in that position now.”
Chris Schulz
Chris Schulz is a contributing writer at The Spinoff. He's an award-winning journalist from Tāmaki Makaurau who has spent 25 years working for local publications. His specialties include live events, pop culture, infrastructure and Aotearoa music.
Sign up to Rec Room, delivered straight to your inbox.