The time for All Blacks optimism is well and truly over

22 Nov 2026
Opinion
Sport
England's Marcus Smith converts a penalty kick with the final play of the match during the Nations Championship 2026 match between England and New Zealand at Allianz Stadium on November 21, 2026 in London, England. (Photo by Andrew Kearns - CameraSport via Getty Images)

England's Marcus Smith converts a penalty kick with the final play of the match (Photo: Andrew Kearns - CameraSport via Getty Images)

Even the most artful spin doctor would be hard-pressed to find mitigating factors, let alone grounds for optimism, in the performance against England, writes Paul Thomas.

We heard a lot about optimism when the Dave Rennie era of All Blacks rugby got under way earlier this year. His buzzword seemed to resonate with a public and media keen to move on from the malaise that permeated the dying days of his predecessor Scott Robertson’s tenure and wanting a reason to believe the All Blacks could and would be great again.

We haven’t heard it much lately, perhaps not surprisingly given grounds for optimism are few and getting fewer. Rennie’s All Blacks have lost five of their 13 tests with the latest loss – 12-37 to England at Twickenham this weekend – being the most comprehensive: as comprehensive as last year’s humiliation by the Springboks in Wellington; as comprehensive as any ever inflicted by a northern hemisphere side.

One of the realities of sport is that things can change – for better or worse – very quickly. Two weeks ago the All Blacks seemed to be tracking pretty well: the Wallabies had been given their annual, ritualistic comeuppance and a second half blitz had seen off a confident Scottish team. It appeared as if the hard lessons of Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry tour had been absorbed and acted upon and the All Blacks were charging towards the inaugural Nations Championship grand final.

Instead they’ll be a support act, engaged in the battle of the also-rans and, perhaps more to the point, desperately trying to avoid losing three games on the trot. One suspects they’d much rather be heading to Heathrow to jet off to a corner of the world where rugby isn’t played, watched or talked about.

At first blush the feckless loss to Wales in Cardiff seemed like an aberration and, besides, who begrudged the long-suffering Welsh their upset for the ages? On closer examination, the All Blacks’ performance raised doubts about their preparation, tactical awareness and game management. The abandonment of the ruck and run approach in favour of trying to batter the Welsh into submission raised questions about their commitment to the game plan. The failure to physically overpower an opposition dismissed beforehand as “lightweight” revived concerns that these All Blacks just don’t have the grunt and muscle to go toe to toe with the heavyweights.

Even the most artful spin doctor would be hard-pressed to find mitigating factors, let alone grounds for optimism, in the performance against England. The yawning gap on the scoreboard reflected the gulf in class on the field.

The shortcomings we’ve become all too familiar with were on display: a sluggish start; a malfunctioning set piece, in this case the lineout; carelessly conceding penalties that gift the opposition possession, territory and momentum; alarming one on one defensive lapses; the default to hot potato catch and pass in the face of defensive line speed with resultant error rate; getting out-muscled at the breakdown with resultant slow ball.

But England were clearly superior in aspects of the game in which All Black superiority was once taken for granted. They were sharper, faster, more athletic, more innovative, more explosive, more intense, more everything. The All Blacks, coaches and players, have talked a lot this year about getting back to the style of rugby that comes naturally to New Zealanders, that we want to play and watch, that’s in our DNA. Nothing we saw at Twickenham suggested the men in black had a genetic edge. The opposite in fact: England beat us at our own game.

So what now? New Zealand Rugby chair David Kirk brought down the guillotine on "Razor" Robertson because the All Blacks weren’t on the right trajectory to win next year’s World Cup. After the Cardiff fiasco, Kirk returned to the theme. It wasn’t so much a matter of having to beat England as bouncing back with an encouraging performance: “You cannot judge the match on the result – we could lose playing really well. But a bad loss would be concerning. I’m sure there will be a serious examination if we play poorly at Twickenham.”

There wasn’t even what the markets call a "dead cat bounce" – an unconvincing, short-lived uptick. The All Blacks were flat, inaccurate, unimposing, never in the game. "Poor", in a word. A "serious examination" sounds ominous but another change of coach at this late stage in the World Cup cycle seems unlikely.

As Kirk conceded, the All Blacks have probably had their hardest-ever year and the long injury list reflects that. However, given what transpired at Twickenham it’s impossible to be bullish about our playing stocks, either depth or quality.

Perhaps it’s time for a reality check: ask yourself how many of the current side would make the 2015 World Cup-winning All Blacks starting XV. If your answer is a number higher than one, congratulations: you are a true blue optimist and Dave Rennie would like a word.

TagsRugby
Paul Thomas

Paul Thomas

Paul Thomas is an award-winning novelist and columnist who has written extensively on sport.

More about Paul Thomas
Keep going