spinofflive
shot-put-final-feat.jpg

SportsDecember 23, 2024

How was Maddi Wesche’s final shot put throw not over 20m? A Spinoff investigation

shot-put-final-feat.jpg

Summer reissue: Was it a false measurement, a full-blown conspiracy or just some mild incompetence? Mad Chapman uncovers the truth of Maddi Wesche’s final throw.

The Spinoff needs to double the number of paying members we have to continue telling these kinds of stories. Please read our open letter and sign up to be a member today.

First things first: Maddison-Lee Wesche is a hero and a legend. After placing sixth at the Tokyo Olympics, Wesche threw a lifetime best to win an Olympic silver medal in the women’s shot put this morning. She wasn’t expected to be on the podium based off her personal best and season’s best so to come out and throw better than you’ve ever thrown in your life (and in poor conditions at that) is an objectively baller move and I look forward to seeing her in Los Angeles in 2028.

At the same time, the shot put final delivered everything a spectator could wish for in a field event. Already all bets were off as the throwers were competing in the pouring rain, meaning a slick circle and no saying who would adjust to the conditions the best. Leading after three throws, Wesche was in pole position for the final three, able to throw last and respond to anyone who might take the lead from her.

And the lead was taken more than once. German thrower and favourite to win Yemsis Ogunyele took the lead with her fifth throw of 19.73m. Then Wesche responded with a PB of 19.86m to snatch it right back. With only two throws left in the whole event, Ogunyele threw a massive 20.00m with her final throw, taking the lead again. Wesche had the final throw of the competition mere moments later. She prepared her throw as Ogunyele was still weeping with joy on the track nearby.

Outside of everything else, this is an incredible shot

And Wesche threw another massive one. So massive it landed very clearly beyond the white 20m tape and eerily close to Ogunyele’s final attempt. It looked like another PB and enough to take the lead and the gold medal back for the last time.

Then the measurement flashed on the screen as… 19.58m.

I’m sorry, what?

Let’s start from the beginning.

Here are the white tape marks in the shot put, indicating some key distances – in this case 18m and 20m. The white tape can move throughout the event, especially if shots land on it and roll over it, but generally an implement landing squarely on the tape would be within 10cm or so of the marker distance.

At the same time, for some reason the shot put in particular always has markers that feel misplaced.

Here is where Wesche’s early leading throw of 19.68m landed.

Some early dusty work from the camera operator but you get the idea

On first glance it looked a bit further than 19.68m, given how close it landed to the tape. So sure, perhaps a throw on or just past the 20m tape would not be measured as 20m but it’s not too far off.

And so it was proven when Ogunyele’s final throw landed here and was measured at exactly 20.00m.

The 20m tape and the actual 20m throw

So Wesche had her work cut out for her in her final throw. But she produced a big one, and again on first glance it looked to have landed comfortably beyond the 20m tape, even further than Ogunyele’s one.

There was a quick replay that still looked confusing, and for some reason, the man with the marker stick ran to stand just beyond the 20m tape.

What are you doing over there?

All the New Zealand viewers at home were confused. It looked so much further than that, and even landing there it surely was further than 19.58m? The NZ Olympics Instagram post celebrating Wesche’s silver medal moments later was flooded with calls for a remeasure and mild conspiracy theories about the coverage, the lack of another replay and the man with the measuring tape.

I put on my investigator cap (read: recorded the TV with my phone) to figure out where exactly the throw landed.

The answer? We’ll never know.

Turns out, what we all saw at home was in fact the second bounce of Wesche’s throw, which was comfortably beyond the 20m tape and would’ve won the gold. Where was the first bounce? It was off-screen. Whoever was operating the camera at the shot put was too slow in panning and the shot flew out of frame in the moment it hit the ground.

This is the moment it hit the ground.

The world’s hardest game of eye-spy because there’s no shot put in this frame

And here is where we all thought it hit the ground because this was the first time we saw it onscreen.

So you see? Sadly there was no conspiracy to overthrow Wesche’s lead nor was there gross incompetence from the man holding the measuring tape. Wesche’s reaction to her throw suggests she knew it wasn’t far enough, though she looked positively stoked with her performance regardless, as she should be.

