It has been a week. (Photo: Fiona Goodall/Getty Images)
It has been a week. (Photo: Fiona Goodall/Getty Images)

PoliticsJuly 26, 2020

Live updates, July 26: Labour over 60%, National at 25% in Newshub poll

It has been a week. (Photo: Fiona Goodall/Getty Images)
It has been a week. (Photo: Fiona Goodall/Getty Images)

Welcome to The Spinoff’s live updates for July 26. The latest on New Zealand news, politics and the Covid-19 crisis, updated throughout the day. 

7.30pm: The day in sum

National recorded a terrible result in a new Reid poll for Newshub, with Labour passing 60%. Judith Collins rejected it as a rogue poll.

A new, merged political vehicle was launched by Jami-Lee Ross and Billie Te Kahika.

Chlöe Swarbrick hit back at being called a “celebrity” candidate by Auckland Central rival Helen White.

There were no new cases of Covid-19 in New Zealand.

Australia reported its deadliest day since the pandemic began.

An investigation into “pumped storage” options was announced.

The Green co-leaders made a pitch for support based on public trust.

Jacinda Ardern turned 40.

6.45pm: What a difference three years makes

Different polling companies, different methodologies and different times, but it’s pretty stunning to consider tonight’s Reid Research poll for Newshub with the poll published almost exactly three years ago, and at almost exactly the same proximity to the 2017 election as tonight’s is to the 2020 edition.

Colmar Brunton One News poll, three years ago versus Reid Newshub poll today:

National: 47% / 25%
Labour: 24% / 61%
Green: 15% / 6%
NZ First: 11% / 2%
Act: 0.5% / 3.5%

6.20pm: ‘One in 20 polls will always be a rogue’ – Brownlee

National has doubled down on dismissing the Reid/Newshub poll (see 6.05pm) as unreliable. Gerry Brownlee, chair of the National campaign, has taken the unusual step of issuing a press release in response to a TV survey, saying: “These numbers aren’t even in the same ballpark as our internal polls, other public polls and the hugely positive public response to our Leader Judith Collins.”

And: “Even with the most rigorous methodology, one in 20 polls will always be a rogue and this is clearly one of them. More than 200,000 New Zealanders are already out of work – and that is before we experience the full impact of the economic crisis as the wage subsidy scheme comes to an end.

6.05pm: Poll crushing news for Collins and National

A new Reid Research poll for Newshub puts National at just over 25%, with Labour surpassing 60%.

The key numbers:

Labour: 60.9% (up 4.4 from last Newshub poll)
National: 25.1% (down 5.5)
Greens: 5.7% (up 0.2)
NZ First: 2% (down 0.7)
Act: 3.3% (up 1.5)
Conservatives: 0.9% (down 0.1)
Māori Party: 0.4% (down 0.5)
TOP O.4% (up 0.3)

Those numbers would make it possible, indeed comfortable, for Labour to govern alone. They’d take 77 of the 120 seats, with National getting 32, the Greens 7 and Act 4.

In the preferred PM numbers, Collins has better news, hitting 14.6%, up 11.5 points from the last poll, and well above the 4.5% Simon Bridges registered before he was toppled by Todd Muller. Jacinda Ardern is on 62%, up 2.5.

“This is a rogue poll,” Collins told Newshub. That “reeks of desperation”, said Tova O’Brien, Newshub’s political editor.

The poll was in the field July 16-24. Collins became leader on July 14.

Read Newshub’s full coverage here.

5.15pm: The JLR-BTK show

As promised, Alex Braae has filed his report from the conscious coupling of Jami-Lee Ross’s Advance NZ Party and Billy Te Kahiki’s Public Party. It sounds like a carnival of conspiracy theory, but don’t dismiss it too quick. As Alex notes, the project will be a test of whether the rampant under-the-radar conversation on the likes of fluouride, anti-Vaxx, Covid-hoax and 5G that plays out on social media can form, with a dash of Jami-Lee Ross thrown into the soup, into electoral success. The turnout – at least 1,000, by Alex’s reckoning – would leave most New Zealand political parties envious.

Here’s a taste of his account:

There were attacks on Dr Ashley Bloomfield, who had spent time at the WHO. “Anyone who does any length of time at an organisation like that is going to be fully indoctrinated.” There were enthusiastic boos for the “fully groomed globalist” Jacinda Ardern. “Her story speaks like the perfect history of a prime minister who will betray our people.”

