spinofflive
The long war between Malcolm Turnbull and Tony Abbott continues (Getty Images)
The long war between Malcolm Turnbull and Tony Abbott continues (Getty Images)

The BulletinApril 13, 2018

The Bulletin: Aussies play politics on NZ’s Manus offer

The long war between Malcolm Turnbull and Tony Abbott continues (Getty Images)
The long war between Malcolm Turnbull and Tony Abbott continues (Getty Images)

Good morning, and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: Australia plays politics with NZ’s refugee offer, National vows to reverse govt’s stance on oil exploration, and dentists warn against getting teeth done overseas.

Behind closed doors, Australia asked New Zealand to keep a rejected offer to take refugees interred on Manus Island on the table, reports Newshub. The Australians wanted New Zealand as a backup option, in case a larger deal to relocated refugees to the USA fell through. The offer to take in 150 refugees has now been in place for five years, but has been rejected due to fears that people relocated to New Zealand would use it as a back door into Australia.

For a bit more context, immigration can be a very harsh battleground in Australian politics. The Guardian reports there is currently a battle going on over discussions of a cut of 20,000 immigrants a year – that’s about 10% of the total intake. Currently the leadership of Malcolm Turnbull is under threat, and as Melbourne Age chief political correspondent David Crowe says, it’s the arena in which the likes of former PM Tony Abbott thinks Turnbull is vulnerable.

“Australians should look on this cheap politics with dismay. The migration challenge is real. Abbott has a right to speak up. Yet the way the issue is exploited means it is all about the Coalition’s revenge drama rather than getting an outcome that matters to voters.”

And what about those at the centre of all of this? People are still being detained on Manus Island, with the most recent reporting from Radio NZ saying the refugees are still asking NZ to bypass Australia, and negotiate directly with Papua New Guinea. Their living conditions remain bare and dangerous, with one refugee being stabbed repeatedly with a screwdriver in an armed robbery just a few days ago. The ABC reports concerns that the level of medical care available to Manus refugees is “grossly inadequate.”


National has vowed to reverse the government’s decision to end offshore oil drilling, reports Stuff.Simon Bridges says the economy of regions with oil and gas activity will be hurt by the wider effect of the changes, and that more imports of fuel as the price rises will mean more dirty coal gets burned. It got hashed out in Question Time, where Paula Bennett went at Kelvin Davis, before they all got bogged down with points of order.

While the Greens are thrilled at the outcome, NZ First are not so positive, says the NZ Herald‘s Claire TrevettShane Jones will have to spend a lot of his provincial economic development fund in areas affected. He also turned himself into a meme at the press conference, with Newshub collecting photos of his impressively expressive facial reactions.


Do you go overseas to get your teeth fixed? Because of the high cost of dentistry in New Zealand, it’s becoming increasingly common for people to go to Thailand to get their teeth fixed. But as the ODT reports, dentists are increasingly concerned that they’re having to do a lot of remedial work on dental tourists. There were calls recently for more government subsidies for dental care, particularly because those on low incomes often couldn’t afford it, reports Radio NZ.


As per the latest release from Vector late last night, there were still more than 20,000 Auckland properties without power. Their response to the storm has been criticised by some, in particular over their phone app to show outages going down, reports Newshub. Vector’s head of networks, Minoru Frederiksens talked to The Spinoff‘s Don Rowe about just how major the storm was, and what is being done to restore power.


A shortage of dermatologists in Christchurch has raised concerns patients could miss out on life-saving treatments, reports Newstalk ZB. It comes amid wider concerns from Dermatological Society President Dr Paul Jarrett, who says there’s a chronic under-investment in the field across the country.


This is a really interesting Newsroom feature on the split between Air New Zealand and Virgin, what it means about their respective organisational cultures, and what it might mean for flights between NZ and Australia. Nikki Mandow writes that a major factor in the split, was simply that the two organisations just didn’t really get each other, and outlines why.

Sign up to The Bulletin





Right now on The Spinoff: What’s the deal with Auckland councillors moonlighting as West Auckland’s booze and gambling tsars? Rebecca Stevenson investigates. There’s an amazing guest post from singer Ladi6, who writes about losing her voice, surgery, and recovery for the first time. And an update to yesterday’s story about workers at the Grey Lynn supermarket going on strike – it got called off because management offered a progressive move to paying all workers across their chain of stores the living wage by May 2019.


And now, a guest post from TV and Gaming Editor Sam Brooks, who has highlighted some of the most influential and important pieces of gaming writing. 

When I think of what is good video game writing, meaning good writing about video games and the culture around them, I go to three pieces. The first, and most essential piece, is Leigh Alexander’s definitive 2014 piece for Time ‘Sexism, Lies and Video Games: The Culture War Nobody is Winning.’ It summed up the source, danger and future of the #gamergate movement better than anybody else, and is written by someone who both knows and loves this industry.

