spinofflive
A rioter throws a desk on to a fire by the parliamentary playground. (Marty Melville / AFP via Getty Images)
A rioter throws a desk on to a fire by the parliamentary playground. (Marty Melville / AFP via Getty Images)

The BulletinMarch 25, 2022

Investigating the occupation

A rioter throws a desk on to a fire by the parliamentary playground. (Marty Melville / AFP via Getty Images)
A rioter throws a desk on to a fire by the parliamentary playground. (Marty Melville / AFP via Getty Images)

The opposition has called for an inquiry, but there’s been no move from Labour to review the three week occupation of parliament’s grounds, Justin Giovannetti writes in The Bulletin.

Physical damage to parliament is still being repaired, but what of the deeper damage to democracy.

In the final days of the three week occupation of parliament, prime minister Jacinda Ardern promised that a review of some kind would be held to look into the response. The occupation saw over 100 arrests, 40 police officers injured and mass disruption to the capital. Three weeks after the protest ended in a fiery riot, work is still underway to clean up parliament’s grounds. However, momentum for an inquiry has now stalled and it risks becoming a partisan issue.

Where are the inquiries into the occupation?

Labour members controlling parliament’s justice select committee blocked a request last week by National MPs to hold a hearing into the occupation and riot. RNZ’s Jane Patterson explains the current state of inquiry into the protest. The government said it was waiting on the Independent Police Conduct Authority to confirm whether it’ll look into the protest and what its terms of reference are. The opposition has voiced concerns about leaving an inquiry to the IPCA, which has more experience looking at individual police misconduct than broad situations like the occupation. The police minister confirmed that no discussion has been held at cabinet about a broader review. The IPCA revealed yesterday that it will conduct a year-long investigation tightly focused on police actions, The Dominion Post reports.

The opposition wants parliament to have a role in a wider review.

Speaking with Stuff, National leader Christopher Luxon said a larger inquiry of the occupation is needed. He worries that an IPCA review would look too narrowly at the protest and not at larger issues that need to be examined. It’s about much more than the interactions between police and protesters. There’s the role of the speaker in terms of blasting music and turning on parliament’s sprinklers; misinformation and the lack of warning from the intelligence agencies, as well as the wider impact on Wellingtonians. The prime minister has said she expects parliament will eventually look at its own operations and whether the grounds should remain open to the public in the future. There’s been no indication on when that might happen.

Why did Labour block an inquiry by parliament?

Labour’s justice committee chair, Ginny Andersen, last week obstructed an opposition request to call the police commissioner to front over the occupation. Contacted by Newsroom to explain the decision, Andersen said the prime minister had spoken about the situation and she had nothing to add. Committee chairs are independent from the prime minister’s office and can hold significant power in parliament. As Newsroom’s Jo Moir writes, it’s noteworthy that Andersen didn’t think she had to explain herself to the public. Labour has a majority on all of parliament’s select committees. In the aftermath of the occupation, there are a number of significant ways parliament could respond. The Conversation makes the case for why a new law is required to protect the heart of the country’s democracy.

Keep going!
Jacinda Ardern announces changes to Covid rules. (Robert Kitchin/Getty Images)
Jacinda Ardern announces changes to Covid rules. (Robert Kitchin/Getty Images)

The BulletinMarch 24, 2022

The new normal

Jacinda Ardern announces changes to Covid rules. (Robert Kitchin/Getty Images)
Jacinda Ardern announces changes to Covid rules. (Robert Kitchin/Getty Images)

New Zealand is aiming for a sense of normalcy beyond the omicron peak with a set of looser Covid restrictions,  Justin Giovannetti writes in The Bulletin.

Most Covid-19 rules scrapped as government adopts a pared-down traffic light system.

Jacinda Ardern unveiled loosened Covid restrictions yesterday that will roll out over the coming days. From Saturday morning, QR code scanning and outdoor gathering limits are gone—but keep the app for bluetooth. In early April, vaccine passes and most mandates end. The Spinoff’s live updates has summarised the announcement and the simplified traffic light system. Continued wearing of face masks indoors will do most of the heavy lifting for the Covid response going forward, along with boosters for the New Zealanders who haven’t had them yet. The prime minister said that while the country’s Covid response has been successful, it was “bloody hard”.

Some vaccine mandates will remain, companies can choose to require vaccination.

Health workers, people in aged care homes, Corrections staff, as well as border workers will remain covered by the government’s vaccine mandate. Teachers, soldiers and police will no longer need to get two doses by default. Those in the hospitality industry covered by mandates will also no longer need vaccines from April 5. 1News has looked more closely at the mandate decision and what it means for workers. A public health group chaired by Sir David Skegg advised the government that certain vaccine mandates could be dropped after omicron’s peak, which is why the mandates will remain until April. RNZ reports that schools have been told they can continue to require vaccines.

The reaction has been mixed, with disappointment at both ends of the spectrum.

Hospitality businesses told RNZ that the government is being too slow and didn’t go far enough. They said they want a move to the orange setting, along with the end to physical distancing rules. The government will review the traffic light setting on April 4. Retail NZ told Stuff it would like the mask rules revoked and worries staff will face aggression. National supported the move, but said the government should provide a timeline for dropping all mandates. Act said Ardern was too timid and the traffic light system should be abolished. The Green Party opposes the new rules and say they put vulnerable communities at risk. The prime minister acknowledged that Māori advisors were uncomfortable with the changes, 1News reports.

Disappointment from Siouxsie Wiles.

Over 500,000 New Zealanders have been confirmed Covid cases, but the actual number could be above 1.7 million according to modelling. The vast majority have occurred over the past month. Omicron has been an incredibly infectious virus and elimination now seems “impossible” anywhere in the world, according to associate health minister Ayesha Verrall. There will be future waves of Covid-19 and all of the measures being scrapped now could return. Here’s what Siouxsie Wiles told the Science Media Centre about yesterday’s changes:

“I’m relieved that not all of our protections have been dropped. The data from overseas is really clear—those countries that have dropped restrictions as their omicron wave was subsiding are now experiencing another wave. For that reason, I am relieved to see masks stay…

But, I am disappointed with parts of the announcement. There was a lot of talk of things being safer now Auckland is coming out of this omicron peak, but safer for who? Certainly not everybody. We know that being boosted helps reduce transmission of this virus so upgrading vaccine passes to include the booster would have helped keep indoor environments safer for the more at-risk members of our community. Similarly, removing vaccine mandates for people working with our children who can’t yet be vaccinated makes me very nervous.”

The Spinoff’s Covid data tracker has the latest figures.