Manurewa High School students with Alexia Hilbertidou (centre). (Image: Ambure Giborees, MHS)
Manurewa High School students with Alexia Hilbertidou (centre). (Image: Ambure Giborees, MHS)

SocietyNovember 16, 2019

The gender chasm in STEM – and those working to close it

Manurewa High School students with Alexia Hilbertidou (centre). (Image: Ambure Giborees, MHS)
Manurewa High School students with Alexia Hilbertidou (centre). (Image: Ambure Giborees, MHS)

Hannah Kronast attends a women’s empowerment panel focused on the huge disparities in training and employment within science and technology. 

In the far back left-hand corner of a women’s equality and empowerment event, a male stuck up his hand. “What can men do to help?” he asked.

It was at a panel discussion earlier this month hosted by the Women’s Infrastructure Network and the Human Rights Commission and the male infiltration was welcomed. Influential New Zealand women had been assembled to encourage future influential New Zealand women to challenge the gender boundaries in employment and leadership in science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM). And the network has recently opened up its doors to allow more men to enter the conversation.

While women make up 64% of Bachelor of Science students, they’re over-represented in the health sciences and significantly under-represented in engineering and technology. Women represent less than a quarter of students studying engineering, just over a third studying IT. In the workforce, women make up just 13% of engineers.

Research also shows significant income gender disparity within Bachelor of Science graduates. More women science grads earn $50,000 or less, and more men earn larger salaries. Women in New Zealand are also under-represented in leadership roles in the research and academic sectors.

Alexia Hilbertidou was 16-years-old when she won a nationwide coding competition. She’d worked hard to prepare for it and was ecstatic when she found out she had won.  “I was thrilled, this was my moment. I was 16 and I was on track to achieve my dreams and have a safe, secure, glamorous path into technology, something I had dreamed about since I was 8.”

When she entered her male-dominated IT class on her first day back at school she expected high fives, a standing ovation even. Instead, her classmates told her she had only won because she was a girl.

“I remember sitting there at 16 and this being a really defining moment for me. And after six months of putting up with insults I really broke down.”

She bounced back to create Girlboss, an organisation encouraging young women to consider careers in STEM and leadership.

This is why Hilbertidou wants men to join the movement to remove barriers for women entering studying and working in STEM fields. While numbers are slowly rising with the help of initiatives focused on women empowering women, men also have an essential part to play in the success of the movement.

Dr Sophie Dawson, Saunoamaali’i Dr Karanina Sumeo, and Alexia Hilbertidou. (Image: HRC).

Hilbertidou was part of the panel discussion, held at the EY offices in Auckland’s Takutai Square, with the Minister for Women Julie Anne Genter, Equal Employment Commissioner Saunoamaali’i Dr Karanina Sumeo, and EY’s Associate Director Dr Sophie Dawson. The four women had recently returned from the Commission on the Status of Women at the United Nations conference in New York. There they’d explored social protection systems, access to public services and sustainable infrastructure for gender equality and the empowerment of women and girls.

When the question from the male at the back of the room came up, each of them almost jumped to grab the microphone. Dawson took the mic with personal intent; her friend’s daughter who had been interested in science was told at the age of six that it wasn’t for her by other students in her class. She emphasised the importance of men helping and being more vocal about the issue.

“Men do tend to listen to other men and so if you do have some men that are supporting these changes then I think that the message will become more widespread and more people will become involved and changes will happen.”

She also noted that men can be hugely influential in whether a female gets the opportunity to travel these challenging paths and therefore it is crucial that they get involved. Dawson encouraged men to consider mentoring along with advocating for equality with their colleagues.

Hilbertidou started by thanking the four men at the event for coming. She encouraged more men to join at future events and said although it may be a little bit awkward to be in a room full of women, she guaranteed it wouldn’t be as awkward as it often feels to be a lone female in a STEM class. Her experiences were even more awkward because she didn’t fit what a stereotypical woman in STEM looks like.

“It wasn’t easy being a short, brown, outspoken female in this environment but I stuck at it,” she said.

She definitely isn’t the quiet-hiding-behind-glasses type. She wore a hot pink jacket. The panel’s diversity also showed that a woman in STEM can look like, act like, and be interested in anything. Dawson was more reserved but spoke passionately about her family and career which included designing the Airbus A380’s air conditioning. Sumeo held the motherly wisdom, and Genter’s political determination was steadfast. But one thing each of these women had in common was their drive and intelligence.

Hilbertidou said that having someone to aspire to be is super important, as women often need to be able to picture themselves in a role before believing they can do it. And that’s what the panel was doing that day. Harleen Bhathal, a year 12 student from Manurewa High School who attended the event with her peers as part of a partnership with EY, said she felt inspired by the speakers. She had previously talked herself out of trying a career in politics because it was daunting as a girl, but events like this empowered her to feel like she could do anything.

“For a bit I felt like I didn’t want to go into politics because everywhere I’d go, even to events, I’d just see a bunch of men and it’s kind of daunting being the only small girl in a room. But I really think that this event has just opened my eyes up again.”

Keep going!
Photo: Alex Casey
Photo: Alex Casey

SocietyNovember 16, 2019

Six things to celebrate this Transgender Awareness week

Photo: Alex Casey
Photo: Alex Casey

Based on their study of trans wellbeing Aotearoa, the research team at Counting Ourselves find six data points that highlight the strength of our trans and non-binary community.

