spinofflive
A planet called Earth.
A planet called Earth.

The BulletinSeptember 16, 2019

The Bulletin: A week of covering climate change

A planet called Earth.
A planet called Earth.

Good morning, and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: Covering Climate Now week begins, hate crimes in focus six months after Christchurch attack, and scale of house flipping laid bare. 

Over the course of this week, you’re going to see a lot of climate change coverage. The Spinoff will be one of the organisations participating in Covering Climate Now, a worldwide initiative aimed at strengthening the media’s focus on climate change. Hundreds of organisations are taking part, including some of the biggest news organisations in the world, and in New Zealand, the ranks will also include our friends at StuffRadio NZ, One News, Newshub, the NZ Herald and Newsroom. I’ll be linking a lot to their work over the coming days, and look forward to seeing each of their unique voices coming through.

As for our coverage, we’re starting the week with three pieces. The first is a report from Mirjam Guesgen, which outlines in detail what Auckland and Southland will feel like in 2050 on current warming trajectories. Climate change minister James Shaw has penned a letter to students participating in upcoming climate strikes. And Sam McGlennon writes about the concept of seizing the moment, and really acting on these seemingly insurmountable problems when the will is there.

Of course, it’s not like this sort of climate coverage is unusual any more. It has become increasingly apparent that stories that never would have been considered in this way are now being seen through the lens of climate change. You can rest assured that we won’t just do this week and then go back to ignoring it, because we haven’t been ignoring it for a long time now.

What you won’t see in these pages over the week is needless doom. Yes, these are enormous problems, with difficult solutions. But to wallow in the idea that there’s no hope, or that we may as well just give up, would be pathetic and stupid. We do still have time, and we owe it to future generations to work hard to give them a world they can inherit.


Sunday marked six months since the day of the Christchurch mosque attacks, in which 51 people were killed and many more injured. This editorial in The Press takes an uncomfortable look at the hate crimes that were taking place beforehand, and have taken place since, targeting ethnic minorities. However, there is still no hard data on exactly how common they are, because it simply isn’t recorded anywhere – despite that having the potential to give warning of future atrocities.


The concept of ‘house flipping’ is one that has dominated plenty of discussion about the housing market, and how it rose so high so fast. Thanks to the NZ Herald’s (paywalled) Kirsty Johnston and Keith Ng, we now have a much better idea of how it worked in practice. Over a six-year boom, more than 14,000 homes were flipped – on-sold for a big profit in the space of a few months – around the country. Some of those has absolutely no work done to them either, raising questions about whether such flipping was a cause or symptom of a market spiralling out of control. Meanwhile, the number of sales on that same market have now slumped to record lows, reports Interest.


The issue of homelessness in Wellington is one that plenty of political promises have been made on. Stuff’s Dileepa Fonseka has looked back on one from the 2016 election – mayor Justin Lester’s plan to build a ‘wet house’ that would allow people to drink while getting treatment – and questioned why it never ended up happening. By asking the question, it forced the mayor and councillors to defend what they had actually done on the issue instead.


Something of a theme is developing around consultations for the government’s freshwater plans. Farmers turn up in huge numbers, and leave unsatisfied with what they hear. Another one in Queenstown has been reported on by the ODT, while I can report much the same thing was evident at Friday evening’s consultation in Wellington. The consultation period has been extended another two weeks to October 31.


Remember the media merger between NZME and Stuff that the Commerce Commission rejected? There are rumours floating around that there could be another attempt. But as the NBR’s (paywalled) Dita de Boni writes, the financial position of Stuff is now in a much more dire state, despite owning by far the biggest news website in the country. Currently the company’s owners – Nine over in Australia – have made unsuccessful efforts to sell it off.


A huge election is about to take place in the Wairarapa town of Carterton. Radio NZ reports voting is now open in the race to decide what colour the iconic clock tower will be painted, with one vote per rate-paying household up for grabs. And while some might say it’s simply cosmetic, the options being put to the public would significantly change the tone of the tower. Voting tokens have gone out with the Carterton Crier, and will close on October 5.


The Bulletin is The Spinoff’s acclaimed, free daily curated digest of all the most important stories from around New Zealand delivered directly to your inbox each morning.

