blog june 11

PoliticsJune 11, 2021

Live updates, June 11: Film on mosque attacks faces backlash, producer addresses criticism

blog june 11

Welcome to The Spinoff’s live updates for June 11, bringing you the latest news updated throughout the day. Get in touch at stewart@thespinoff.co.nz

Support our mission to analyse and uncover the new New Zealand. Click here to learn more about how you can support our work from as little as $1.

Top stories:

3.50pm: Harete Hipango is an MP again

Harete Hipango is officially a member of parliament. She returns as the next on the National Party list after Nick Smith, who resigned after 30 years, his departure expedited by his expectation that a story was about to break relating to an “altercation” with a staff member. The story never materialised. Hipango missed out on re-election in the seat of Whanganui at last year’s election.

She was interviewed by Maiki Sherman for an episode in the new series of Matangireia, released earlier this week.

2.55pm: Mosque shooting film could be taxpayer funded, producer addresses criticism

They Are Us – a film set following the 2019 Christchurch mosque shootings – could be partially funded with taxpayer dollars, Newshub has claimed.

Philippa Campbell, one of the producers on the controversial film, said work on the project had so far been privately funded. It’s understood the film could gain funding through the New Zealand Screen Production Grant.

Asked about the backlash to the project, Campbell acknowledged the story was complex – and admitted not all families connected to the tragedy were consulted.

“The challenges are obviously huge,” she said. “We have a deep respect for the communities at the heart of the tragedy. We want to assure them and New Zealand audiences that we understand the responsibility of telling this story.”

2.10pm: Ikea on the way – and sooner than we thought

Reports suggest iconic Swedish retailer Ikea could make it to New Zealand even sooner than expected.

BusinessDesk claimed that Ikea could set up shop as soon by October, with the company’s Australian chief Jan Gardberg​ saying the move will take place within the next three to four months following a sales boom in Australia. “We already have the locations, the strategy, who we are doing deals with and so on,” Gardberg added.

Along with Ikea, Auckland is set to get its first Costco in 2022.

1.05pm: Second person transferred to hospital with Covid-19

Two people are now in Middlemore Hospital with Covid-19, after being transferred from the Jet Park quarantine facility.

In a statement, the Ministry of Health said both are in a stable condition. One has been in hospital since Tuesday night, with the second moved yesterday.

“[Both] were taken to hospital safely using strict infection prevention and control measures which are in place for all hospital transfers from managed isolation and quarantine facilities,” said a ministry spokesperson.

“For privacy reasons, no further details about these patients’ care will be released.”

Meanwhile, there are no new community cases of Covid-19, with five reported today in managed isolation. The total number of active cases in New Zealand is 29.

12.55pm: Backlash after mosque attack movie focusing on Jacinda Ardern announced

The news that a movie set in the aftermath of the Christchurch mosque attacks would star Rose Byrne as Jacinda Ardern has been criticised online, with concerns it could end up in “white saviour” territory.

Aya Al-Umari lost her brother in the attack and posted on Twitter to say she had no idea the film was being made. “It was news to me when I saw this morning,” she said. “None of my close contacts knew either.”

Those connected to the attack were allegedly consulted during work on the film’s script, according to directly Andrew Niccol.

But, speaking to Stuff, Al-Umari said she is sceptical of that.

”Given the statement did say that it was in consultation with several members of the mosque tragedy [families], I would have expected to know,” she said.

Tony Green, who acted as a spokesperson for the Muslim Association of Canterbury after the attacks, said he was also unaware of any consultation. He said at least one family he had spoken to, who lost a loved one in the attack, was angered by the project.

“If you were serious about a movie which was about possibly New Zealand’s worst event domestically, you’d want to know this was grounded in a fairly wide a decent coverage of those who were affected, and at first glance, we’ve all been blindsided by this, that does not appear to have happened.”

The government has moved quickly to distance itself from the production; a spokesperson for the prime minister told The Spinoff that neither Ardern nor the government were involved in the film.

