spinofflive
Tūranga, the new central Christchurch library, has had over one million visitors since it opened a year ago.
Tūranga, the new central Christchurch library, has had over one million visitors since it opened a year ago.

ĀteaJune 24, 2019

The buildings are ‘uniquely Aotearoa’. Their Māori designers are ignored

Tūranga, the new central Christchurch library, has had over one million visitors since it opened a year ago.
Tūranga, the new central Christchurch library, has had over one million visitors since it opened a year ago.

When the new Christchurch library Tūranga – widely praised for its indigenous motifs and design references – won a major award last week, the significant Māori input into its design apparently warranted no mention at all. Such erasure is becoming a trend, writes Rebecca Kiddle.

I woke up on a grey winter’s morning last week and an app notification alerted me to something interesting on LinkedIn. The post was design firm Architectus congratulating itself and its client/developer, construction company, engineers and a partnering architectural design company on winning not only the Best in Category but the Supreme Award at the recent Property Council New Zealand Rider Levett Bucknall Property Industry Awards.

Now if one has time to write that doozie of an award name, surely one might have time to acknowledge the integral role that Matapopore Trust – the group tasked by local hapū and iwi Ngāi Tūāhuriri/Ngāi Tahu to be their voice on rebuild projects following the 2010 and 2011 earthquakes – played in the design and realisation of what, by all accounts, is a beautiful piece of architecture: Tūranga, the new library in central Christchurch.

Rhys Head, a Matapopore trustee, points out in the comments below the post that Matapopore’s input and inspiration was present throughout the design.

He writes:

“From the inspiration of Harakeke in the facade, depiction of Paikea by Riki Manuel and Morgan Hales on Colombo St facade, Fayne Robinson’s stairway Pou carving as a light box, the roof top native gardens pointing to Aoraki, the Peninsula, Maungatere Mt Grey. Without the assistance of Matapopore this Auckland and Sydney Architecture company would have been bereft of inspiration….come on Architectus at this point it is appropriation of indigenous design. As a Trustee it is disappointing our team have received no acknowledgement from the core project team.”

Debbie Tikao, Matapopore’s general manager, commented in an email to me:

“This is an outstanding building and worthy of this award, however, for us at Matapopore, this is incredibly disappointing. We worked with the Library team and architects for years to make this project a true reflection of our connection to place. Our input has added so much beauty and meaning. For this not to be considered something worthy of acknowledgment is a truly sad reflection on us as a nation!”

A quick Google search reinforces Tikao’s and Head’s point, with Christchurch City Libraries acknowledging on its website that Matapopore Trust had been “a key partner in the development of our new central library since the beginning of the project” and that “Cultural values, aspirations and narratives are woven throughout Tūranga’s entire experience”.

On Matapopore’s own website, you can find a full eight-page PDF outlining the ways in which Ngāi Tuahuriri are now able to be seen in this place through the efforts of Matapopore. A beautiful narrative that connects Ngāi Tahu back to Ngāti Porou grounds the building in a history that spans the two main islands of Aotearoa.

This is by no means an isolated incident. Just last month, the Tirohanga Whānui walking and cycling bridge in Auckland won a prestigious award at the 2019 Auckland Architecture Awards. Ngāti Whātua artist Graham Tipene, whose artwork arguably defines the bridge, was never even invited to the awards ceremony by the architects involved, despite the lead consultant, engineering firm Aurecon, describing the bridge as “a bridge design that echoes the richness of Māori culture and will leave a legacy for bridge design in New Zealand”.

The Tirohanga Whānui Bridge, connecting the Albany and Pinehills sides of the Northern Motorway, Auckland. (Wells Architects/ NZ Institute of Architects)

These two examples are the tip of the iceberg. Talk to almost any iwi or hapū group who have worked with built environment professionals and they’ll tell you stories of where their mātauranga (knowledge) has been taken, appropriated and the resultant building, bridge or space’s success attributed only to the design skills of the firms putting themselves forward for these awards.

Where, though, do the award-givers sit in all this? Surely they – in this case Property Council New Zealand – should have mechanisms in place to ensure the designs submitted are fully credited to those who had input into them.

Come on, designers, engineers and award bodies. Don’t be dicks and acknowledge and celebrate the hefty contribution Māori, iwi and hapū are giving to these projects creating uniquely Aotearoa, ‘could only be in New Zealand’ places.

Dr Rebecca Kiddle is a Senior Lecturer in Environmental Studies at Victoria University of Wellington.

Keep going!
Vunilagi Vou gallery in Ōtāhuhu. Image supplied.
Vunilagi Vou gallery in Ōtāhuhu. Image supplied.

ĀteaJune 23, 2019

‘Art belongs to us’: Behind the scenes at Ōtāhuhu’s first-ever art gallery

Vunilagi Vou gallery in Ōtāhuhu. Image supplied.
Vunilagi Vou gallery in Ōtāhuhu. Image supplied.

Earlier this month Vunilagi Vou opened in Ōtāhuhu, the first art gallery the south Auckland suburb has ever had. Its director, curator Ema Tavola, is passionate about centring South Auckland communities and art makers in conversations around contemporary New Zealand art.

Ōtāhuhu is home to a large migrant population, more than half are from Pacific Island nations, but a lack of investment for years by the council means that its residents aren’t focused on fine arts as a community issue.

A well-established curator of mixed Fijian-Pākehā heritage, Ema Tavola rejects the idea that art should be confined to rich, white areas. She says moving to New Zealand to study a visual arts degree in Ōtara highlighted the huge difference in expectations of rich and poor suburbs.

