spinofflive
CAMERON SLATER WON THE BLOGGER OF THE YEAR PRIZE AT THE CANON MEDIA AWARDS IN 2014.
CAMERON SLATER WON THE BLOGGER OF THE YEAR PRIZE AT THE CANON MEDIA AWARDS IN 2014.

MediaJune 2, 2019

The best of The Spinoff this week

CAMERON SLATER WON THE BLOGGER OF THE YEAR PRIZE AT THE CANON MEDIA AWARDS IN 2014.
CAMERON SLATER WON THE BLOGGER OF THE YEAR PRIZE AT THE CANON MEDIA AWARDS IN 2014.

Bringing you the best weekly reading from your friendly local website.

Sam Brooks: The 10 most shocking moments in the blistering new book ‘Whale Oil’

Slater tried to add Blomfield’s 10-year-old daughter on Snapchat

Well after the armed attack, and a fair way into the protracted legal battle between the pair, Slater, or someone pretending to be Slater, tried to add Blomfield’s 10-year-old daughter on Snapchat.

Slater, meanwhile, had been attempting a different kind of access into Matt’s realm. Early March 2017 and Rosalie, Matt’s now 10-year-old daughter, taps on the Snapchat icon on her phone. Someone called Cam Slater from whaleoilnz is asking to follow her. She looks at that name. It seems familiar. She takes her phone to Matt. ‘Dad,’ she says, ‘isn’t this the man who said mean things about you?’

Slater allegedly has a soft handshake, and eats steak

For reasons I can’t fathom, but I’m sure are explicable to the men at the centre of this saga, Cameron Slater and Matt Blomfield have lunch together to try and hash things out. At the Winebox Cafe, of all places! In the book, Blomfield admits that it was ‘an attempt to re-establish that power balance’. Blomfield had a chicken burger, Slater had Scotch fillet.

But, also, Blomfield notes Slater’s handshake:

Matt paid for Slater’s lunch; noted his soft handshake. ‘The whole thing was therapeutic from my point of view,’ he says. ‘I thought, you’re just a guy with a website.’

David Farrier: The mysterious Instagram influencers offering cash for hotel bed jumping videos

“Hotel Bed Jumping is a strange world. Unverifiable names, supposed competitions, and ultimately a desire to gather as much footage as possible of a sort-of-innocent-but-is-it-something-else activity.

There is no giant scandal to be found here. No-one is getting hurt. What we have is a really good example of how strange influencer culture has become.

I mean, you have a bunch of influencers that jump at the phrase “free hotel room” and “charity”.  Then you have hotel chains happy to give away rooms to a “Travel Agency” that appears to be nothing more than an Instagram account with 26,000 followers.

Hypothetically, if I was someone who wanted footage of women jumping on beds, I’d probably do exactly what TPT Marketing has done. And suddenly I’d be getting free hotel rooms to offer to ‘influencers’, in exchange for them filming themselves and sending me the footage. And I’d be doing all this in plain sight because the social media influencer scene is so cooked. No one would even blink an eye.

I checked my DMs again, and there were some new ones from @hotelbedjumping_community. They said they were aware I’d been making inquiries and were upset I’d voiced my suspicions to participants.”

Simon Connell: The fascinating case of Hannah Tamaki vs the Māori Women’s Welfare League

“In 2011, Hannah Tamaki was nominated for the presidency of the Māori Women’s Welfare League, the organisation famously lead by Dame Whina Cooper throughout the 1950s. It was the first national Māori organisation to be formed, and the first to provide Māori women with a forum in which their concerns could be aired, brought to a wider national audience and placed before the policy-makers of the day.

The National Executive Committee of the MWWL decided to exclude Tamaki from the presidential ballot and omitted to send the ballot to thirteen league branches that the committee regarded as associated with the Destiny Church, justifying its actions on the basis of protecting the league’s constitutional commitment to non-sectarianism.

Tamaki took the league to Court.

Was this a case of the ‘old guard’ improperly attempting to retain control of an organisation in the face of new membership or an underhanded attempt by the Destiny Church to stack the deck?”

Alex Casey: What is the best New Zealand jingle of all time?