Rose Byrne herself has not responded, but the actress’ Instagram page has been flooded with comments criticising her involvement with the film. “Please do not do ‘They Are Us’ we need to show that the Muslim community are more important than the narrative of the white saviour,” wrote one person.

12.25pm: Palmerston North schools in lockdown after possible gunshots

There are reports of shots being fired in Palmerston North, prompting schools to go into lockdown.

According to Newshub, officers received reports of a possible firearms incident on Milson Line just before 11am. The Armed Offenders Squad has been called in and several schools have closed as a precaution.

At this stage, there has been no confirmation of whether shots were actually fired or if anyone has been arrested in connection with the reports.

11.25am: Waka Kotahi chair Brian Roche to resign – report

The chair of Waka Kotahi, the transport agency, is set to quit.

Stuff is reporting that Sir Brian Roche – a popular appointee of the Labour government – will step down from his role in mid-June next year. He has served as chair since 2019 after having already held the role for a period when the agency was established in 2008.

Roche was a member of the group that looked at reforming the health system, alongside Heather Simpson. The pair also examined the Covid-19 MIQ system.

10.00am: Lorde releases first single in four years

Updated

Lorde has dropped her new single Solar Power – the first from her upcoming and long-awaited third album. The song was first confirmed this week after the cover art was posted to Lorde’s website. It quickly went viral.

At the time there was no release date, with a message posted alongside the cover art simply saying “patience is a virtue”.

Earlier reports claimed the song would be released at 11am NZT, but it dropped on streaming services shortly before 10am.

The release of the song may have been brought forward after it leaked overnight.

In a newsletter sent out to fans, Lorde confirmed her album will also be called Solar Power.

“The album is a celebration of the natural world, an attempt at immortalising the deep, transcendent feelings I have when I’m outdoors,” wrote the singer. “In times of heartache, grief, deep love, or confusion, I look to the natural world for answers. I’ve learnt to breathe out, and tune in. This is what came through.”

Read more: Scorching takes on Solar Power – Lorde’s new single, reviewed

9.35am: ‘Cut back’ – DHBs reportedly told to slow vaccine roll-out as stocks plummet

Some DHBs have reportedly been told to slow down their vaccination rates as stocks of the Covid-19 Pfizer jab are running low.

The overall vaccine roll-out is about 10% ahead of schedule, with the minister in charge Chris Hipkins saying a further million vaccines will arrive next month.

According to the Otago Daily Times, some southern health boards are at risk of running out.

“People giving out vaccines have been told to cut right back because there is not enough vaccine for the country to continue at the current rate,” said a senior clinician. “There is not much transparency from the Ministry of Health regarding vaccine availability.”

A spokesperson for minister Hipkins said he was unaware of an instruction to slow down vaccinating and said there were enough doses in the country to meet the roll-out plan.

8.20am: Rose Byrne to play Jacinda Ardern in new film

Updated

Australian actress Rose Byrne is reportedly lined up to play our prime minister in a new film set in the wake of the March 15 terror attacks.

According to international reports, the film – titled They Are Us – will take place in the aftermath of the 2019mass shooting. It will be written and directed by Andrew Niccol, the New Zealander who previously helmed the infamously bad Justin Timberlake film In Time.

It’s not a done deal yet as the film is heading to the Cannes market this month to secure financing.

“They Are Us is not so much about the attack but the response to the attack,” said Niccol. “How an unprecedented act of hate was overcome by an outpouring of love and support. The film addresses our common humanity which is why I think it will speak to people around the world. It is an example of how we should respond when there’s an attack on our fellow human beings.”

The title of the film comes from a quote of Ardern’s when speaking after the devastating terror attack. “They are us. The person who has perpetuated this violence against us is not.” Ardern said.

Niccol’s script was developed in consultation with several members of the mosques affected by the tragedy, however the focus on Ardern raises questions about whether the film will end up falling into “white saviour” syndrome. Ardern herself has resisted attempts to focus the March 15 story on herself.

A spokesperson for Ardern told The Spinoff the prime minister and the government have no involvement with the film.

