In defence of MMP
Rawiri Waititi and Harry Mowbray both advocated for an overhand result, on opposite ends of the political sprectrum
Overhangs are kind of the whole point.
New Zealand's next parliament will be its biggest yet. On provisional results, 131 MPs will take their seats, 11 more than the usual 120. Both Te Pāti Māori and National, the main party of the centre right, won more electorates than their shares of the party vote entitle them to. Under our mixed member proportional (MMP) system, they keep the lot, and the size of the House simply grows.
Not everyone is pleased with this result. Forty six academics and commentators, led by Andrew Geddis, Lara Greaves and Max Rashbrooke, have signed an open letter entitled "Keep the 'P' in MMP". Geddis told RNZ that the result was "definitely not the way MMP was supposed to work". The signatories want a select committee to fix things before the next election.
But they have it backwards. This is precisely how MMP was supposed to work.
The clue is on the ballot paper. Each New Zealander gets two votes: one for their preferred local candidate, one for a party. The very point of the system is that they might use them differently. Had the designers wanted local and national preferences to line up, a single vote would have done just that.
This year, indeed much more than in the past, voters took the hint. National's candidates won about 41% of the electorate vote; the party managed only about 29% of the party vote. Geddis himself calls National's seven extra seats "more like an organic result". Hundreds of thousands of people, in other words, like their local National MP but cast their party vote elsewhere. In the Māori electorates, many voters picked Te Pāti Māori candidates while giving their party vote to Labour or the Greens – an outcome campaigned for by Te Pāti Māori itself, netting the party four extra seats.
The overhangs didn't slip in through a loophole. The Electoral Act provides for them explicitly: a candidate who wins the most votes in a seat is not turfed out to tidy the arithmetic. The royal commission that designed the system in 1986 thought large overhangs unlikely. Unlikely is not impossible, and a rule written for an outcome is decent evidence that at least someone foresaw it. Overhangs have occurred at five previous elections, each adding a seat or two, without anyone reaching for a pen. And, though this one is bigger, its scale does not make it a design flaw. The alarm is better seen as a reaction to the vicissitudes of electoral results rather than a critical fault in the machinery itself.
Moreover, New Zealanders chose this. They voted for MMP in 1992 and 1993, and opted to keep it in 2011. What they chose was a system that lets them split their votes. To declare it broken because they did so is odd.
The critics' best argument is historical. In 1978 and 1981 Labour won more votes than National, yet National formed the government, a perversity that helped kill first past the post. Geddis warns that the overhang could hand a three-party coalition a majority of seats on fewer party votes than the other four parties combined. But the parallel is inexact. In 1981 the voting system overrode voters' choices, whereas this year's result flows from voters' choices. While the party vote sets the baseline for proportionality, MMP deliberately subordinates the strict cleanliness of mathematical proportionality to local representation whenever the two collide. Voters who split their tickets to back a local candidate over a party list are actively choosing to weight local representation higher and that is rightly represented in the outcome.
Critics may retort that no voter chose an 11-seat overhang. True, but no voter chooses a parliament either. Elections exist to aggregate millions of individual decisions into a collective judgement. That is not a bug in democracy. It is, to call upon a fan favourite, democracy manifest.
That is a judgement renewed every three years. An election is not merely a verdict on parties; it lets citizens weigh the state of the country, its institutions included, and back whatever agenda they think serves them best. The royal commission predicted that deliberate manipulation would "attract an electoral backlash." If voters think the split voting went too far, they can say so in 2029. For parliament to rush through a law against an outcome the electorate delivered only weeks earlier would be unseemly, and arguably at odds with the very mandate it has just received.
None of this rules out reform, of course. If MPs wish to tinker, they may be better served to strengthen proportionality rather than penalise split-voting, perhaps by restoring the share of list seats, which has slipped from 55 in 1996 to 49 today, or lowering the 5% threshold, which so often wastes swathes of party votes. Regardless, the result of the recent election was one squarely within the contemplation of its framers and unworthy of the nation's alarm.
Tom Peoples
Tom Peoples is a public and regulatory lawyer. He holds a Master of Laws, has been a visiting scholar at George Washington University in Washington, DC, and previously worked as a political advisor in the 53rd Parliament. More recently, he was Senior Legal Advisor for the Parliamentary Service.