Sign up now


National’s agriculture spokesperson Todd Muller, next to an office shelf filled with American political paraphernalia (Alex Braae)

Right now on The Spinoff: Leonie Hayden looks at the Māori innovators and entrepreneurs at Matariki X, and the increasing strength of the Māori economy. Hayden Donnell reports from Hamilton on a debate that shows change could be coming for the city. I interviewed National party agriculture spokesperson Todd Muller, on the topic of compromise and bipartisanship. The Gone by Lunchtime podcast returns to survey the situation for Labour after their last week. Matt McAuley meets Miss June, a band whose frontwoman manages to balance music and medical school. And Toi Kai Rākau Iti, who is running in the Eastern Bay of Plenty Kohi Māori constituency, finds something to like about his crudely defaced billboards.


For a feature today, a look into the unexpected physical challenges that come with being a chess grandmaster. This piece from ESPN has been doing the rounds, in part because it cuts against the premise of one of the biggest debates around chess – whether or not it’s a real sport. As the piece shows, it’s an irrelevant question, because the immense physical and mental challenges of it happen regardless. Here’s an excerpt:

To combat it all, today’s players have begun to incorporate strict food and fitness regimens to increase oxygen supply to the brain during tournaments, prevent sugar-related crashes and sustain their energy. In the 1980s and ’90s, smoking, drinking and late-night parties were common on the chess circuit — that’s right, chess had a “Boogie Nights” phase — but that scene has all but disappeared.

“Physical fitness and brain performance are tied together, and it shouldn’t be a surprise that grandmasters are out there trying to look like soccer players,” Ashley says.


In basketball, the Breakers have slammed the door on offers for shooting guard Corey Webster, reports Guy Heveldt at One News. Webster had a fantastic World Cup, and an offer came in from a Turkish club – though it didn’t come with a buyout attached to it. Even though Webster wanted to go so much he offered to pay the buyout himself, the club said it still wouldn’t have made sense at their end, with two years remaining on Webster’s contract. It could make for something of an awkward start to the season, which gets underway pretty soon.

And finally, what a crazy year for Katrina Rore. The netballer has just won a third Grand Final of the year, adding a Super Netball title with the NSW Swifts in Australia to her World Cup with the Silver Ferns, and ANZ Premiership with the Pulse, reports Radio NZ. I think looking at her career as a whole, with many years of toil in teams that failed around her, it’s fair to say she deserves these trophies. Hopefully the Halberg Award selectors are watching.


That’s it for The Bulletin. If you liked what you read, and know other people who would find it useful, pass on this signup form to them. And if you want to support the work we do at The Spinoff, please check out our membership programme.

Keep going!
Rua Kēnana
Rua Kēnana

The BulletinSeptember 13, 2019

The Bulletin: A day of proving the point of NZ history education

Rua Kēnana
Rua Kēnana

Good morning, and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: Examples of why teaching history matters immediately emerge, accused Labour staffer resigns, and giant of Tongan democracy dies. 

In the space of a day, there were two examples that clearly showed why New Zealand’s history needs to be taught in schools. In case you missed it, we published a cheat sheet on what has been announced, with New Zealand’s Māori, colonial and modern history to become a compulsory school subject from 2022. The announcement of the new expectations on schools has been widely welcomed, including by the NZEI, National leader Simon Bridges, and iwi leaders.

The first example concerned the introduction of legislation to pardon Rua Kēnana of Tūhoe, reported on by Radio NZ. The prophet and pacifist was brutally persecuted by the government in the 1910s, including having his son killed in a raid. Those events have had a huge influence on the course of the relationship between Tūhoe and the Crown ever since. It would have been instantly recognisable to those who knew the history, in the police raids made into Urewera communities in 2007. And yet it is only now that this redress is being made.

And the second example pertains to a pernicious myth that has been passed down in place of actual history. In fact, as Don Rowe reported yesterday for The Spinoff, the myth of the Moriori arriving in Aotearoa before Māori has spread so far, it even ended up in the set of prominent American comedian Jim Gaffigan. He subsequently apologised, and as if to underline the point, said “I honestly thought that was the universal belief. I was simply repeating what I was told.” That very myth has long been a powerful piece of misinformation used to justify the historic oppression of Māori, and has actively contributed to making New Zealand less well informed about itself.