“Jingles are the great unifier of our fair nation. A high level source confirmed that even the All Blacks sing jingles together because they are the only tunes that everyone knows apart from the national anthem. Jump onto any party bus at a certain hour of the night and you’ll be guaranteed to slay with a rousing rendition of ‘Tony’s Tyre Service’. Stuck in a quiet elevator? Mutter “cats prefer Chef” and see just how many soft meows you get back.

Over the past week or so, New Zealand jingles have taken over my life. I’ve thought about them more than I’ve ever thought about anything, I’ve talked about them with basically everyone I’ve come into contact with, I’ve gasped awake several times with CAROLINE EVE, YOU WEAR IT SOOOO WELLLLLLL tearing through my brain.

There’s also been a lot of fierce discussion in the office about what is and isn’t a jingle, with the utterance “that’s not a jingle, that’s a song sung by fleas as part of a skit” being made aloud by one anonymous Spinoff staffer. But which New Zealand jingle is the very best? Based on my research across social media, asking various celebrities and canvassing strangers on the street, here are my findings from worst to best.”

Emily Writes: How childbirth works, according to a man

“I was interested to hear pregnant people can plan when they go into labour. Can you explain that to me?

Of course sweetheart! So, the way it works is a baby is in the baby home for nine months. When you get to nine months, you go to the hospital and the baby comes out the baby hole.

Oh. I had my both of my babies at 37 weeks-

Darling listen, this is how babies work. They come out after nine months. They grow and grow and then they come out. You need to hold them in until then. You can cross your legs.

I feel like that’s not-

It’s science sugar tits. I have read the Wikipedia page on birth three times since this whole drama came out. The way it works is you put on the calendar the day that you’ll have had the baby in the baby home for nine months and then when it’s that time you go to the hospital the day before. Don’t go on the day of. That’s just asking for trouble isn’t it? If you go the day of, the baby might come early and you might be caught out. That’s hardly the fault of the DHB is it chicky?

But what about premature babies?

They don’t exist.”

Illustration: Toby Morris.

Murray Brewer: The tax empathy gap: Why Kiwis don’t want others to have a share

“Kiwis see the likes of universal superannuation and free healthcare as their birthright. Yet these same New Zealanders are known to wring their hands in outrage over social good spending such as Treaty of Waitangi claims. The fiscal reality is that two months of this year’s superannuation payments would cover the last 20 years’ worth of Treaty settlements.

There is a name for this emotional response to money. Mental accounting is the theory that people think of value in relative rather than absolute terms.

Stick with me because it explains a lot, and the recent extreme reaction to the government’s plans for a capital gains tax (CGT) is a good example.”

Josie Adams: I survived the Waiheke ferry

A watery war zone has emerged in New Zealand’s biggest city, with Waiheke-Auckland ferry cutbacks leaving abandoned souls desperate for home and hungry for retribution. Josie Adams risks everything to experience the nation’s most hostile ferry journey.

Don Rowe: There are eleven more bodies on Everest

“Like a Monday night at the self-service, they’re stacked back-to-back-to-back in their puffy jackets, jostling in crampons, huffing on bootleg oxygen canisters and quite literally starving for oxygen as they crawl over actual dead bodies in a manic shitfight to reach the top of the world.

“Some people lose their sense of decency,” reports the New York Times.

The regulatory environment in Nepal is all but non-existent and the government refuses to stop issuing permits and so the mountain itself is open to the beautiful free market, which brings $20-30m a year and about 300 corpses to the region. Everest even has its own insurance scams.

There’s just one week in May where the weather means you might have a shot at the summit. The decision on who gets to go is made by storefront cowboy operators in Kathmandu. But the line is too long now and half the climbers shouldn’t be there anyway. When the oxygen runs out, sherpas are asked to hand over their own. Sherpas have been agitating for better treatment for 100 years straight.”

Keep going!
Jacinda Ardern world

PoliticsMay 31, 2019

‘A beacon for the world’: What foreign media is saying about the Budget

Jacinda Ardern world

What did international coverage get right about the 2019 Budget? Not a hell of a lot, writes Alex Braae.

“I read the foreign news to understand my nation.” So said Matt Berninger of band The National, in a line from the song ‘Fashion Coat’.

The government’s 2019 budget – the first ever Wellbeing Budget at that – has been a big deal overseas. Many international media outlets and commentators have run articles that capture the vibe of what the government was going for. But does Berninger’s pithy aphorism hold true when it’s applied to the budget?