It was Agenda 21. It was anti-vaxxing. It was 5G. It was people being forced out of the provinces to live in “technocratic high rise cities”. It was all on the way, said Te Kahika, and he was the only one who could stand in the way of “them”, who were using Covid-19 to get the public used to “herd control”.

3.30pm: Pumped storage project part of 100% renewable ambition

A major investment in “pumped storage” options which may pave the way to a 100% renewable power grid have been announced today. The Government will fund a “close examination” of an Interim Climate Change Committee recommendation to develop hydro schemes which pump water to manage demand for electricity.

“If a business case stacks up pumped hydro would be a game changer for securing sustainable, cheaper, low-emissions electricity for the long term,” said Megan Woods, who among other things is the minister for energy, in a statement.

“Pumped hydro moves water to an upper reservoir when there is surplus renewable energy generation and demand for electricity is low. It is released back down to a hydro power station to generate electricity when demand is high. It works like a battery because the stored energy in the water is released when it is used in the hydroelectric dam. This opens up huge possibilities for cheaper electricity and increased supply.”

The government has allocated $30 million to the analysis, which will predominantly be focused on a pumped hydro storage project at Lake Onslow in Central Otago.

Russel Norman of Greenpeace welcomed the move, but stressed that the investigation must “look at the climate, biodiversity, social, cultural, technical and economic impacts of such a scheme”.

2.05pm: Australia records deadliest day of pandemic

More tragic news from across the Tasman, with the state of Victoria reporting 10 more people have died from coronavirus, making it the deadliest day in Australia since Covid-19 first arrived. The news came as Victoria, which has returned to lockdown, recorded 459 new cases of the coronavirus.

“Seven men ranging in age from their 40s to their 80s and three women in their 70s and 80s are the latest to die from the virus and take the state’s death toll to 71,” reported the ABC.

More than 42,000 tests were processed yesterday, a new high.

Read Siouxsie Wiles here on the critical difference between the strategy in Australia, and that in New Zealand.

1.15pm: Jami-Lee Ross’s Advance Party merges with NZ Public Party

The leftfield potential of New Zealand elections over the last decade continues in 2020, with the confirmation this afternoon that the Advance Party of Jami-Lee Ross has merged with Billy Te Kahika’s NZ Public Party.

A statement announcing the merger of Ross’s fledgling party, formed after he was ejected from the National Party in a fireball of scandal, and the NZ Public Party, which has built an online following which includes many conspiracy theorists, makes clear it is a marriage of convenience. “By forming an alliance of parties, together with other small parties that believe in greater freedom and democracy, we stand a stronger chance of uniting together and crossing the five percent threshold into parliament,” said Ross.

He called the new combo “the new Alliance Party of the 2020s, but a centrist version of that model”. Te Kahika will stand in Te Tai Tokerau and Ross in Botany.

The Spinoff’s Alex Braae is at the launch event, where he is watching what “may be the wildest shit I’ve seen in this country’s politics”. We’ll have a full dispatch from our chief wild shit correspondent later today.

Speaking of Jami-Lee Ross, Andrea Vance’s interview with Sarah Dowie, the Invercargill MP who is leaving parliament at the end of the term, makes for important, sobering reading.

1.00pm: No new cases of Covid-19

There are no new cases of Covid-19 in New Zealand, the Ministry of Health has announced in a press release. There are no new recovered cases, either, so the total active case number remains at 21, all of whom are in managed isolation or quarantine. It is 86 days since there was a case of Covid-19 “acquired locally from an unknown source”, said the ministry release.

Yesterday laboratories processed 1,754 tests, well short of the daily target of 4,000. “Testing remains an important part of our overall strategy to detect any community cases of Covid-19 as quickly as possible,” is the ministry message. “We all have a part to play and we’re encouraging anyone who is offered a swab, to take up that offer.”

12.05pm: New role for top Trump aide, New Zealander Chris Liddell

Reuters is reporting that Chris Liddell, deputy chief of staff in Donald Trump’s White House, is about to be nominated by the US as the next secretary to the OECD. Sometimes dubbed the “club of wealthy nations”, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development is a policy and research body comprised of 37 nations including New Zealand.