The point is, history matters. And it continues to matter long after those who experienced it are gone. It can only be a good thing for this country that it becomes part of everyone’s education.


The Labour staffer accused of sexual assault has resigned, in a statement provided through his lawyer, reports Stuff. He continues to “adamantly refute the serious allegations” and says he is co-operating fully with the inquiry, however is resigning “because of the stress of the situation, and my wish not to be a distraction to the work of the Government.” It follows the PM saying she had been taking advice on his continued employment with the party. And another report from Stuff – the Labour Council was warned two years ago of a “troubling culture of bullying, and of sexual harassment and assault.


Tonga’s prime minister ‘Akilisi Pohiva has died. He was a leading figure in the Kingdom’s pro-democracy movement, and was beloved by the people, who made him the country’s longest serving representative. He went to prison for his convictions, but persevered nonetheless throughout every setback in a remarkable life, which has been chronicled in an obituary by Keith Locke. May he rest in peace.


Farmers have been turning out in big numbers to angry consultation meetings on government freshwater plans. The Southland Times reported on one in Winton, at which there was heavy opposition to both the duration of the consultation, and the proposals themselves. The report indicates that many left at the end, feeling like the consultation had been “a sham.”


National is refusing to back down from an ad labelled confusing and deceptive by the Advertising Standards Authority, reports Radio NZ. It related to some stuff put out about the government’s electric car feebate scheme. The verdict isn’t binding, because the ASA isn’t an entity with legal powers.


Beer industry figures are warning the glut of new craft beer brands cannot be sustained, reports the NBR (paywalled.) Partly that’s because of customer appetites, which are at the moment tending towards novelty. But if that bubble bursts, a lot of new breweries will be left high and dry.


This is a good read on the importance of Kōhanga Reo, by Sophie Bateman at Newshub. Outside of the obvious language differences, there are various ways in which that system differs from the mainstream education, and some believe the latter could learn more from the former.   


The Bulletin is The Spinoff’s acclaimed, free daily curated digest of all the most important stories from around New Zealand delivered directly to your inbox each morning.

Sign up now



Right now on The Spinoff: Danyl Mclaughlan writes about the inadequacy of current systems used to deal with sexual assault allegations. Zoe Mills asked Hong Kong New Zealanders what they wanted to say to those back home, as they fight on to protect their civil liberties. Jihee Junn looks at the trademarking of pieces of indigenous culture by Western brands. Johnny Crawford and Lee Belk have put together a guide to passive-aggressive te reo phrases you can use around the office. Josie Adams went to Great Barrier Island to find out why it has the highest local election voter turnout in Auckland. And with everyone in Wellington trying to get elected on a ‘fix the buses’ platform, I ask how possible that will actually be.


For a feature today, a really honest and brave piece of self reflection, on a so-called “personal and professional growth, training and development” introduction session. Writing in Noted, Sasha Borissenko has related her story of going to a Landmark course, and coming away both out of pocket, and feeling more bereft. The piece raises important questions about whether these sorts of courses are ethical. Here’s an excerpt:

But it was worrying that vulnerable people were sharing these stories in a place where none of the people in authority had any specific training. Landmark mightn’t market itself as a mental health programme of any nature, but it sure as hell deals with people who’ve had traumatic experiences. I would say it would be virtually impossible to have a breakthrough of sorts without drawing on a distressing experience.

For every instance of sexual assault or extreme bullying I heard, I wondered whether it had a triggering effect on the audience members. Saying this, if you could relate to the trauma that was being described on the stage, you could equally transform, or so the Landmark theory goes.


A domestic rugby update to take you into the weekend: Hawke’s Bay continue to be unbeaten in the Mitre-10 Cup, with Stuff reporting it takes them well clear at the top of the Championship. Meanwhile in the Farah Cup, there could be significant early movement this weekend, with Wellington hosting Counties Manukau – 4th and 2nd in the Premiership respectively – and a loss for either likely to be damaging over the short season.


That’s it for The Bulletin. If you liked what you read, and know other people who would find it useful, pass on this signup form to them. And if you want to support the work we do at The Spinoff, please check out our membership programme.