grebour

OPINIONPoliticsMay 31, 2016

Labour and the Greens get into bed, Winston prepares his pyjamas, and other bad metaphors

grebour

Labeen? Grabour? The marriage of the two main parties of the left makes sense, but the course of true love never did run smooth.

Shortly after the Labour Party’s calamitous defeat at the election in 2014, the soon-to-be-former leader David Cunliffe admitted that they had erred in rebuking an offer made by the Green Party, some months before the election, to campaign together.

“I think we can all learn some lessons from history,” he said. “In hindsight the progressive forces of politics probably would have got a better outcome if they’d been better coordinated.”

It may not have made any difference, so hapless was the Labour Party in 2014 – so hapless that MPs in both Labour and the Greens that have told me that it was probably just as well they didn’t get a chance to form a government with NZ First – but it was nevertheless a daft decision.

grebour

Essentially, it comes down to this: among those paying any attention, nobody who party votes Labour, and nobody who votes Green, will imagine that either party can take government in an MMP election next year without the other. And if the parties hope to achieve a governing arrangement with NZ First, which, pending some remarkable change in fortunes, they’ll certainly need, they’re much more likely to present a plausible and palatable deal to the public if it’s Labour-Green plus NZ First, rather than a motley and irksome soup of Labour, Green and NZ First.

And so today’s announcement was, if not entirely inevitable, sensible and constructive. It is hardly a massive surprise – except to, for example, one prize-winning blogger, who denounced my April column urging such a deal by saying it proved I did not “understand the basics of politics”, and such a deal was a non-starter, because “trying to get any deal with the Greens is near impossible”.

The Memorandum of Understanding (PDF), in essence, commits to a coordinated approach in the leadup to the 2017 election.

mou

Inevitably there will be tensions, including between the right of the Labour Party and the Green’s carob left. Andrew Little’s advocates routinely argue that the former union leader is a stellar coalition building, an expert at managing disparate teams: that is about to be put to the test. Both parties need to persuade the public that the electoral system was designed to allow coalition governments, and that their arranged marriage is simply behaving – and treating voters – like grown-ups.

Speaking of romance, a high five for this:

jouyce

And an ew-gross, get-a-caucus-room, for this:

ewgros

And, of course, players gonna play:

dunneplay

The machinations of political deal-making very often attract the imagery of flirtation, conjugal rites, and the rest.

In that spirit, Little told reporters this afternoon that “this is not a monogamous relationship”. He was making reference to space in the bed for Winston Peters and New Zealand First, of course, but he might be tempting uproar from Family First, because it’s not simply about playing the field, it’s about achieving a kind of polygamy in marriage, uniting in government at least Labour and the Greens and NZ First – maybe more.

That is no easy courtship, and the likeliest outcome less than a year and a half away from the next election remains – at risk of being premature – a National-NZ First consummation. But it is no longer, for Labour and the Greens both, the stuff of fantasy alone.

Keep going!
takethat

OPINIONSocietyMay 31, 2016

Blindness to the beauty of Ngāruawāhia is blindness to the beauty of New Zealand

takethat

Heather du Plessis-Allan sparked controversy this week with a column calling the Waikato town ‘rotting’. In fact, Ngāruawāhia is the epitome of uplifting small-town NZ, writes former resident Tainui Stephens.

In 1998 I fled Herne Bay in Auckland to live in Ngāruawāhia. It was one of the best things I ever did. I lived there for 12 years and cried my eyes out when I left. It had been a wonderful home and had treated me well.

Moving to a small town was an escape from traffic and the pressure of big city survival. I had thrived in it, and had reached a point in my life where I wanted a change. I was able to work from home, and this Waikato region was nicely perched between Auckland and Hamilton airports for when I needed to travel.

Ngāruawāhia had all the shops I needed for my day to day interactions with food, services, and DVD hire. It was only a two minute walk to the single main street. Every time I walked it, I felt blessed that it was so easy.