Maddi Wesche threw a career best 19.86m to win a silver medal at the Olympics. Whoever was operating the camera and missed her final throw did not win a medal.

First published August 10, 2024.

Keep going!
a pink background, with logos of the TAB and its subsidary betcha showing someone golfing and a young woman sitting on a fake horse on instagram
Gambling events are now designed to photograph well for Instagram. (Image: Screenshots/The Spinoff)

InternetDecember 20, 2024

How the gambling industry is using influencers to appeal to a new generation

a pink background, with logos of the TAB and its subsidary betcha showing someone golfing and a young woman sitting on a fake horse on instagram
Gambling events are now designed to photograph well for Instagram. (Image: Screenshots/The Spinoff)

From paid partnerships and podcasts to ‘party holes’, the TAB and its youth-focused subsidiary Betcha are making a concerted effort to attract young people to gambling. Shanti Mathias reports. 

A group of men are crowded around a golf green, waiting for a ball. When it’s successfully putted into the hole, they start cheering. I swipe to the next video. A lean, muscled man does some training outside, puts on a NZ Warriors T-shirt, eats a healthy lunch, then has a “flutter” on the TAB app. “You’ve worked hard for this life, enjoy every minute of it,” someone writes in the comments. Another Instagram Reel. A group of women get dressed up to go to the races, partying in a tent full of disco balls, then leaning close to the race track to watch the horses galloping by. The next video is an ongoing segment in which two men discuss whether they’ll “bet or forget” on upcoming competitions. 

This is a universe of paid partnerships, sponsored podcasts, exclusive invites for influencers and underneath it all, gambling, all carefully choreographed and reduced to catchy Instagram Reels. Many of these posts have been paid for: individuals with significant social media followings (usually upwards of 5,000 followers) receive money and other perks, like free tickets to events, food or transport costs; in exchange, brands usually get to vet the content that is posted, and are tagged in videos or photos.

It’s been more than a year since TAB, New Zealand’s only licensed betting platform, partnered with the London Stock Exchange-listed gambling giant Entain. Entain committed $900m in investment to take over the TAB’s betting and broadcasting operations for 25 years. Since then, even while many companies have been cutting their advertising spend, the TAB and its youth-focused subsidiary Betcha has been everywhere: billboards, TV, podcasts, radio and your Instagram feed. The generation of people who grew up going down to the TAB to place bets on the horses is getting older: the gambling industry needs young people to get involved. 

a pink background and screenshot of an instagram post showing someone using the TAB app
Some Instagram posts show people using the TAB app. Most sports betting in New Zealand now happens online. (Image: Screenshot)

Murky regulation

Gambling advertising is regulated by the Advertising Standards Authority. Influencers and athletes have run into trouble in recent years promoting gambling via social media, including former New Zealand cricketer and England test coach Brendon McCullum, who ended his partnership with online gambling company 22Bet after the Problem Gambling Foundation complained to the Department of Internal Affairs about his YouTube posts promoting it (only Lotto NZ and the TAB are allowed to advertise gambling in New Zealand). DIA was unable to take action due to YouTube being an overseas company. He was also investigated by the English Cricket Board.

Māori influencers, meanwhile, have spoken out against online casinos approaching them to ask for promotion. “The use of this technology for advertising is a relatively new thing,” says Maria Bellringer, director of AUT’s Gambling and Addiction Research Centre.

Some of the influencer posts that are direct paid partnerships with TAB subsidiary Betcha or the TAB itself include a note that says “R18, Gamble Responsibly”, as do some of the videos that the TAB and Betcha post directly. Bellringer points out that this phrase, which is often used in messaging from the gambling industry, is vague. “How am I supposed to know whether I’m gambling responsibly? It doesn’t mean anything, it just pushes the onus onto the gambler.” 

screenshots of two podcasts focusted on sports gambling
Podcasts like Boys Get Paid and The Group Chat discuss gambling with minimal mention of harm reduction. (Image: Screenshots)

Many of the posts The Spinoff found, posted by influencers as well as from the Betcha and TAB accounts, however, do not have any mention of harm reduction resources for gambling. All TAB and Betcha social media accounts include a note in the bio that followers must be above 18, the legal gambling age (and in line with rules that gambling advertising must not be aimed at children and those below 18). Posts that promote events one step removed from gambling, like racing festival The Grand Tour or golf spectacle Chasing The Fox, don’t need to include any such disclosure. 