It’s not the first time someone has played Ardern – although it will be the first serious screen depiction. However, casting an Australian in the role is certainly a bold move accent-wise. As Madeleine Chapman wrote for The Spinoff back in 2018: “Our accent is hard.”

And in 2015, Byrne attempted a… quite poor New Zealand accent on the Ellen Show. Fush and chups, anyone?

It’s not yet known when They Are Us will hit the screens but considering talks are under way now, we can possibly expect a release late next year.

7.30am: Top stories from The Bulletin

Nurses and DHBs are back to the negotiating table after this week’s strike saw 30,000 health workers off the job for eight hours. Glenda Alexander from the NZ Nurses Organisation told RNZ that it was not just about pay, and improving work conditions was just as important. “They’re kind of interwoven [pay and conditions]. If we don’t pay people what they’re worth, what the job is worth, they’re not going to stay and we’re not going to get new people into the nursing workforce,” said Alexander.

The DHBs say they are “keen to close gaps” in the areas that nurses think are lacking. Spokesperson Jim Green said previous negotiations had addressed “many of [nurses] requirements” and DHBs were looking at would could be done next. “We’ve made offers around all those areas – we’ve made a pay rise increase of up to 8 to 12% and of course there’s the pay equity settlement that will be coming in on top of that as well,” he said.

Meanwhile, there are reports this morning of empty beds at Christchurch Hospital because of a lack of nurses. Unnamed sources at the hospital said that resources were stretched and the workforce was at breaking point. 19 beds were sitting empty across the hospital last week, according to RNZ. “There’s only so much you can keep asking people to step up and do more with less and that’s usually less of us to do more for the number of patients that we have through the door on any given day,” said one unnamed nurse.

Read more and subscribe to The Bulletin here

Keep going!
blog upd june 10

PoliticsJune 10, 2021

Live updates, June 10: Nick Smith apologises for gay marriage vote in valedictory; Victoria travel pause extended

blog upd june 10

Welcome to The Spinoff’s live updates for June 10, bringing you the latest news updated throughout the day. Get in touch at stewart@thespinoff.co.nz

5.25pm: Halt on quarantine-free travel from Victoria extended

The travel bubble pause between New Zealand and Victoria will continue for another seven days, Covid-19 response minister Chris Hipkins has announced.

Despite the lifting of lockdown restrictions in greater Melbourne as of tomorrow, “today’s advice from New Zealand public health officials is that the travel pause should continue” despite the “overall risk to New Zealand” being low, said Hipkins in a statement.  “The government is taking a precautionary approach in continuing the pause, which will be reviewed again next Wednesday.”

There are now 93 cases associated with the outbreak in greater Melbourne, spread over four clusters.

“Green flights” will continue, meaning new Zealand residents and others who can provide a negative test can return without having to go into MIQ.

5.00pm: Nick Smith apologises for gay marriage vote in valedictory

As he completes a 30-year parliamentary career, National MP Nick Smith has delivered his valedictory speech to the House of Representatives. Smith suddenly announced last week that he was leaving less than a year into the term, prompted by a mysterious media story that he believed was imminent relating to an “altercation”. The story is yet to materialise.

In his address, Smith said he “got wrong” his 2013 vote against the marriage equality bill. “The error is all the more personal with my 20-year-old son being gay,” he said. “I wish to put on record today my apology to New Zealand’s LGBT+ community. I pay tribute to Louisa Wall, Fran Wilde and Amy Adams for their leadership that has improved the lives of my son and thousands of other New Zealanders. I also acknowledge Jenny Shipley’s courage as the first PM to attend a Gay Pride parade in 99.”

Smith began by saying it had “been a blast and an enormous privilege to be part of governing this amazing little country we share. My time here has had as many ups and downs as our Southern mountains that I studied in my PHD thesis.” He made particular mention of his two stints as conservation minister. “Conservation is the best job in the Cabinet room. To get it once is lucky; twice is to be truly blessed.”