I also walked the streets morning and night in a mild attempt at exercise. It was always the same route: up the neighborhood, by the school, through the town, and down along the river.

naha
The Waikato River at Ngāruawāhia. Photo: Russell Street

As I do anywhere in the world, I would look at the homes and imagine the variety of life experiences that were occurring or perhaps even simmering behind closed doors. For all the evidence of happy families that I saw, I also knew that Ngāruawāhia was no different to any town or city where people are under pressure and break. I remember when a local woman Cherie Kurarangi-Sweeny stood up to make a noise about child abuse. She was excoriated by some locals, but to me she was a total hero. It takes enormous courage to stand up for what is right when everyone knows who you are, and where you live.

Another hero was the late Māori Queen Te Atairangikāhu. The local Tūrangawaewae marae is an official seat of the Kingitanga, and the fruits of her visionary leadership were on display whenever a big hui took place there. On my walks I could see over the river into the back of the marae complex. There was always something going down: cultural and sporting events and the impressive hosting of visitors from near and very far. I was always hearing speeches, song and haka bursting out. He ātaahua tōna rongo.

The rich history of Ngāruawāhia is ever present for those who choose to see it. When I walked down to the point where the Waipā and Waikato rivers meet and savoured the early morning mist; I could clearly imagine George Grey’s British troops emerging in their iron-clad boats of war, as much as earlier eras when iwi in their waka plied the waters.

On Saturday mornings there was a market in the main street. Nothing fancy, nothing flash, and a great opportunity to really see who lived in Ngāruawāhia. It was at those moments of local peeps gathering to have a kai and a kōrero, that I witnessed one precious reasonwhy I enjoyed life in a small town. No one worried about what you looked like. There was no parade of folk concerned with their image or what they wore. I knew that I loved to live in a place where you can go to town in your pyjamas, and no one cares.

One of the local characters was an elderly Pākehā man called Bill. He was a bit of a loner who worked at the supermarket. An unassuming chap who shuffled about the place with his bung leg to retrieve and return the shopping trolleys. He helped out around the town. I sometimes saw him being a warden at Anzac Day parades. If a tangi was on at the marae he would go there too. Humbly and by himself. Paying his respects by just being there. I always enjoyed seeing Bill as a guy who had his place and mana in this little community.

He lived alone down on the Esplanade. A glorious little tree lined street by the Waikato River. If he wasn’t at work at New World, he would be perched in his porch on an old seat. He would sit there for hours, watching not much go by.

I had to go to Tūrangawaewae recently for the tangi of a friend. I drove around the old Ngāruawāhia streets I knew so well, and suffered the pangs of memory. Not much had changed. There was evidence of some growth in the town, but nothing extraordinary. And down by the river, there was Bill. Sitting in the same spot, but this time with his Zimmer frame. I suppose someone else is doing the shopping trolleys now.

Here is the front page of today
Here is the actual front page of today’s Waikato Times, which featured Heather Du Plessis Allen with a moustache, a missing tooth, and horns

I have been fortunate to have traveled and done work in many small towns around the country. While indeed some of them are suffering tough economic times the response and resilience of the people is staggering. I see it in the good deeds of the community. I see it in the slow turnover of generations when the young step up with their beauty and talent to finish the work of their elders. I see people struggling against overwhelming odds. I see evidence of patience and love. I don’t see so much of it in the big smoke. Of course it’s there, perhaps lost a little in the haze.

When yet another television mediocrity decides to hurl a smart-arsed remark as evidence of personality, I am bemused at what it reveals of their character. I am also intrigued when city dwellers scorn those who live in small towns. The throb of a city is a seductive experience. But in my experience, cities the world over look more and more the same. Same shops, same traffic, same frenzy. New Zealand’s small towns are one bastion that protects our national identity: if only because we are close enough to the land and to the people upon it, to know the eternal beauty of that.

I now live in Ōtaki, and see the same stuff. Yippee.

Mauriora ki a tātou.