As a result, Bellringer says, digital promotion of gambling can make messaging around harm reduction less prominent. The Entain “safer gambling” page is linked to in small print at the bottom of the Betcha and TAB websites under a full page of odds for NBA games, the Brazilian women’s football league and a darts championship. “People aren’t going to scroll to find the tiny print,” says Bellringer.

a woman applies makeup in a screenshot of an instagrm post discussing going to the races
In sponsored posts about horse racing, women post about outfits, makeup and ‘good vibes’ (Image: Screenshot)

Marketing ‘a true social experience’

A lot of advertising money in particular has gone to Betcha, a TAB subsidiary launched in August that was developed with the intention of making gambling more accessible for people aged under 35. A few months before the launch, Entain New Zealand’s managing director Cameron Rodger told the NZ Herald the brand would give a group of customers who feel that “TAB isn’t the brand for them or doesn’t resonate with them” a different option, “something that they feel like they can have an identity and connect to”. In a statement to The Spinoff, Rodger said that Betcha makes gambling “a true social experience, emphasising the social and competitive value of sports”.

“The gambling industry, not just here but also in Australia and the UK, is trying to attract a younger demographic to gambling,” says Bellringer. The US, too, has seen much more widespread sports gambling since a Supreme Court ruling in 2018 made it possible for individual states to allow online sports betting. While the TAB’s dark blue and serif font looks more traditional, Betcha’s branding – bright blue and orange, lower case writing – bears an obvious resemblance to trendy sports betting apps from overseas, like the swirl of Draft Kings from the US (orange and green), the minimal black and white of Betway from the UK and Australia’s purple Dabble (sample website review: “active in the community and always helps the punters”). In Australia, particularly, young people have been targeted by at least $287m of gambling industry advertising. 

The most recent comprehensive New Zealand Health and Lifestyles survey, from 2020, showed 14.5% of men in the adult population had gambled via the TAB, while only 7.3% of women had. It’s difficult to establish causality: do more men participate in sports betting because sports in general is seen as a male domain? Or are men more vulnerable to the marketing techniques used by gambling companies? More involvement from women in both sports and betting is clearly on the TAB/Betcha’s wishlist: former White Fern and sports commentator Katey Martin has posted videos promoting Betcha, as has Sky Sports broadcaster Courtney Tairi

a pink background with screenshots of cocotairi and katey martin's instagram accounts with paid betcha partnerships
Female athletes and broadcasters like Courtney Tairi and Katey Martin have partnered with Betcha and emphasised how easy betting is (Image: Screenshots)

Unlike some posts from young men, which explicitly show them placing bets on the TAB website, the posts from women are less direct. A vlog from one influencer shows preparation for a day at the races: an early start for hair and makeup, “making sure we see a horse”, pictures of the “girlies’ feet getting sore” from dancing and the note that “we won $0 lol”.  “We’re going to the races and you’re coming with me,” begins another video showing a day of dancing and snazzy dresses, ending with the note “tell me if you won anything… overall incredible experience”. These posts are tagged as ads for The Grand Tour, a “racing festival” sponsored by Love Racing, a subsidiary of New Zealand Thoroughbred Racing, and Betcha NZ. “The festival aims to re-invigorate a movement around horse racing, reimagining it as a festival-style experience to engage and shift perceptions amongst a younger audience,” reads an article on Stop Press about the events. It is The Grand Tour, rather than Betcha or the racing industry directly, which is paying for a partnership with these influencers. “For the fashion girlies who enjoy days out in the sun and absolute vibes, this is your sign to book your tickets to The Grand Tour,” reads the caption of one Instagram post from a paid partnership with The Grand Tour, complete with pictures of heels and a soundbite from an Addison Rae song.

a screenshot of an instagram post with a TAB logo
While videos from young women emphasise outfits, drinks and photos, TAB logos and mentions of gambling crop up too. (Image: Screenshots)

“There’s a focus on getting young women involved by portraying [racing] as a night out, making it a bit glamorous, a chance to dress up, have fun, have a few drinks, and have some bets at the same time,” says Bellringer. The influencer marketing adds to this: people follow influencers because their lifestyles are desirable. 

