spinofflive
Mongrel Mob Defence, released by Supremacy, replaced the titular Mongrel Mob member with… Alf Stewart.
Mongrel Mob Defence, released by Supremacy, replaced the titular Mongrel Mob member with… Alf Stewart.

Pop CultureJanuary 22, 2018

The Mongrel Mob game is bleak proof that all publicity is good publicity

Mongrel Mob Defence, released by Supremacy, replaced the titular Mongrel Mob member with… Alf Stewart.
Mongrel Mob Defence, released by Supremacy, replaced the titular Mongrel Mob member with… Alf Stewart.

On Friday little known developer Supremacy released a mobile game named Mongrel Mob Defence and the media, predictably, went nuts. Sam Brooks says this kind of controversy not only allows these kinds of developers to thrive – it’s what they need to survive.

Thousands of games come out every year. As each year passes, more and more of these are mobile games. To get noticed among the deluge of games, many with the same core gameplay but different bright colours, you have to stand out. One way of standing out is by being genuinely good, getting your audience to love you, getting people to talk about your game. You know, the organic way to stand out.

The other way of standing out is to do something incredibly controversial that will get the name of your game and your company to a group of people who have never heard of your game, absolutely never heard of your company and probably have never played a mobile game other than Words With Friends.

Ladies and all otherly identified, this is how you get a game like Mongrel Mob Defence, and also how you get the absolute shitstorm that surrounded it this past weekend. (A shitstorm which I am delicately adding my take to.)

A highly photorealistic rendering, surely.

Mongrel Mob Defence is a simple, dumb and offensive game. In its original form, the player is a Mongrel Mob member. Your goal is to shoot Black Power members as they come onscreen. If you fail, you die. That’s it. Simple, not super innovative. Where it gets offensive is that the player character is a notorious member of the Mongrel Mob, Greco  – or more accurately, a caricature of Greco. Greco was a real person who passed away six years ago.

Depicting a real-life figure, even one as understandably controversial as Greco, as a caricatured character whose only purpose in the game is to shoot Black Power members is offensive. That’s obvious. It’s in poor taste, it is incredibly unclassy and just a pretty shitty thing to do to a real person. This isn’t like Assassin’s Creed portraying Richard the Lionheart as a power-hungry Templar. This is a real person whose family is still alive, likely with real and present feelings that were not taken into consideration making this game.

After the completely reasonable outcry, the developers added this note to the game:

Just in case you thought that Supremacy were acting in good faith, this confirms that… nope. They just want to screw around with people for a bad taste laugh.

We should absolutely decry something offensive when it’s done. But the profile of this game has been exponentially increased by its coverage. Over the weekend, it hit number one on the Google App store. There is absolutely no way that it would’ve come anywhere near that achievement without the controversy it generated – the controversy it was designed to generate.

The developer Supremacy has other apps on the Google Play Store which are equally tasteless. They’re largely free sound apps: Ooga Booga Sound, Fart Sound, Donald Trump Sound, and so on. (There’s also a Blow Valve Sound, which I guess isn’t tasteless but potentially helpful should you ever require a Blow Valve Sound.)

There’s absolutely no way the Herald, RNZ or Newshub would’ve looked twice at this game if it had been popped into their inbox via a press release. Hell, there’s no way I would’ve looked at it twice, and I actually care about video games. But you call your game Mongrel Mob Defence, use a caricature of a real-life person in it, make them do caricatured and offensive things and suddenly you’ve got five hundred comments on Facebook, fifty shares, and a handful of death threats.

A weekend of controversy gave this game more success than many other games of this ilk will have in their entire life. I am now aware of an app developer named Supremacy, and before I stumbled across a news post on Facebook I sure as hell wasn’t. I don’t think I ever would have been. A developer like Supremacy doesn’t just thrive on controversy, it breathes on controversy.

Giving oxygen to this game is like listening to the floppy-haired teenager from next door talk about how anarchy is the only way forward; you legitimise him just by giving him your time and your oxygen. Mongrel Mob Defence and Supremacy have had enough oxygen. Let them suffocate on their own carbon dioxide now, thanks.

