Possible contenders for the Green Party co-leadership include Chlöe Swarbrick and Teanau Tuiono (Image: Tina Tiller)
Possible contenders for the Green Party co-leadership include Chlöe Swarbrick and Teanau Tuiono (Image: Tina Tiller)

PoliticsJanuary 30, 2024

Who could replace James Shaw as Green Party co-leader?

Possible contenders for the Green Party co-leadership include Chlöe Swarbrick and Teanau Tuiono (Image: Tina Tiller)
Possible contenders for the Green Party co-leadership include Chlöe Swarbrick and Teanau Tuiono (Image: Tina Tiller)

Assessing the frontrunners – and the outside choices – to join Marama Davidson at the top of parliament’s third-biggest party.

The announcement this morning that James Shaw would be stepping down as Green Party co-leader wasn’t a huge surprise, but it has still triggered what’s set to be a lengthy battle to see who will take up the position alongside Marama Davidson. 

The Green Party constitution dictates that one co-leader must be a woman, while the other can be of any gender. There’s also a requirement that one must be Māori.

Nominees can start publicly coming forward from tomorrow, with a result due on March 10. The process is slightly more complex than for other parties, with party members at local meetings deciding who gets the job. Each branch is entitled to a certain number of votes proportionate to the number of members who live in that electorate.

So far, neither Shaw nor Davidson have been willing to publicly back anyone (despite the best efforts from press gallery reporters to squeeze out an endorsement). “I’m not going to make any announcements on behalf of anybody today – that really is up to them,” Shaw told reporters today. 

“It really is up to anybody who wants to put themselves forward to make those announcements themselves.”

So, while we wait to see who comes forward – and with a high-profile former contender in Golriz Ghahraman now out of parliament – we’ve taken a look over the Green Party caucus (and beyond) to pluck out some possible candidates for the top job. 

Chlӧe Swarbrick

The de facto frontrunner, Auckland Central MP Chlӧe Swarbrick is a political superstar. First entering parliament in 2017, Swarbrick has been an impressive performer in the house, and an even more impressive performer with the public. She’s routinely cropped up in preferred prime minister polling – sure, at just around 1% or 2%, but it’s  a remarkable feat for someone who isn’t even leader of their party.

When Shaw faced a leadership challenge in 2022, Swarbrick took herself out of contention. But with a vacancy now needing to be filled, could the high-flying MP put her name in the ring? It seems very likely, though Swarbrick did not respond to The Spinoff’s request for comment.

Auckland Central MP Chlöe Swarbrick (Photo: Benjamin Brooking)

Julie Anne Genter

A familiar face in politics, Genter had enough support to scoop up the Rongotai electorate from Labour in last year’s election. She’s been in parliament since 2011, making her one of the party’s longest-serving MPs, and has been a visible face in debates over sustainable transport, particularly in and around the capital. 

While the Let’s Get Wellington Moving plan has been scrapped by the new government, that may only make Genter’s role as an opposition MP even more important for the Greens. And with Shaw on his way out of parliament, perhaps the Greens would like to keep a Wellington-based MP as co-leader given the party’s overperformance in the city during last year’s election? Whatever the reason, Genter is most definitely a frontrunner in this co-leadership tussle.

Teanau Tuiono

He’s less of a Green Party celebrity than the two people mentioned above, but Teanau Tuiono can’t be ruled out of contention. For starters, he seriously considered a run for the co-leadership in 2022, which would have pitted him directly against Shaw. With Shaw now out of the race, it paves the way for a clearer path should Tuiono choose to contest.

But beyond that, Tuiono is an up-and-comer in the party. He was recently elected assistant speaker – the first time a Green MP has been offered that role. He was also the party’s first Pasifika MP and has been a strong voice in favour of scrapping a “racist” law dating back to the Muldoon government that denied citizenship to Western Sāmoans. His member’s bill on the matter remains before parliament.

Tuiono also represents a branch of the Greens that Shaw did not, coming from a more activist background. Whether the party want another Shaw-esque leader – or someone more closely aligned with Davidson’s style of politics – remains to be seen.

Green Party list MP Teanau Tuiono (Photo by Lynn Grieveson – Newsroom via Getty Images)

Steve Abel

It’s only been about four months since the election, but new MP Steve Abel is an outside choice for the co-leadership. He’s well known in activist circles, having spent 245 days as part of an occupation protesting the felling of native trees in Avondale. Abel has also been a campaigner for Greenpeace for many years, protesting prominently against mining on conservation land and deep sea drilling – two core issues for the Green Party.

Whether or not he’s personally willing to put himself forward for the co-leadership remains unknown (Abel has not responded to The Spinoff’s request for comment), and he may have less support from the urban, centrist types likely to endorse, say, Swarbrick. But for a Green Party that – at least at the last election – has benefitted highly from disenfranchised Labour backers, Abel is certainly a possible, though leftfield, contender. 

Efeso Collins

Swarbrick isn’t the only former Auckland mayoral hopeful within the Green Party caucus. Efeso Collins lost his bid for the mayoralty to Wayne Brown in 2022. He quickly pivoted into central politics and made it into parliament at last year’s election. It’s only been a few months, so Collins hasn’t had much of a chance to make an impact. But his failed mayoral campaign undoubtedly elevated his status, particularly in Auckland where support for Labour dipped dramatically post-lockdown. If the Greens wanted to capitalise on Labour’s falling support in the super city, Collins could be an option.