Going to the races is one step removed from actually gambling, but the two are intrinsically linked. Ninety percent of the horse racing industry’s money comes from gambling. Of course, portraying horse racing as a fun reason to dress up and get drunk with your friends is nothing new, but in the digital era, Instagram’s tagging system shows how much gambling money is integrated with the whole enterprise.

Influencer marketing works in tandem with real-life events 

Entain says that influencer marketing is just a way to meet audiences where they are. “[Younger people] are generally not consumers of traditional media, so it makes sense for us to communicate through social media and through influencers,” Rodger said, in response to The Spinoff’s questions about Entain’s marketing strategy. Rodger suggested that marketing Betcha and the TAB was a way to prevent New Zealanders from spending money on offshore gambling sites which have no regulation or harm minimisation. “The rise of offshore betting operators in the past decade has been the main barrier for newer generations being able to enjoy and engage in sports betting with the right safeguards in place,” he said.

In New Zealand, the complex web of sponsorships and events takes place offline, too.  Take “Chasing the Fox,” the second iteration of an event held on Friday, December 13 in Auckland that pitted New Zealand golfer Ryan Fox against politicians (David Seymour and John Key), media personalities (Dai Henwood and Jeremy Wells), plus well-known past and present Warriors, All Blacks, Black Caps and Olympians. Its lead sponsor was the TAB, with casino group SkyCity listed as an associate partner and other sponsors including Heineken, Red Bull, American Express and Porsche. A much-hyped “party hole” (the final hole of the six-hole course, turned into a spectator-friendly “party”) was sponsored by Betcha. 

pink background with screenshot showing celebrities featured in chasing the fox like cricketers and john key
Chasing the Fox featured dozens of male celebrities and generated a great deal of social media content. (Image: Screenshots)

The event was promoted heavily in the media (“We’re going to be pretty focused on the party hole, which sounds like something that the Royal Auckland Golf Club has never seen before,” broadcaster Scotty Stevenson, who presented the event’s live coverage on TVNZ, told The Spinoff), and multiple stories appeared in the Herald and in other media outlets. It was all over social media, too, with  “Foxcatcher” merch, posts from Canadian golfer/influencer Mac Boucher, who has 508,000 followers on Instagram, and the Alternative Commentary Collective posting golf reels. None of these pieces of media explicitly endorse gambling: instead, it’s just in the air, part of a fun, summery, celebrity-filled sports event and promoted online and by traditional media alike.

Almost all of the celebrities featured in Chasing the Fox are men, as are many of the influencers who have promoted Betcha and the TAB directly online. Popular account Boys Get Paid, spun out of a Facebook group, now has a podcast under the Alternative Commentary Collective banner, focused on racing. Its Instagram account, with 21,000 followers, posts things like a meme of a baby crying and pointing at a horse, with the caption “when you tell your wife what you want for Christmas”. 

“It’s like old adverts for casinos, with bowties and ballgowns, everyone is drinking cocktails or champagne, famous people are there,” says Bellringer, who scrolled through a number of examples of influencer posts before speaking to The Spinoff. “It makes gambling socially acceptable. It doesn’t show the downsides, or what the real chances of winning are.” 

Rodger says these sponsorships are necessary so that younger New Zealanders gamble “with harm minimisation in place”. But there’s another motivation, too. “The bottom line is that the TAB wouldn’t pay for influencers or events if it wasn’t productive for them,” says Bellringer. 

‘Like a thousand-piece jigsaw puzzle, each member is vital to the whole picture. Join today.’
Calum Henderson
— Production editor
But wait there's more!