He also paid tribute to his colleagues in the “brat pack”, the youngsters of the National caucus in the 90s: Roger Sowry, Bill English, and Tony Ryall. “Many wrongly assume the strong friendships between the four of us meant we agree politically,” he said. “We have been on opposite sides of many of National’s policy, conscience and leadership debates. Our annual week-long shared holidays rotating between the upper and lower and North and South islands over 30 years have enabled us to enjoy watching our 16 children grow up together.”

12.35pm: Don’t drink the water at parliament!

Our dehydrated political editor Justin Giovannetti reports:

Wellington’s water woes have now hit the centre of government.

The water being served to MPs in the house today won’t be from the taps, after an announcement that the water at parliament house and the parliamentary library isn’t safe to drink at the moment. The two buildings hold the main debating chamber as well as the offices of many MPs, parliamentary staff and the press gallery.

“This is a precautionary measure due to an external issue,” staff were told in an email at midday. Bottled water will be brought to parliament if the issue can’t be solved quickly.

It’ll be a blow for Covid-19 response minister Chris Hipkins, who only recently traded in his faithful plastic mini Pump water bottle for a metal model refilled at parliament’s taps.

Despite the frequency with which the capital’s pipes spontaneously bust, showering water and less pleasant things through neighbourhoods with million dollar villas, The Economist ranked Wellington as the world’s fourth most liveable city yesterday.

12.10pm: Queensland, New South Wales, at ‘serious risk’ of Covid spread

There are concerns Victoria’s Covid-19 outbreak could have spread to other states, with health authorities in both Queensland and New South Wales on high alert.

According to Newshub, Queensland has recorded two new local cases of Covid-19 after a couple travelled to the state from Melbourne.

The couple’s trip took them via New South Wales, with health minister Brad Hazzard saying there was now a “serious risk” of an outbreak.

“I am very concerned that we’ve had people leave the lockdown and travel across our state and into Queensland, putting everyone at risk,” Hazzard said.

“What we need to understand is why that was done and there’s no clarity on that at this point.”

11.50am: ‘Everybody should have the right to participate’ – Robertson on transgender athletes

The starting point for a discussion about transgender athletes is that anyone should be allowed to play sport, said Grant Robertson.

The sports minister has weighed into the issue after a letter co-signed by a group of former Olympians called on the government to widen Sport New Zealand’s consultation on the participation of transgender athletes in sport.

Robertson told RNZ that the matter was a complex one. “I applaud Sport New Zealand for the fact that they’ve gone out particularly firstly to the Rainbow community and to the trans community and said ‘how can we support people to participate and be involved and included in sport and recreation’. To me, that’s the starting point.”

The approach to the issue should be one of inclusion, said Robertson.

11.15am: More migrant dairy workers, vets allowed into the country

Another 200 dairy workers will be allowed into the country under a border class exception – but it might not be enough.

The government announced the exception this morning. It will also see another 50 veterinarians enter New Zealand.

“It is clear from conversations with the dairy and veterinarian sectors that they are facing workforce pressures. These border exceptions will go a long way towards relieving those pressures,” said the agriculture minister Damien O’Connor.

But Federated Farmers said it will go no where near far enough. “We thank the Minister of Agriculture for trying on our behalf, but we do need to do more,” the group’s employment spokesperson Chris Lewis told Stuff.

The dairy sector was short between 2000 and 4000 workers, Lewis said.

O’Connor said that the announcement showed the government recognised immediate expertise was needed in some sectors. But, he said New Zealanders needed to upskill in these areas too. “What we have also made clear to sector leaders is that we need to ensure there is a strong incentive for New Zealanders to take up entry level roles and develop careers in dairying,” he said.

10.00am: Climate report should be ‘binned’, says Act

A bit of political reaction to yesterday’s finalised report by the Climate Change Commission.

Both National and Act have come out against the report, with David Seymour calling for it to be shredded and binned.

“If the rest of the world wants to decarbonise, then we should track them. It is dangerous for a small trading nation to get out of sync with its trading partners for reasons of diplomacy, trade, and consumer preferences,” said Seymour.

