Yes, 6pm is the best dinnertime
I know it and you know it too. (Composite image: The Spinoff)
With the days long and summer imminent, it’s time to eat early.
At the risk of sounding parochial or, even worse, like a toddler, there is an ideal time for dinner and it’s 6pm. I know it and you know it too. In fact, most of us agree, even if we don’t always live this truth (jobs present one hurdle, extracurriculars another).
Early dinners come into their own in summer, when the days are long and sunlight stretches closer to bedtime. Under these circumstances, eating at 6pm can feel like a second lunch, or a sliver of the weekend blessing your post-work drudgery. The sun is up, the weather’s warm and you can feel the stress melting like butter in a warm pan. Dinner formats vary as more options are afforded by the good weather and they’re made better the earlier you eat. Enjoy a crisp, greasy bundle of fish and chips on the beach; ignore the oven and throw together a salad; or chuck something (anything) on the barbecue while you drink a cold beer and dissociate in the sun, one eye on the grill.
Another benefit is time. Embracing your diurnal nature by dining early frees up the rest of your evening. Eating at 6pm means that by the time you’ve finished it’s still light outside. Fueled by a good meal and the desire to live a little (which mysteriously surges at this time of year) you could go do literally anything, like watch Wicker, join your local froyo queue, or explain the MMP overhang, again.
As a nation, our proclivity for earlier-than-usual dinner is well known and something of a curiosity; in 2024, when New Zealand was anointed earliest diners in the world, The Guardian shared our quaint habit with its readers.
There’s arguably some antiquated charm to be had when eating without electric light. And dining early really is a different experience. Still running on the energy of the day and not yet catatonic on the couch, mealtimes have a sense of momentum. That can be hasty, in the case of a quick plate, or leisurely, since starting early affords more time to eat.
Of course, an early dinner usually relies on availability – someone’s home early enough to put something on the table and you’re there to eat it – and convenience. An early meal can be convenient, in the case of soup noodles, or you can dine out and, very conveniently, have someone make dinner for you.
Committing to a 6pm dinner requires some measure of self control. Resist the urge to work longer, sun shining; instead leave work on time and proceed to your destination of choice.
At restaurants, nothing signals the luxury of time and freedom more than a 5.30pm booking. Settle into your seat and watch as the restaurant slowly grinds into gear. Wait staff arrive for the evening shift, tables are neatly set anticipating their patrons, and the kitchen is fully charged and ready to go. Take your pick of the specials, because nothing’s sold out yet! And, since not everyone realises this is the best time, you may be privileged with a quiet restaurant and extra-attentive service.
It’s often cheaper, too. Savvy restaurants incentivise early diners. Coco’s in Tāmaki Makaurau, which opens at 4pm, offers a happy hour menu from 4pm to 6pm. Pasta pomodora, margherita pizza and a daily special are all only $15. Between that and the restaurant's streetside seating, which comes into its own on warm summer nights, the early slots are popular, as evidenced any night of the week. In Te Whanganui-a-Tara, Michelin-starred fine-dining restaurant Logan Brown opens at 5pm and serves a set-price “bistro menu” until 7.15pm, catering to an after-work crowd and theatre-goers.
Smelling a business opportunity from the hungry-for-revenue hospitality market and cost-conscious diners, enterprising booking apps are helping to fill this early window. Local app First Table features discounts – with some caveats – for off-peak bookings. Leading Auckland restaurants Mr Morris, Kingi, Cibo, The French Cafe and Swashbucklers are among the many (many!) eateries offering 50% off pre-6pm bookings, where available. Booking and payment app EatClub, which is co-owned by Marco Pierre White, launched in New Zealand last month with a similar premise. It allows restaurants to offer discounts of up to 50% for empty tables. As of writing, Cassia and Times of India were all offering diners 30% off for arrivals between 5pm and 6.30pm, Atelier’s window is 4pm-6pm, and Khu Khu’s 5pm-7pm.
The benefits of a 6pm dinner time can also be experienced at home. An early finish means more time to do the dishes, stream some garbage, prepare for bed and get to sleep at a reasonable hour (or play Grand Theft Auto 6 till dawn). Experts reckon eating two to four hours before bed is better for you – it helps with digestion and regulates your blood sugar and circadian rhythm.
Of all the early diners, there’s one cohort that’s truly committed. Children, though their taste and judgment may be questionable, famously love it (whether they like it or not).
Hayden Donnell, who has some children, explains that they “have literally no capacity to sit with discomfort, so if they’re feeling hungry (usually around 5.30pm) they’re instantly complaining.” A late dinner has a flow-on effect to bedtime, regardless of early rising, meaning less sleep. “At which point they become a demon and cause everyone around them to suffer a mental breakdown.” His family eats together, the same meal at the same time. This means less cooking and more free time after dinner for leisure. “I’m a supporter of the early dinner,” Hayden says. “It’s also just kind of aesthetically nice eating a lovely meal and perhaps drinking a drink in the fading light.” You don’t need to persuade me.
Emma Gleason
Emma Gleason is a staff writer at The Spinoff and an award-winning fashion journalist. But it’s not just clothes that interest her, you’ll find her exploring tasty cheese, influenza outbreaks and more important things right here. She has experience with some of the country’s leading media outlets as well as the toaster in our kitchen.
Sign up to The Boil Up, delivered straight to your inbox.