Last month the first comprehensive national survey on transgender health and wellbeing in Aotearoa was published by the academics and researchers at Counting Ourselves. Exploring the lives of 1,178 trans and non-binary people, the community report showed shocking levels of violence and discrimination, severe health inequities, and hardship. 

However, it also revealed some surprising and inspiring ways that trans communities live and support each other. To mark Transgender Awareness Week, researchers involved with the project have identified six reasons to celebrate.

1. Being trans improves our quality of life

Almost two-thirds of participants in the study (65%) reported that their quality of life had improved since identifying as trans or non-binary. This is despite most trans and non-binary people reporting high levels of psychological distress, depression and anxiety. These often make people see the world through a negative filter, so to have such a high proportion of participants rate their quality of life positively shows just how important it is to be true to ourselves. 

Being accepted and affirmed by my family and whānau in my preferred gender improved my mental health. (Trans man, youth) 

It’s been nearly two years and I haven’t stopped having ‘happy’ as my baseline mood. I love life and I love who I am, which is a stark contrast from before. (Trans man, adult) 

The effect on my mental health of realising I was trans was profound. A year ago, I would have answered ‘most/all of the time’ to most of the questions [about mental health problems] on the previous page, and that has been the status quo for as long as I can remember. The change was noticed by others in my life, even before I came out to them. (Trans woman, youth)

Photo: Alex Casey

2. We are proud to be trans 

While our report shows clear evidence that stigma and discrimination still exists for trans and non-binary people in Aotearoa New Zealand, pride in ourselves is an important step in reducing the impacts of stigma on how we feel about ourselves. It is heartening that most Counting Ourselves participants (62%) felt proud to be trans or non-binary. 

I hugely value the role model trans people, that allow themselves to be seen. They have helped me greatly to accept being transgender. (Non-binary, older adult)

3. Trans people are supporting each other 

While the report demonstrates a clear need for support from the wider community, it also shows how trans and non-binary people are filling many of the current gaps. More than half of participants reported that they provided a lot of support for or felt connected to other trans or non-binary people, and it’s making a difference.

I feel very connected to the trans community in Wellington through volunteer work, it’s important to me that young trans folk never have to deal with any of the internalised issues that held me back from coming out for so long. (Trans woman, adult)

I feel like I’m a part of a community for the first time in my life. (Trans woman, older adult)

A rally in support of transgender people on the steps of New York City Hall. Photo: Getty Images

4. Whānau support is growing

Trans and non-binary people don’t exist in isolation, we are a part of families, cultural communities, social networks, schools, and workplaces. Some Counting Ourselves findings on these topics give us cause to be hopeful for our futures.

Many trans and non-binary participants had a lot of support within their whānau. Out of survey participants whose whānau knew they were trans or non-binary, more than half (57%) reported that most or all of their family supported them. Younger people were more likely to have this support.

My children are very supportive and are more than happy to go places in public, just not an issue with them. Love them to bits. (Trans woman, older adult) 

I love my family. It was a transition for all of us, but we got there. (Trans woman, adult)

My family’s cultural background has a strong tradition of gender variance and this has helped me a lot in terms of understanding and making peace with what I am. (Trans man, adult).

5. Connections to other trans students make school a safe place to learn 

The survey was completed by 93 trans and non-binary secondary school students. Four out of five (80%) reported that their school provided a safe space to meet other trans and non-binary students. This level of connection to other trans and non-binary people is something most of us who are older could have only dreamed of.

We have an LGBT club, good counsellors, and (a few bad) gender neutral bathrooms. [Our] teachers and principal are good – [they are] trying their best. (Trans man, youth)

It is an “all-girls school”, although I know quite a few trans/non-binary kids, and nearly all of my friend group isn’t cisgender. (Trans man, youth) 

Illustration by Sam Orchard

6. Supportive work colleagues lighten the load

While many participants had not told their work colleagues that they were trans or non-binary, our findings were more positive for those who had. More than three quarters of participants (79%) reported that these work colleagues were mostly supportive.

I think I was able to face transition mainly due to the support and respect that my workplace and fellow employees provided. (Trans woman, adult)

Trans and non-binary people face many difficulties, but Transgender Awareness Week is an opportunity to show the difference that support makes and for people to step up and walk beside us. For anyone reading this who isn’t trans or non-binary, here are some of the things you can do to support us this Transgender Awareness Week:

  1. Support and advocate for trans and non-binary people in your family, school, workplace or community. Even if you are not sure if you know any trans people, making a safe space might do more good than you expect. 
  2.  Attend Transgender Awareness Week events, including the Gala in Wellington this Saturday at the Newtown Community and Cultural Centre. The stalls are open from 11am to 5pm, followed by the Wellington launch of our Counting Ourselves report.
  3.  Attend a local Transgender Day of Remembrance event or take time to remember those trans people who have been victims of murder and to commit to creating a safer, non-violent world for all of us. 
  4. Read the Counting Ourselves community report to learn more about the issues trans and non-binary people face and what you can do to help build a brighter future. 

Transgender Awareness Week runs for the week leading up to Transgender Day of Remembrance (TDoR) on 20 November; a sombre day first held in Massachusetts 20 years ago and now marked in all regions of the world. On TDoR we encourage you to speak out against the transphobic violence towards our communities, and remember those who are no longer with us due to trans-based violence. In previous commemorations in Aotearoa, we have stood together in churches and public spaces and read out the names of the trans people, who have been murdered, so that they are not forgotten.