SportsAugust 29, 2017

The case for renaming the Black Ferns


The next women’s Rugby World Cup should be defended by a team named the All Blacks, argues Jamie Wall.

The Black Ferns won the World Cup on Sunday, beating England 42-31 in a highly entertaining advertisement for women’s rugby. Not only did it spark celebrations for an unprecedented fifth Rugby World Cup title, it also brought up the age old arguments of funding and support for minor sports in this country. (Minor sports being everything that isn’t men’s rugby, America’s Cup yachting, cricket and, for some reason, the Warriors.)

A lot was made in the wash up about the part-time, more or less amateur status of the players and why they aren’t paid more. There is one quick fix for the Black Ferns, and it’s one that should have been taken care of years ago. It’s that they shouldn’t be called the Black Ferns. They should be the All Blacks.

In 2010, NZ Rugby made a decision to align the senior representative teams under the All Blacks name. All of a sudden we had the Māori All Blacks and All Blacks Sevens to go along with the national side. It didn’t go down too well in some quarters, and the union didn’t help itself by slashing the funding and effort required for the abbreviated version of the game.

The Māori All Blacks have a very condensed calendar these days and their lack of preparation time was clearly evident in June when they were thumped by the British and Irish Lions. Meanwhile the less said about the All Blacks Sevens the better, given that they bombed out of the Rio Olympics and failed to win a tournament at all last season.

Still, there was no reason given for why the Black Ferns weren’t brought under the same naming umbrella. It was even less logical to not apply a new name to the women’s sevens team, who have been far more successful than their male counterparts, who went on simply being called the ‘New Zealand Women’s Sevens Team’.

The fact is, the Black Ferns are the closest thing to the All Blacks there is. They are the only other open, senior New Zealand national XV. Not to mention their excellent test record and World Cup success. So why not put them together, for brand alignment at the very least?

First and foremost, this is a pragmatic solution to an existing problem. The women’s programme needs money and this is an easy way to get it. They can easily slide in beside the men and start sharing their endorsement deals, match fixtures and merchandise sales – because they’ll play in identical jerseys.

Put them in ads alongside the men – because, you know, marketing to women is probably a good idea anyway. It’s highly unlikely anyone will get offended by seeing Portia Woodman taking a swig of Gatorade with Sonny Bill Williams after a clearly staged training session.

And don’t just call them the All Blacks, make them All Blacks. Add all the women who have represented our country into the official list – admittedly the one that no one paid any attention to until the 1000th All Black made his debut. Put their records in alongside the men. Boast about how the All Blacks have won eight World Cups, an Olympic medal, and how a former All Black was the driving force to legalise same-sex marriage.

Captain Fiao’o Fa’amausili lifts the trophy. (Photo: David Rogers/Getty Images)

Right now the media is already starting to put the women on the same par with the men, anyway. One of the more frequent soundbites of the last fortnight was how superstar winger Portia Woodman is on track with prolific All Black try-scorer Joe Rokocoko’s strike rate after 20 tests.

Just make it official. If nothing else it’ll mean that Woodman will have the World Cup record for tries in a match by an All Black – a record currently held by Marc Ellis.

And guess what? It’s been done before, and was highly successful – just the other way round. The name ‘Black Sticks’ used to refer to just the women’s hockey team, until Hockey NZ aligned the name for both sides. While the women have a clearly higher profile, a Google search brings up news and images of both sides.

I know this will cause some consternation among fans of the Black Ferns’ name, and yes, I do understand that there is a lot of mana that has been built into it by some seriously committed and strong women. But things change, and often for the better. I watched Athletic Park, home of some of the most iconic moments in All Blacks history, get torn to the ground and replaced with Westpac Stadium. The British & Irish Lions played Super Rugby teams rather than provincial unions this year and it worked perfectly. Rucking is long gone and no one under the age of 58 misses it.

The uncomfortable truth is that the Black Ferns name isn’t going to bring the money that the All Blacks can. Right now they have AIG emblazoned on their shirts and that’s where the bulk of their operating budget comes from, but by making them a full rather than junior partner in the All Black brand will mean exposure to a whole new world of commercial opportunities.

But let’s just put the money issue aside. Given the standing the All Blacks have in our society, this would be a huge gesture towards the equal standing of women in employment. Because it’s 2017, and it’s kind of a big deal.

The content originally ran on

Our sports coverage is powered by the generous support of our members. If you value what we do and want to help us do more – tautoko mai, donate today.

Mad Chapman, Editor
Aotearoa continues to adapt to a new reality and The Spinoff is right there, sorting fact from fiction to bring you the latest updates and biggest stories. Help us continue this coverage, and so much more, by supporting The Spinoff Members.Madeleine Chapman, EditorJoin Members

Get The Spinoff
in your inbox