Tamatha Paul

It’s probably too early for new Wellington Central MP Tamatha Paul to consider a tilt at the top job, but her future with the Green Party is undoubtedly bright. It’s hard not to compare her to Swarbrick in that she’s incredibly popular and well known among a key Green Party demographic (young urban liberals) and managed to scoop up an electorate seat (Wellington Central, where the Greens also won the party vote)

In a short but sweet statement to The Spinoff, Paul indicated she wouldn’t be putting herself forward. “Nah bo,” is all she said. Still, putting one’s hat in the ring isn’t always a personal choice – there’s always an element of doing what’s “best for the party”. It remains possible, though unlikely, that Paul could be encouraged to run.

James Cockle

Green Party leadership contenders don’t have to be current MPs – which makes 2021 leadership hopeful James Cockle a (very, very slim) possibility. Sure, he lost to James Shaw in that contest by a healthy margin, winning just four delegate votes to Shaw’s 116. But his name is also James which would make things a lot easier for the public. Don’t rule him out.

‘If you value The Spinoff and the perspectives we share, support our work by donating today.’
Anna Rawhiti-Connell
— Senior writer
Keep going!
Green Party co-leader James Shaw will leave parliament (Image: Tina Tiller)
Green Party co-leader James Shaw will leave parliament (Image: Tina Tiller)

PoliticsJanuary 30, 2024

‘Privilege of my lifetime’: James Shaw announces resignation as Greens co-leader

Green Party co-leader James Shaw will leave parliament (Image: Tina Tiller)
Green Party co-leader James Shaw will leave parliament (Image: Tina Tiller)

The Green Party co-leader will stay in parliament ‘for the time being’, with a replacement to be announced on March 10. Stewart Sowman-Lund reports. 

James Shaw has announced his resignation as co-leader of the Green Party, prompting a contest to determine who will join Marama Davidson to head parliament’s third-biggest party.

Shaw will remain in parliament “for the time being” to support a Green-backed amendment to the Bill of Rights, but challengers for the co-leadership can start putting themselves forward from tomorrow.

In 2022, the Greens’ co-leader constitution changed from requiring one male and one female co-leader to instead requiring one woman and one person of any gender, plus a requirement that one must be Māori.

“It has been the privilege of my lifetime to serve as New Zealand’s climate change minister for the last six years and as Green Party co-leader for nearly nine,” Shaw said in a statement. 

First entering parliament in 2014, Shaw surged to the top of the Green Party list in May of the following year. He became co-leader alongside Metiria Turei, who resigned in 2017, and remained in the role alongside Marama Davidson.

James Shaw and Metiria Turei

In his statement, Shaw paid tribute to the two co-leaders he had served alongside, and the “extraordinary caucus of Green MPs, staff, party officials and volunteers”. 

Alongside his role as climate change minister, Shaw held a number of other senior roles within the Labour-led government, including statistics, associate finance and associate environment. He faced criticism from former Green MPs from the more activist wing of the party, with Sue Bradford accusing Shaw of turning the Greens into “Labour light”.

In 2022, he faced a leadership contest after Green delegates did not reconfirm Shaw as co-leader. He ultimately retained the role comfortably after defeating his sole competitor, James Cockle.

“I’m very proud of what the Green Party has achieved over the last eight years,” Shaw said today. “I would like to thank Green Party members and supporters for their incredible hard work and support over that time.”

He continued: “In 2017, the Greens became a party of government, with ministers, for the first time. We also made political history by increasing our support at the end of each of our two terms – a feat no other government support partner had achieved.”

Nominations for the co-leadership will open tomorrow and close on Wednesday, February 14. A new co-leader is expected to be announced on March 10. Shaw said he would not be endorsing any nominee for the co-leadership, but admitted there had been “private conversations”. 

While a blow to the Greens, the departure of Shaw from politics was sign-posted ahead of last year’s election after he decided against running for an electorate seat. While never holding an electorate during his time in parliament, he had routinely contested the Wellington Central electorate. With Labour incumbent Grant Robertson deciding not to contest the seat in 2023, Shaw was considered a strong contender. But he stepped aside to let up-and-comer Tamatha Paul run in Wellington Central, and she won.

Shaw denied that stepping aside in Wellington Central was a sign of an impending departure from politics, telling Newshub that he didn’t run because he could not give that job his all while being the best climate minister possible.

At the time, Shaw said it was “open-ended” how long he would stay in his position. “When I first ran for the Green Party co-leadership in 2015 I said my commitment was to take us into government for the first time and then safely out the other side,” he said.

“So it’s open-ended in the sense that we are not yet done. In fact, I would argue that we are only just getting going, there is so much more that we need to do.”

Ultimately, while the Greens’ election result delivered its largest ever caucus – and a historic three electorate seats – the party was not returned to government at last year’s election.

“In government, we passed the landmark Zero Carbon Act with unanimous support across parliament, becoming one of the first countries in the world to place the Paris Agreement’s 1.5’C target in national legislation,” Shaw continued.

“It is especially gratifying to see the Zero Carbon Act survive its first change of government. New Zealand can be proud that it has an enduring climate change framework, with long-term targets and institutions that will guide us over several decades and changes of government.” 

Shaw said the Greens’ success in last year’s election “ushered in a new era” for the party. “Now is the time for a new co-leader to work alongside Marama to take this new caucus into the future,” he said.

“The Green Party will continue to lead the fight to stop the climate crisis, restore and protect our wildernesses and wildlife, eliminate poverty, and honour Te Tiriti.”

The Green Party has been rocked in recent months by the departures of MPs Elizabeth Kerekere and Golriz Gharahman, the former after allegations of bullying and the latter following claims of shoplifting. This week will also mark the arrival of Gharahman’s replacement Celia Wade-Brown joining the Green caucus.