The other essential piece is actually a series of videos by Anita Sarkeesian, under the Feminist Frequency brand, which garnered a lot of hate from the aforementioned #gamergate: Tropes vs. Women in Video Games. It’s a little bit basic at first, but it’s a detailed and nuanced examination of the treatment of women in video games, where it comes from and what it means.

And finally, to tout one of our own pieces, is an interview of That Dragon, Cancer maker Ryan Green by Tof Eklund, which delves into what it was like to make a game about their son’s terminal cancer, and what that game meant for audiences.


And in sport, it’s the last weekend of the Commonwealth Games, so if you’ve missed some or even all of the action, tune in now. The big upcoming highlights include the Hockey gold medal final, after the Black Sticks won a dramatic shootout against England to make the final – video on NZ Herald. That game will be on Saturday. The Sevens is also on this weekend, so if you’ve had enough diving and competitive walking and just want to see some sport you understand, try that.

New Zealand looks likely to settle in or around 6th place on the medal table. It’s about the same spot as 2014, but way up the 11th place from 2010. Australia are way ahead of the pack on the medal table, but as Stuff‘s Ian Anderson opines, there are far too many medals on offer for swimming sports, which Australia dominates. In my opinion there should be medals for ten different weight classes in Rugby Sevens – male and female. Though of course, we’d run the risk of being beaten by Fiji 20-odd times.


From our partners, Vector’s new technology engineer Kate Murphy writes about the humble LED, and shines a light on the history and impact little things can make on energy reduction at scale.


That’s it for the The Bulletin. If you liked what you read, and know other people who would find it useful, please forward it on and encourage them to sign up here. Thanks for joining us this morning, and have a lucky Friday the 13th.


The Bulletin is brought to you by Vector. If you live in Auckland, they also delivered the power you’re using to read it. And they’re creating a new energy future for all of us, as showcased by the incredible Vector Lights.

Keep going!
‘She was in her mother’s arms when a piece of shrapnel hit her head’, a local told the authors of 3-year-old Fatima. Photograph: Jon Stephenson
‘She was in her mother’s arms when a piece of shrapnel hit her head’, a local told the authors of 3-year-old Fatima. Photograph: Jon Stephenson

The BulletinApril 12, 2018

The Bulletin: Long awaited Hit and Run inquiry launched

‘She was in her mother’s arms when a piece of shrapnel hit her head’, a local told the authors of 3-year-old Fatima. Photograph: Jon Stephenson
‘She was in her mother’s arms when a piece of shrapnel hit her head’, a local told the authors of 3-year-old Fatima. Photograph: Jon Stephenson

Good morning, and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: Hit and Run inquiry launched, the government moves against offshore oil exploration, and there’s an outbreak of measles in the South Island.

The government has launched a long-awaited inquiry into the events detailed in the book Hit and Run. The book, by investigative journalists Jon Stephenson and Nicky Hager, alleges that Afghan civilians were targeted and killed in a raid by NZ SAS troops, and property deliberately destroyed. Newshub reports the terms of reference of the inquiry will assess the conduct of NZDF personnel in the raid, and the accuracy of public statements by NZDF top brass.
Two journalists at Stuff Circuit believe the terms of reference in the inquiry don’t go far enough, saying there is a lack of accountability at the top of the Defence Force, particularly with relation to the Afghanistan deployment. Paula Penfold and Eugene Bingham, who have visited the village at the centre of the claims, describe it as a missed opportunity:
“Those problems run very, very deep. A bold Government would have taken on these issues. Instead, it has wilfully turned a blind eye.”
National’s Defence spokesman Mark Mitchell, who was briefly the minister last year, told Newstalk ZB an inquiry is unnecessary, and will be waste of millions of taxpayer dollars. The counter argument is best summed up in an opinion piece written for The Spinoff by security analyst Paul Buchanan last year:
“The bottom line is this: as a public institution in a liberal democracy, the NZDF is accountable for its actions to the New Zealand public. It can do so without compromising operational security. It must do so because now its professionalism and integrity are in question.”

