Ten ways to fix MMP, explained

19 Nov 2026
Politics
A collage of election-related images.

Does New Zealand need to change the MMP system to ensure proper proportionality in perpetuity?

The largest overhang in MMP’s history has put electoral reform back on the agenda. Here are some of the main options likely to be on the table, and what each would mean for the next parliament.

“The genie is out of the bottle.” That’s the message from a group of cross-partisan electoral experts in an open letter released yesterday, which asked all parties in parliament to commit to adjusting the settings of MMP to prevent further perverse outcomes. 

Based on the preliminary results of the 2026 election, New Zealand’s next parliament will have 131 seats, up from the standard 120. That’s due to National winning six more electorate seats than its party vote would otherwise entitle it to, and Te Pāti Māori gaining an additional five seats. Both parties’ overhangs could be reduced after special votes are counted. 

Whether or not the overhangs were engineered or influenced by billionaires is kind of a moot point. A result like this was inevitable in a world where the major parties’ share of the vote keeps shrinking and voters become tactical as they grow more familiar with the system. If that system remains unchanged, it's likely to be exploited even further in the future. 

New Zealand voted to adopt the mixed-member proportional voting system in dual referendums in 1992 and 1993, replacing the old first-past-the-post system. The public backed it again in 2011 with 58% support in a follow-up referendum. MMP has been officially reviewed several times: in 1986 by a Royal Commission on the Electoral System, in 2001 by a parliamentary committee, in 2012 by the Electoral Commission and 2023 via an independent review. 

Those reviews recommended myriad tweaks to make the system fairer (most of which were ignored by the governments of the day), but none anticipated the situation we find ourselves in currently or proposed a solution that would fix it. So what options are available and how would they work? 

1. Remove the overhang and limit parliament to 120 seats 

This was recommended by both the 2012 and 2023 reviews but would actually make the current problem worse. Rather than creating additional seats, parliament would have a hard cap of 120 seats: each party would get their full number of electorate seats and the remaining seats would be divided up based on the party vote.

At the time, it was seen as a solution to the small overhangs previously seen with United Future and Te Pāti Māori. If those recommendations had been adopted, this year’s election would have produced an even less proportional result. National, with its 42 electorate wins, would have 35% of seats having won 29% of the party vote, while Labour would have 26% of seats having won 29% of the party vote. The coalition would be safely re-elected even with a minority of the nationwide party vote. 

2. Increase the number of list seats and/or reduce the number of electorate seats 

The fewer electorate seats there are relative to list seats, the harder it is for parties to produce an overhang. The 1986 Royal Commission initially envisioned a parliament with 60 electorate MPs and 60 list MPs, though the first MMP election in 1996 ended up with a 65:55 split. The number of electorates has increased over time due to population growth and currently sits at 71, with 49 list MPs in a standard parliament. 

The easiest way to make this change would be to increase the overall size of parliament without changing the number of electorates. The New Zealand Initiative’s Nick Clark suggested in 2025 that parliament should have 170 MPs, and Victoria University's Jonathan Boston has proposed 180-200 MPs. The same effect could be achieved by reducing the number of electorates, but this would require new boundaries and could arguably reduce local representation.

This solution would address the problem of the overhang created by National, but wouldn’t fix the overhang caused by Te Pāti Māori, which won five Māori electorates with just half a percent of the party vote. 

3. Compensation seats 

The compensation seats system would mean that if one party produced an overhang with electorate seats, every other party would receive additional list MPs until proportionality was restored. The potential problem is that the size of parliament would be larger and less predictable. On the preliminary results of this year’s election, parliament would need to grow to 142 seats to achieve proportionality. 

Germany, the first country to adopt MMP, applied the compensation seats method from 2013 to 2021 but it quickly got out of hand, with the Bundestag growing from a standard 598 seats to as many as 736 after the 2021 election. That led the German government to scrap the idea and switch to the next proposal. 

