Idea: Let's not form a government
We could probably go a few years longer without hearing from Chris Hipkins and Chris Luxon. (Image: The Spinoff/Tina Tiller)
New Zealand deserves a longer silence of the Chrises.
Hark! Put your ear to the Beehive. What do you hear? Press your cheek against Parliament House. What emanates from its stone walls? That’s right, nothing but abiding, merciful electoral silence. No men called Chris bickering their way through the world’s most elongated mid off. No David Seymour branding you a dropkick. No Harry Mowbray calling you an emotional woman. Journalists aren’t even bothering to misspell Qiulae Wong anymore. Click on a website, and it’ll serve up a mundane potpourri of horrors and dietary advice. Switch on RNZ, they’re talking about the loud fire siren in Waverley. Over at Stuff, they want your take on the new Bond.
It’s like when an extractor fan gets switched off and you realise the sound that was subconsciously stressing you out has vanished. New Zealand has finally turned the volume down on what felt like an endless election campaign. Chrises have been replaced by Christmas. Nicola by St Nick. No one knows what the government is going to be. The nation is in a leadershipless liminal space, and things haven’t felt this good for a long time.
Wayne Brown agrees. Auckland’s mayor returned from a recent trip to China convinced that “democracy has had its day”. Though his pronouncement was ostensibly inspired by the authoritarian country’s economic successes, he may also have been luxuriating in the new system of non-government New Zealand has been existing under for the last few weeks.
As we wait for the special votes to be counted and the resulting Winston Peters-infused political wrangling to begin, New Zealand is being run under caretaker conventions, named both for the fact that they prevent the incumbent government from carrying out any major reforms and the way they take care of our collective mental health. It is literally illegal for things to happen now, and frankly, that’s good. There have been too many things. We all deserve a break from things.
In place of stuff happening, we have stasis. The legislative shape of the nation is preserved in amber. There’s nothing to debate. Nothing to fight over. Nothing to love or deplore. An infinity of political oblivion to sink into; silence interrupted only by the distant blare of Waverley’s fire siren.
What could be better? Of course New Zealand still has a whole heap of problems to solve. Our tax system is so stupid that even the commies at the International Monetary Fund are pleading with us to expand it to include capital. We seem to have tasked roughly three nurses and a doctor on Zoom with staffing all of our emergency departments. Despite that, we’ve committed all our money for the next three decades to building two roads. Meanwhile, mince costs $1,000.
But let’s get real. What have our politicians done more of in the last 40 to 50 years: fix problems or cause them? The reason we’re even in this mess in the first place is arguably because they’ve focused their energy on the latter. Maybe some extra time off would help them reflect and reassess. The bureaucrats can run things for a bit while they buck up their ideas. In the meantime we get a break from their incessant posturing, sniping, backstabbing and bloviating.
We wouldn’t be the first country to go through an elongated parliament-free period. Belgium famously went 541 days without a government in 2010 and 2011. Was there chaos? Rioting? Societal collapse? The Guardian crossed the English Channel to find out at the 250-day mark and found a surprisingly sanguine populace. "Everything goes on in the same old way," said Edmund Cocquyt, a Flemish connoisseur of bars. Cocquyt hailed the country’s stalemated politicians as “heroes” before issuing an uncanny echo of a future Auckland mayor. "It's better not having a government. Besides the trouble with democracy is it is so slow. If we want to build a new road, it takes us 20 years to decide. The Chinese dictatorship does it the next day."
Back home, Opportunity’s deputy leader Daniel Eb is already promising a “gnarly” negotiation period before our next governing coalition is formed. His party’s eco-friendly bottom lines run directly counter to at least two of its likely coalition partners’ policies on mining and fishing. The stand-off could be brutal and it can't go on long enough. Hold your ground, Winston. Don’t blink, David. Don't quit, Qiulae. If repeated in New Zealand, the Belgian government’s interregnum would take us to 2028. That sounds like a good enough break. See you all then, God-willing.
Hayden Donnell
Hayden Donnell is a senior writer for The Spinoff. He previously worked at RNZ, TVNZ and the New Zealand Herald, alongside other media companies that have since closed down or been renamed. His primary passions are local politics and the Big Fresh animatronic fruit and veggies.