spinofflive
debatefeat-850×408

PoliticsOctober 10, 2016

Moon landing: fake or real? And other public-submitted questions for Hillary and Donald

debatefeat-850×408

For the second presidential debate between Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump, the American people of the internet have been asked to submit their own ideas for questions. Toby Manhire goes in search of some of the best

America is all about its ‘of the people, by the people, for the people’ ethos, and when Abraham Lincoln thought that one up he almost certainly had in mind the potential for the internet to crowdsource questions for presidential debates.

That vision has been realised thanks to the Open Debate Coalition, which has successfully arranged for the second presidential debate, a “town hall”-style affair on Sunday (Monday, NZ time), to involve questions posed via its website.

whatwouldyouask

Users can then vote in support of particular questions, with “Would you support requiring criminal background checks for all gun sales?” currently leading the pack, backed by more than 35,000 people and counting. That’s a good one, they should definitely ask that, but there are a bunch of other good ones, too, languishing with rather fewer user votes, and we hope they get asked, too.

Here are 20 of them:

1.

presqu11

Terrific wall-based question, Jared! This really would be good to ask.

2.presqu9

Only two votes so far for Tiffany’s moral dilemma (no, me neither) but this clearly needs to be put to the would-be free-world leaders.

3.

will you hit the nuclear button on impact and blame votersYidong may have been reading too many Marvel comics, but on the other hand this could catch Trump out.

4.

presqu12

Good thinking, Michael: instead of a debate, just read out the URLs of your websites and then fuck off.

5.

presqu1

Yes or no.

The future President Trump (artist's impression)
The future President Trump (artist’s impression)

6.

presqu2 Best dinner party eva.

7.presqu3

The government doesn’t like people posing questions about its legislative assaults on freedom, and it’s pretty clear that in this instance they got to him before he could finish. RIP Gary.

8.presqu23

Countries such as New Zealand and The Vatican have been plagued with violent Islamic rule, so it’s little wonder that Geraldo wants to know what you plan to do about it.

9.

presqu6

The anti-Godwin.

10.

presqu7

True, the American education system could use some work.

11.

presqu8

U OK, Ross?

12.    presqu13

And get the Mexicans to pay for it.

13.presqu14

Actually this could be a genuinely good one. Thanks again, Tiffany S.

14.  presqu16

Especially keen to hear Mr Trump’s thoughts on this.

15.

ghostbusters controversy trump clinton

Especially keen to hear Mr Trump’s thoughts on this, too.

As president, what will you do about female comedians in jumpsuits?
As president, what will you do about female comedians in jumpsuits?

16.

is globalm warming a conspiracy by israelDon’t just tell Hotman, tell us all.

17.

presqu18

Oui, quel est-ce?

18.

presqu19 Kinda meta but chuck this at the candidates and see how they get on.

19.

how big is your stash

Strange when you think about it that “How big is your stash?” hasn’t been asked in a presidential debate before. Thanks, Bob!

20.

presqu20

Phil Goff campaign posters, October 2016
Phil Goff campaign posters, October 2016

AucklandOctober 8, 2016

The War for Auckland is over! Here’s who won what…

Phil Goff campaign posters, October 2016
Phil Goff campaign posters, October 2016

You won’t believe who’s won the Auckland mayoralty race (you will), and all the other outcomes of interest.

And the new Mayor of Auckland is …

They tried, oh how they tried, to sex up the contest. Guyon Espiner called the leadup to Phil Goff’s candidacy announcement “the longest striptease in history”; Hayden Donnell made reference at every opportunity to his (ie Goff’s) “single unshakeable multi-decade-spanning coitus”.

But in truth Aucklanders had probably had their fill of Supercity mayoral sauciness for the millennium, and the solid, reliable, predictable Phil Goff was always going to prevail.

Provisional results give Goff 179,206 votes, or nearly 48% of the total. Vic Crone did better than polling had predicted, finishing second with 105,413. That result is familiar: three years ago, the centre-left Len Brown recorded 164,338 votes against his main rival from the right, John Palino, on 108,928.