“It was just the most extreme thing to be talking about fine art from Europe and walk out the gate into a community that was 70% Polynesian. I really wanted to find out what art looked like that lived in communities like this and create space where our communities can find value in the things we love to do, which is make work in this fine art context.”

Ema Tavola. PHOTO: Pati Solomona Tyrell

That contrast pushed Tavola to work with Pacific communities and after a time volunteering at a community-run Ōtara gallery, she moved into a full-time role at Manukau City Council. While there she established Fresh Gallery Ōtara, a gallery that celebrated local and South Auckland artists. After curating 66 shows there, she made the move to Ōtāhuhu.

While the concept is very similar, Tavola says there is a huge difference between the areas.

“Ōtara is a very connected community, and they’ve got together and done a lot of things as a group, they have agency and they participate a lot in things that affect their lives… Ōtāhuhu has very siloed cultural communities, big Vietnamese community, Sikh community, if you go to any local board things here… the participation levels are quite different to Ōtara”

Vunilagi Vou is a Fijian name, vunilagi meaning ‘horizon’ and vou meaning ‘new’. Tavola says the name represents the life-giving energy of the sun. “The sunrise and sunset is that metaphor for projects, in the way that I work methodologically, that I love when things have a beginning and an end.”

The gallery’s opening exhibition is made up of works from 13 different artists, and includes weaving, photography, painting and printwork. Tavola aims to highlight female artists in the space, and says in her experience, they’re less likely to be pushing their own work into these galleries.

“Since I’ve become a mum it’s made me realise how much mother-artists completely put their practise on the back burner. My daughter is almost five and for the last five years I’ve really tried to enable women and mother artists to have opportunities because they’re not out there so much, they often get overlooked.”

Of the 13 artists on show at Vunilagi Vou, eight are women. But Tavola says it was an exercise in questioning her own biases. She curated a show in the International Biennale of Casablanca last year, and says most of the artists she initially thought of taking were men.

“I had to really take a step back and say who are the women artists doing great things but not out there on the front lines showing it off all the time… You have to check your biases. It’s definitely easy to work with male artists when you just do a quick scan and forget to think more deeply about it, but I have a lot of intention to enable women artists.”

“Mind That Māori” (2019) by Melissa Cole in collaboration with Rudi Robinson. PHOTO: Vunilagi Vou.

Tavola curates her art carefully, selecting pieces for her shows that speak to the heart of the community she’s involved in. Looking straight through the doors from the tiled arcade is a portrait of social media star Boom Bullet, by artist Niutuiatua Lemalu. He’s well known in the Pasifika community, and the work is a prime example of how when art is taken out of its societal context, it can lose meaning.

“A lot of people have come in and wanted to ask questions, the thing I love about curating in this kind of setting are the themes and how they resonate with these audiences… [Boom Bullet’s] famous for his tattoo, he gets heated in videos and takes his shirt off and smacks his chest, and here, people are like ‘ohh Boom Bullet!’ they know it straight away, and that opens up a conversation.”

A dark portrait placed in the corner of the room was a late selection for the gallery. Tavola says she chose it after hearing the news that Sāmoan actor Pua Magasiva had died.

“That had such an impact on our community and it just makes me think about the darkness that sits within our communities. Every group of Pacific Islanders have this behind the surface and its things that we don’t want to look at and we don’t want to confront.”

That kind of conversation is what’s missing from other, more traditional galleries. Tavola wanted to make a space for Pasifika art not just to bring the art to the people, but to make the people more comfortable with seeking out art that resonates with them.

“This is about accessibility, and I’m not going to sell a $2000 painting to my average customer here, but it’s about seeing that our work is part of this community, reflects this community, and hopefully bring the art community to us.” 

“Octopus Dream” (2019) by Daniel Weetman, “Boom Bullet” (2019) by Niutuiatua Lemalu and a photograph by Julia Mage’au Gray. PHOTOS: VUNILAGI VOU.

She’s worked all over the world and says one of the barriers to lower income or minority communities enjoying art is the walls of the galleries themselves. Vunilagi Vou has a glass storefront, which is one of the reasons the space stood out to Tavola.

“At lots of gallery openings, you’ll find Pacific people outside. They’ll be outside because they don’t often feel that comfortable inside. I love that we can say this is an inside outside gallery. The arcade makes it sort of a safe space as well, you don’t have to have an intention to go to an art gallery, it’s just here as part of our landscape.”

It’s probably no surprise that most of the artists in Tavola’s show have jobs outside their creative pursuits. The arts have always been seen as an elusive way to make money, and there is no difference here. “One of Daniel’s jobs is being a musician in the Black Seeds, but like most creative pursuits, there’s often a need to subsidise creative incomes with other work.”

But exhibitions like the one at Vunilagi Vou do create moments where more established artists and new artists can take a space on a wall next to each other. Tavola says this exposure can help both of these groups in different ways. “It’s really good having the likes of Daniel Weetman who’s never exhibited before, be able to say his first exhibition was alongside Andy Leleisi’uao, who is one of our most successful contemporary Pacific artists. It’s beneficial for emerging artists, and it’s really beneficial for Andy as well because, in the art world, success is about selling work mostly to people not in your community.

“Our artists are our prophets, they connect us to our past and present and future and they hold a special place. It’s about bringing it back and not letting art be held and seen as a palagi thing because it’s not. It belongs to us, it sits in our communities, it should sit and be accessible to our people.”