Liddell is one of the very few White House senior staff who have survived more than a couple of years in a turbulent Trump term. Born in Matamata, Liddell was a student at Mt Albert Grammar and Auckland University. He has been CEO of Carter Holt Harvey in New Zealand, and the CFO at both General Motors and Microsoft in the US.

His little red Corvette parked outside the West Wing, Liddell’s White House role overseeing the policy process includes determining which officials get face time with the president. “The US is committed to a strong and unified OECD, and intends to nominate Christopher P Liddell to be the next secretary general of the OECD,” said an unnamed official, according to Reuters.

Chris Liddell at the White House. Photo: The Spinoff

10.45am: Swarbrick hits back at ‘celebrity’ label

Auckland Central’s Labour candidate, Helen White, launched her campaign on Friday night by urging left-leaning voters to support her efforts to peg back the 1,518 majority achieved at the last election by Nikki Kaye, who in recent months was elevated to the National deputy leadership before quitting politics altogether. White told RNZ that there was no chance of a deal to make way for Chlöe Swarbrick, the Green candidate who has launched a full-blooded campaign to win the seat itself, rather than the usual party-tick-focused campaign favoured by the Greens.

White’s team is keen to point out that at the last election the Green candidate won fewer than 3,000 votes, compared with her 11,617. Don’t split the vote, is their message. It’s a compelling argument. But the tone and language of the campaign is evidently playing directly into the hands of Swarbrick’s campaign. Sarah Robson reported that when asked what she would say to those who pointed to Swarbrick’s higher profile, White said: “I’d ask them whether they’re looking for a celebrity or someone to do this job very seriously.”

In response Swarbrick has this morning had this to say: “Before I fought my way into parliament with the Greens, I was dismissed as having no life experience. Now I’ve put my head down and done the work to huge results, and a candidate preferring themselves the front runner is using the same attacks against me that misogynists do our PM?”

It’s already a heated race, and we don’t even know who the National candidate is yet.

10.00am: Bloomfield of dreams

Several ongoing plot lines in the story of New Zealand collided yesterday in Wainuiomata, where Ashley Bloomfield took the field for the Centurions versus the Parliamentarians. Here he is, as you’ve never seen him before:

Ashley Bloomfield makes a run during the 25th annual parliamentary rugby match. (Photo by Elias Rodriguez/Getty Images)

We sent our political editor, Justin Giovannetti to watch the game. It was the first game of rugby he’d watched in his life. Read his match report here.

9.45am: The prime minister turns 40

Happy birthday to Jacinda Ardern, who like so many of us no doubt woke this morning wondering at a milestone birthday whether she would make anything of her life. Her daughter, Neve, recently marked her own milestone birthday (2) with a cake from the greatest cake book of them all.

Here’s hoping that her family managed something from the book today. Or maybe they enlisted top New Zealand pâtissière Laura Daniel to whip up another of these tributes?

Laura Daniel’s Jacinda cake

Three years ago today, Jacinda Ardern wasn’t even the leader of the Labour Party. It was, however, a momentous day in its own right. Here’s what she wrote in her review of the last election:

We were resolute, united, focused on policy and ideas, but by June and July Labour was polling in the mid-20s and falling. In fact, I remember specifically the crunch point, and since then both Andrew and I have spoken about it.

It was the 26th of July. I remember because it was my birthday. 

9.30am: Greens point to trust failure in politics

The Green Party yesterday launched its campaign for the 2020 election, along with a 52-page document designed to underpin its policy thinking both in post-election negotiations and in government, should it find itself there again. Thomas Coughlan of Stuff has a good summary of its contents here.

Both co-leaders appeared on Q+A this morning, and there was a strong indication of the kind of messages the Greens are likely to be pushing. Marama Davidson said that while the party had not achieved everything it sought over the last three years, “it’s clear for people to see what the Greens have been fighting to the wire for.” Asked by Jack Tame for the achievement she was most proud of, Davidson pointed to the ban on new offshore oil and gas explorations, “something our people and our party have been campaigning for for decades”.

She refused to say whether or not she trusted New Zealand First, instead noting that the Greens, unlike other parties, were not embroiled in investigations or charges relating to donations. “I think politics at the moment is showing that people need to have trust in the democratic system,” said Davidson. “All political parties need to do a lot better.”

8.00am: Yesterday’s key stories

After a major police search overnight, a 17-year-old boy who absconded from a managed isolation facility in Hamilton was apprehended by police in Auckland yesterday morning. He and three family members appeared in court, and it emerged they had been trying to attend the children’s father’s funeral.