Here’s Mayor Goff’s acceptance speech, via RNZ:

Swarbrick and the rest

The surge of the Chloenator and her Swar for Auckland turned out to be more than a flash in the local body pan, and the candidate whose age isn’t really important but she is only 22, came an impressive third, with 26,474 of the vote, despite a campaign resourced by little more than a Sim card and a Buzz Bar.

John Palino finished on 21,398, and the most tragic man in New Zealand, Mark Thomas, on 9,170.

And only 6,577 people recognised that Penny Bright should be in charge.

In Wellington, which is another city in New Zealand, Justin Lester is the new mayor.

Who cares anyway?

Turnout is up a smidgen from last election’s historic low. At this stage, with a touch over 376,000 votes counted, 36.5% of registered voters returned their ballots. At the same stage in 2013, the figure was 34.3%, and the final turnout was 34.7% – a drop of more than 15% from 2010.

Would it have been higher if Goff wasn’t seen as such a clear favourite? Maybe. But it’s a pretty serious problem.

And the ones that really matter …

The new Auckland Council will comprise Phil Goff and the following:

Albert-Eden-Roskill: Cathy Casey and Christine Fletcher.

Albany: John Watson and Wayne Walker.

Franklin: Bill Cashmore (Big Bill the Boss of Franklin elected unopposed).

Howick: Sharon Stewart and Dick Quax.

Manukau: Alf Filipaina and Fa’anana Efeso Collins.

Manurewa-Papakura: Daniel Newman, John Walker (Calum Penrose unexpectedly jettisoned by voters).

Maungakiekie-Tāmaki: Denise Krum.

North Shore: Chris Darby and, get this, Richard Hills or Grant Gillon (Too close to call at this stage – Hills and Gillon will be permanently mopping sweat until the final result, specials included, are published on Thursday).

Orākei: Desley Simpson (by a huge margin).

Rodney: Greg Sayers (incumbent Penny Webster a surprise loss here).

Waitākere: Penny Hulse and Linda Cooper.

Waitematā and Gulf: Mike Lee (the polarising political veteran wins by a small margin over the polarising media veteran Bill Ralston).

Whau: Ross Clow.

What does all that mean?

Hard to say exactly. Assuming Hills holds on, it means the 20 councillors’ tickets break down as follows:

Auckland Future (rightish): 1

City Vision (leftish): 1

Communities & Residents (rightish): 2

Labour (leftish): 3

Independent or ward-specific ticket: 13

As for the local boards, again far the most are independent, unaligned or under ward-specific banners – 94 of them. Labour has 26, Communities & Residents 11, City Vision 9, and Auckland Future 6.

And as far as the Spinoff’s War for Auckland endorsed council candidates (some endorsed with heavy hearts, pegs on noses, mind you):

People who became councillors probably because they were endorsed by Spinoff website: 13 (plus Goff)

People who somehow became councillors despite not being endorsed by Spinoff website: 7

What does Leroy Beckett of youth rabble Generation Zero make of it all?

“Overall this new council based on our scores averages to a B,” he said in a message that actually began “Haha from the pub”. He continued: “We are thrilled to see candidates we scored A+ Richard Hills and Efeso Collins join council, as well as a number of great current councillors return. Young candidates did incredibly well, from Chloe Swarbrick coming third against better financed candidates, to Adrianna Christie jointing the Waitemata Local Board. There hasn’t been a big shift , a face lift without any real change, shows Aucklanders are overall happy with the progress we have made over the past three years.”

Meanwhile …

A recording has emerged showing a man who could  become the president of the United States boasting about sexually harassing women.

Nb This has nothing to do with the Auckland local body election but FFS is the world even real any more?

And now …

For the new mayor and new council to show whether they’re up to the task of building a future worthy of Aucklanders, for a deputy mayor to be appointed (Penny Hulse again? Bill Cashmore? Even Desley Simpson?) And the small matter of a byelection in Mt Roskill.