In a statement to Newshub, the developer called the game a ‘comical time-waster.’ Absolutely. And continuing to talk about this game is a slightly less comical time-waster. If you want to support some cool New Zealand developers who are making games that you should absolutely give oxygen to, check out Dinosaur Polo Club or PikPok Games.


This post, like all our gaming content, comes to your peepers only with the support of Bigpipe Broadband

Keep going!
alex (1)

Pop CultureJanuary 21, 2018

What international reality franchises should NZ adopt next?

alex (1)

2018 is going to be a big year for local reality franchises from Dancing With the Stars to Project Runway, but what’s still missing? Calum Henderson fills in the gaps. 

It’s never too late to pick up a successful international reality television franchise and give it a good honest Kiwi twist. Last year we saw the inaugural season of Survivor NZ arrive 17 years after the first US Survivor was broadcast, and this year TVNZ have promised another decades-overdue New Zealand reality first in Project Runway NZ.

The frantic fashion design show looks to be the cornerstone of another bumper year for reality television in this country: other new titles coming to TVNZ include competitive upcycling show Design Junkies and the off-brand Love Island clone Heartbreak Island, while Three has the Colin Mathura-Jeffree-hosted Great NZ Dance Masala in the pipeline.

When you add in the long list of returning titles (Dancing With The Stars, Survivor season 2, The Block season 100) there sure is a lot of reality programming coming our way in 2018… but there could always be more. How, for example, have any of these not been made yet?

New Zealand Ninja Warrior

Put the call out to every crossfit gym and rock climbing club in the country – the extreme agility course show is a reality bandwagon New Zealand needs to get on ASAP. From Top Town to Clash of the Codes and even Tux Wonder Dogs, we already have a proud history of making this sort of thing. A New Zealand Ninja Warrior – or better yet, a slightly low-budget rip-off – should be at the top of every network’s to-do list.

The Voice NZ

The law of diminishing returns in New Zealand reality television has never been more evident than the second series of X Factor NZ. It was so abysmal it seems to have put us off making competitive singing shows altogether (with the exception of TVNZ 1’s acappella The Naked Choir last year). Talk about throwing the baby out with the bathwater. The Voice has always felt a better fit for us anyway – a nation of above average singing ability and below average charisma. Someone please borrow those mechanical swivel chairs from the Australian version and give New Zealand the televised singing competition it deserves.

Family Food Fight NZ / The Great Kiwi Bake Off

Without the cold hard data to back it up, it seems safe to say New Zealand has more celebrity chefs per capita than any other country in the world. We certainly don’t need any more, yet we still persist in making reality shows based around the tedious exploits of amateur foodies hoping to catch a cookbook deal. The rest of the world has already embraced the new wave of fun cooking shows full of heart and personality (Marae Kai Masters on Māori TV is our best local example). A big-scale New Zealand version of Australia’s multicultural Family Food Fight (currently on TVNZ 2), or even a local attempt at emulating the wildly popular Great British Bake Off, looks like the way to go.

Shark Tank NZ

Imagine how many new inventions have been dreamed up by entrepreneurial and/or delusional New Zealanders since the first and only series of Dragons’ Den NZ (featuring prominent dragons Dame Julie Christie and Sir Bob Jones) aired in 2006. It’s possible that New Zealand simply wasn’t ready for such a show back then, but the overseas success of the modern variant Shark Tank in recent years suggests we ought to give it another try. He would no doubt sniff at the idea, but Gareth Morgan would make a sensational shark.

Big Brother NZ

Weirdly Big Brother and its thrillingly bleak ‘celebrity’ variant is still going strong in quite a few countries. On one hand, New Zealanders should probably take great pride in the fact our country is one of the few places to have never produced a local series of the show. On the other… you have to admit Big Brother NZ would be quite something. You know you would watch it. We would all watch it. The guy with the pet pig from Married At First Sight NZ would probably go on it. It would be the reality TV apocalypse. Bring it on.

Garry Busey will probably be there

This content, like all our television coverage we do at The Spinoff, is brought to you thanks to the excellent folk at Lightbox. Do us and yourself a favour by clicking here to start a FREE 30 day trial of this truly wonderful service