Future offshore oil will be banned in an announcement expected to be made this morning by PM Jacinda Ardern, reports the NZ Herald. Exploration could continue for up to a decade, due to existing permits that will be unaffected by the announcement. But the move will partially please environmentalists, who hoped for something concrete like this when Ardern accepted a Greenpeace petition about the issue at Parliament earlier this year. To underline the political significance of this move, the Dominion Post and Press are both leading their papers with it, as is the Taranaki Daily News – more on them below.
Just last week, The Spinoff published the views of Cameron Madgwick, who is CEO of the Petroleum Exploration and Production Association. His view is that natural gas is cleaner than coal, and so such a move could on balance be environmentally negative. Let’s not forget too, that managed correctly, oil extraction makes you very very rich. That’s probably partially why the Taranaki region, which economically relies heavily on extraction, will get a short reprieve of three years on the exploration ban – details in this story on Stuff.
Also fronting the announcement this morning with Ardern will be Green party co-leader James Shaw, and NZ First’s minister for regional economic development Shane Jones. It’ll probably be one of the greatest days of Shaw’s political life, and a day of swallowing great big dead rats for Jones. He has long been in favour of exploration and extraction, and this revealing interview with the Taranaki Daily News showed.

People with symptoms of measles are being asked not to go to GP clinics or hospitals, reports Stuff. New cases of the highly infectious disease have been reported in Nelson and Christchurch, and are believed to be linked to cases last week in Queenstown and Wanaka. Symptoms are as follows:
“Unimmunised people exposed to the disease first develop a dry cough, runny nose, high temperature and feel very unwell. A rash starts after four to five days, usually on the face moving down to the chest and arms.”

Tens of thousands of Aucklanders are still without power, reports the NZ Herald. Lines company Vector says with more stormy weather predicted today, more power cuts are possible.

Some Aucklanders are saying there wasn’t enough warning about the severity of the storm, reports Radio NZ. But Metservice says they couldn’t have done much more, and you have to feel some sympathy for them – they also get the blame when a storm isn’t as bad as predicted.


Farmers are being warned extreme weather is the new normal, reports the ODT. Canterbury had a tough season, with very high temperatures in November and December, followed by heavy rain when it was time to harvest. Arable Research Foundation chairman David Birkett says farmers will need to adapt and rethink what they grow, with such weather events more likely as climate change advances.


Sky TV losing the bidding for the 2019 Rugby World Cup rights is all but confirmed, reports the NZ Herald. Sky Sport executive Richard Last says the company won’t be raising their offer for the rights, meaning they’re almost certain to lose. But, he also made the point that those predicting the end of Sky’s dominance of sport should consider the fact that the broadcaster films much of its content. And anyone watching the Commonwealth Games on TVNZ will be able to tell you that a little expertise in sports broadcasting can go a long way – a point made in this recent column by Chris Rattue.

Sign up to The Bulletin





Right now on The Spinoff: Transport minister Phil Twyford has fired back at Wayne Mapp over his Spinoff column on Labour’s “zealotry.” Sam Brooks has collected the weirdest moments of TV show Modern Family. And I spoke to ‘ethical supermarket’ workers who are going on strike, over pay they say is anything but ethical.


I for one am very very online, and I suspect some of the readers of The Bulletin are too. That’s probably partly why I found this feature in the New Yorker so fascinating, titled ‘Reddit and the struggle to detoxify the internet‘. This piece is quite different to a lot of others about social media, in that it treats a platform like Reddit on its own merits.

Arguably, Reddit is neither a positive or negative thing in and of itself, but a forum in which the best and worst impulses of humanity can be expressed. The piece also an interesting meditation on the idea of free speech absolutism, which as an idea has taken on far more complexity in the web 2.0 era of user generated content. Here’s a sample paragraph about trolling:

“Traditional journalists and editors can decide to resist the bait, and sometimes they do, but that option isn’t available on user-generated platforms. Social-media executives claim to transcend subjectivity, and they have designed their platforms to be feedback machines, giving us not what we claim to want, nor what might be good for us, but what we actually pay attention to. There are no good solutions to this problem, and so tech executives tend to discuss it as seldom as possible, and only in the airiest of platitudes.”

A quick warning – some of the subreddits (forums housed within the wider Reddit platform) and user comments discussed in the piece would be considered offensive by any reasonable person. Much like browsing Reddit itself, this article may be not safe for work.


In absolutely classic Warriors news, it turns out owner Eric Watson might himself be a bandwagon fan of the Warriors. The NZ Herald reports he has been so encouraged by the early season form of the club (5 from 5!) that he may be reconsidering selling. While the team is winning, their value might also be climbing – the stands at Mt Smart will probably be full or close to for the next two weeks with home games, and the wins will sell a lot of merch.

Finally, please enjoy this video on One News, of New Zealand gymnast Stella Ebert doing her Commonwealth Games routine with Metallica as her backing track.


 

From our partners, Vector’s new technology engineer Kate Murphy writes about the humble LED, and shines a light on the history and impact little things can make on energy reduction at scale.


The Bulletin is brought to you by Vector. If you live in Auckland, they also delivered the power you’re using to read it. And they’re creating a new energy future for all of us, as showcased by the incredible Vector Lights.