“It would be foolish for New Zealand to ‘lead’ the world. Whether we like it or not we are a passenger on this journey, our emissions alone will not change the climate.”

Meanwhile, National has given a slightly softer response with the party’s climate change spokesperson Stuart Smith saying the report leaves unanswered questions.

“We still have questions on why farmers are being asked to do more than the targets set out in the Zero Carbon Act,” he said. “We still have concern with some of the policy interventions being proposed to achieve out emissions targets, such as the car tax.”

Both Labour and the Greens took up the report’s call to action, with climate change minister James Shaw saying it showed we need to act immediately.

“They have set out a pathway that would need every part of the Government to come to the table and commit to further action to bring down emissions in their sector. If we can do that, then we can reverse the current trend and finally bring emissions down in line with what science requires. There will be work for everyone to do, so from now on nearly every minister will, in some ways, be a climate change minister.”

MORE: ‘We need to move faster’: Climate Commission lays down challenge in final advice

9.05am: Paula Bennett ‘hurt’ by Muller leadership coup, reveals call that made her quit politics

Former deputy prime minister Paula Bennett has revealed more details about the behind the scenes turmoil within the National Party that saw her leave politics.

Bennett was bumped as deputy last year when Todd Muller replaced Simon Bridges as leader.

Speaking to RNZ on the new episode of Matangireia, Bennett said she was “hurt” by how the leadership coup played out. “At some level I just thought well, Simon and I are just going to be constantly kind of undermined from within, and caucus will decide its own destiny,” she said.

Following the leadership change, Bennett said she received an early morning call from the Muller. “At that point he said to me, ‘I’m going to rank you really poorly, I don’t see a role for you’ and that was incredibly tough,” Bennett said. “I deserved a degree of respect.”

Listen to the full podcast here

Paula Bennett at the press conference to announce her departure (Alex Braae)

8.10am: Thousands of foreign workers given visa extension to ease labour shortages

About 10,000 foreign workers will be allowed to stay in the country for longer after new visa extensions announced this morning.

Working holiday visas and seasonal work visas due to expire between June 21 and the end of the year will be extended for another six months to help manage ongoing labour shortages caused by border restrictions.

The immigration minister, Kris Faafoi, said the move will provide assurances to both employers and visa holders. “We will continue to monitor the border and labour market situations and will extend these visas again if necessary,” he said.

Essential skills work visas for those earning below $27 per hour median wage would be increased from six months to 12 months.

7.30am: Top stories from The Bulletin

National MP Nick Smith is returning to parliament today, to formally end his 30 year political career. Smith will give his valedictory speech this afternoon, in the presence of the National caucus including leader Judith Collins. It’s almost two weeks since Smith announced he would be leaving parliament amid an inquiry into a “verbal altercation” that took place in his office. Of course, there was also that tip-off that a media story about him was going to break – something that never happened.

So, what do we know now about Smith’s resignation? The circumstances remain fairly sketchy, with Judith Collins still refusing to confirm or deny whether she is the one who gave Smith a heads up about the media story that never was. As Newsroom’s Jo Moir wrote earlier this week, there’s something of a contradiction in Collins’ statements about Smith. As Moir writes: “Collins denies she told Smith to leave while at the same time insisting she warns her MPs when she thinks a media storm is coming their way.”

Then there’s the role of Newshub’s Tova O’Brien in the whole thing. Allegedly, Smith thought it was O’Brien who had the mystery story about him. It makes sense, as Newshub are never far from a big political scoop. And yet, O’Brien said last week she never had a story on Smith in the works. Judith Collins has continued to maintain she does not disclose the contents of conversations she has with her MPs – a statement that is simply not true – and therefore will not reveal whether she did indeed tip-off Smith.

What’s going to be in that valedictory then? According to Newshub, not much. Or at least, not much if you were hoping for answers to the big questions surrounding Smith’s mystery resignation. Newshub understands his focus will be on his three decade long political career rather than how it all ended.