Many of the journalists filing for international outlets are actually based in New Zealand, and reporting from the ground here. But the shift in tone – from granular local reporting to foreign correspondent – is still notable, with many articles taking a broad brush approach to the budget and what it means for New Zealand.

Let’s start with the best of the bunch and work our way down. Top of the list is the New York Times, the famed Grey Lady and leading light of coastal American liberalism. In an article by NZ-based journalist Charlotte Graham-McLay, the overall thrust of the budget and its focus on ‘wellbeing’ measures other than GDP was given strong backing. London School of Economics professor Richard Layard was quoted saying the budget was a “game changing event,” as “no other major country has so explicitly adopted well-being as its objective.”

Then there’s the Guardian, which has become one of the biggest news websites in the world and by far the largest liberal outlet. Again, their piece was written by an NZ-based journalist, in this case Eleanor Ainge-Roy. There the major focus was on the major investment in mental health services, with plenty of voices expressing support for the budget, and only a few lines of opposition from the National party. In fairness to Ainge-Roy, she’s no government shill – this week she has also written about the massive teacher strike, the absurd Treasury website bungle, and the stock photo model on the cover of the budget moving to Australia.

On Al-Jazeera, a story attributed to ‘news agencies’ framed the Wellbeing Budget as a move set to “cement Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern’s reputation for compassionate leadership.” It added that “the New Zealand leader, widely praised for her respectful handling of the March shooting in which 51 Muslims were killed at two mosques, said the budget put people before economic indicators.” The article also gave significant space down page to the views of National’s Amy Adams.

Major international thinkers were also showing support on Twitter. Economist Rutger Bregman, the guy who told the rich people off at Davos, said New Zealand was “a beacon for the world. First major country that realizes the time for GDP is over.” And prominent English journalist Caitlin Moran said it was “an unbelievably thrilling alternate way of doing politics. We know infinite economic growth is impossible, and fucking hell what an exciting idea.”

An American based site called Common Dreams went even further, headlining their story with “Applause for New Zealand ‘Wellbeing Budget’ That Dedicates Billions to Mental Health Care and Ending Child Poverty.” And it included this rather telling comparative paragraph:

“The wellbeing budget represented a stark contrast to the spending priorities of other wealthy countries like the U.K.—where the past decade’s austerity policies prompted a recent rebuke from the U.N.’s human rights expert—and the U.S., where the Trump administration proposed hiking military spending by $34 billion in March while claiming $1.1 trillion in Medicaid cuts were necessary.”

Somehow Common Dreams failed to notice the big boost in defence spending in the Wellbeing Budget.

The New Zealand portrayed in these overseas publications isn’t necessarily one that a lot of New Zealanders will recognise. It’s a New Zealand seemingly depicted entirely through the personage of Jacinda Ardern herself. That’s not intended to be a slight on the PM, it’s just that her day to day job doesn’t actually involve an awful lot of being painted in giant murals, or being feted by leaders of some of the most important countries in the world at major international summits. The press gallery don’t tend to greet the PM with a rousing chorus of Yaas Kween.

International readers who are vaguely interested in New Zealand’s politics probably don’t actually care all that much that most of what was announced yesterday was heavily contested from many different and diverse perspectives. Going by much of that overseas coverage, it appears that what they’re really interested in reading about is an avatar for a better world, one that they wish they lived in. New Zealand, the country so fantastical that some people don’t even believe it really exists, is a beautiful dream for many people in countries like the USA and Britain that are governed by grotesque oafs.

Fortunately, the Daily Mail is always there to restore some balance. Ben Hill, formerly of the NZ Herald, filed a piece introduced with the following paragraph: “Jacinda Ardern’s ‘kooky’ plans to spend $26BILLION on a ‘wellbeing’ Budget will devastate New Zealand and force Kiwis to flee to Australia – and even the mum on the cover has crossed the ditch due to cost of living.” The article is heavily based on comments from some rabid Australian commentators on a talkback radio show.

When that’s the quality of the analysis, it’s probably better to ignore Matt Berninger’s advice entirely, and stick to local news sources.

This article has been edited slightly for clarity since it was first published.