4. Let the party vote override electorate wins 

Under this system, there is no overhang because no party can receive any more seats than their party vote entitles them to. If a party won more electorates than their party vote share, the MPs who won by the slimmest margins wouldn’t get to go to parliament. This ensures that parliament is proportional to the nationwide vote, but it means that some electorates don’t get any representation. At the 2025 German election, 23 constituencies voted for MPs who didn’t end up going to parliament, which was understandably controversial. 

Uploaded Image
The 11-seat overhang has led to serious questions about whether MMP is broken.

This policy would be especially difficult in the Māori electorates, where Te Pāti Māori almost always wins more seats than its party vote share. The open letter proposed a softer version of this policy where each party could keep one or two overhang seats, but any more electorate wins over the cap would be disallowed. 

5. A single combined party-and-electorate vote 

Another option is simply to do away with the separate party and electorate votes and combine the two into a single vote that does both. Every individual vote would help to elect an MP and also determine the proportionality of parliament. 

It’s theoretically possible for this system to produce an overhang if a party’s votes were highly concentrated in a few electorates, but it would be relatively minor. The bigger issue is that it would remove the ability for voters to pick a local MP from a different party. 

6. Only party votes count in parliament 

Parties in parliament vote already as a bloc on almost every issue. Even if most MPs are away from the House, their votes are counted as if they are all there. One option proposed in the open letter is that legislative votes in parliament should be based on the share of the party vote each party received. Electorate MPs from parties with an overhang would still get a seat in parliament to ensure their region was represented, but their party wouldn’t get any additional votes. 

This system would hit a small hurdle in the instance of conscience votes, where parties allow their MPs to vote individually based on their values. These are relatively rare and are usually applied to social issues such as alcohol regulation, gambling, marriage equality and end of life choice. 

A man standing in the House of Parliament
Clerk of the New Zealand House of Representatives David Wilson has to figure out how to fit all the extra MPs into the building. (Photos: Supplied/The Spinoff)

7. Ranked-choice voting and/or multi-member seats for electorates

While it wouldn’t entirely fix the overhang problem, ranked-choice voting in electorates would reduce the chances of vote-splitting and allow voters to simply order the candidates by preference. Another option, proposed by economist Keith Rankin, is to have fewer electorates but for each electorate to elect multiple local MPs based on a ranked system, similar to how some council wards work. This generally leads to more balanced representation rather than a winner-takes-all outcome and means voters are likely to have at least one local MP who shares their values. 

8. Abolish the Māori seats 

The original Royal Commission report on MMP suggested that the Māori electorates could be scrapped because party lists would ensure greater diversity in parliament. This change would nullify Te Pāti Māori’s electorate-only strategy, but it would draw intense backlash from Māori voters who value the seats and would likely be a political non-starter. 

9. Abolish all electorates

Maybe local MPs are unnecessary in this increasingly connected world. By switching to a party-vote-only system, parliament would be guaranteed to proportionally represent the views of all voters. It would mean less local representation, though this could perhaps be negated by giving greater powers to councils. 

10. Abolish democracy

New Zealand’s most popular politician, Auckland mayor Wayne Brown, recently visited China and was so impressed that he came away believing that “democracy’s had its day. It’s time for something else.” 

Auckland mayor Wayne Brown with piles of coins, a laptop and the Sky Tower
Future supreme leader Wayne Brown.

Brown didn’t have any particular alternative to democracy in mind, telling Stuff, “I don’t get involved in that sort of ideological shit.” Reading between the lines, his implication is clear: Wayne Brown should be dictator for life. I, for one, welcome our new cranky octogenarian overlord.

Joel MacManus

Joel MacManus

Joel MacManus is a senior writer for The Spinoff. His journalism focuses on the political and economic systems that shape New Zealand. He won the 2025 Voyager Media Award for Best Columnist, Opinion or Critique.

More about Joel MacManus
Keep going