The Greens launched their election campaign with a new policy platform entitled “Think Ahead, Act Now”.

There were no new cases of Covid-19.

Director general of health Ashley Bloomfield scored a try for the Centurions XV in a rugby match against the Parliamentary XV in Wainuiomata.

Read yesterday’s live updates here

Keep going!
The Public / Advance Party conscious coupling in Auckland. Photo: Alex Braae
The Public / Advance Party conscious coupling in Auckland. Photo: Alex Braae

OPINIONPoliticsJuly 26, 2020

Jami-Lee Ross, Billy Te Kahika and the rebel alliance of Election 2020

The Public / Advance Party conscious coupling in Auckland. Photo: Alex Braae
The Public / Advance Party conscious coupling in Auckland. Photo: Alex Braae

Can the conspiracy theories of social media be coalesced into a party that makes parliament under MMP? We’re about to find out. Alex Braae attends the conscious conspiracy-theory-replete coupling ceremony.

A covers band was smashing out a blistering version of ‘Higher and Higher’, on a stage packed with candidates. The flags were waving proudly over a packed and heaving Logan Campbell Centre in Auckland. Vinnie Eastwood, New Zealand’s most prominent conspiracy theorist YouTuber, was right up the front in a suit getting absolutely wild with it.

The band rolled straight into ‘Simply the Best’, which was meant to be the triumphant intro music. But the star speaker wasn’t quite ready to come out, and there was a lull.

In the brief break, I had a chat to Norm from Tauranga. He had never voted in his entire life, but had suddenly been mobilised. He has no trust at all in the established media, but had started to “wake up” after seeing what was “really happening”, as he put it.

Then the band picked up the chorus again. At least a thousand voices in the hall roared as Billy Te Kahika Jr, the leader of the New Zealand Public Party, emerged. He placed his hand on his heart, and drank in the standing ovation.

The first speaker was the party’s Banks Peninsula candidate, who rarked the crowd up with calls that it was time to take the country back. Finally, he said, there was a leader who would be speaking the truth to them.

“This moment has risen like a tsunami from the silent ones. We have heard you, and together we have watched in amazement, disbelief and increasing unease as the government and ones before them have sold us out.”

Billy Te Kahika and Jami-Lee Ross speaking to media after the launch (Photo: Alex Braae)

When it was Te Kahika’s turn to speak, he opened with a long mihi, before expressing surprise to be “at the front of a movement to lead on your behalf”. He described himself as “the most reluctant politician you’ve ever seen” and told the crowd, again and again, that it was “your movement”.

Te Kahika’s journey through “the eclectic kind of life I’ve had” has largely revolved around music. Last time he was on the stage at the Logan Campbell Centre, he was playing support for bluesman George Thorogood. He’s a Christian, and has a small ministry in Te Tai Tokerau. Over the last few months, he has been speaking to increasingly large crowds through the provinces, and building up an immense social media profile.

During lockdown, he started to “look at the narratives surrounding the Covid-19 health crisis”. He had been in Chicago a few weeks previous, and said while he was there, “Covid-19 had entered the global media”. Then, coming back to New Zealand, it was “fear, fear, fear” on every screen he saw. “And I started to see cracks in the story.”

“It told me that the Covid-19 health crisis was something that was going to be used, to eventually destroy our democracy in Aotearoa New Zealand.” He wanted people to understand that he believed in the dominant scientific understanding of Covid-19 at first, but no longer did.

It hardly needs saying that the views of Te Kahika – and evidently shared by the crowd – go against official scientific advice. In fact, it might even be fair to say that they don’t believe official scientific advice precisely because of who the messengers are. They have no trust in the government, international institutions like the World Health Organisation or the United Nations, or billionaire philanthropists like Bill Gates.

There were attacks on Dr Ashley Bloomfield, who had spent time at the WHO. “Anyone who does any length of time at an organisation like that is going to be fully indoctrinated.” There were enthusiastic boos for the “fully groomed globalist” Jacinda Ardern. “Her story speaks like the perfect history of a prime minister who will betray our people.”

It was Agenda 21. It was anti-vaxxing. It was 5G. It was people being forced out of the provinces to live in “technocratic high-rise cities”. It was all on the way, said Te Kahika, and he was the only one who could stand in the way of “them”, who were using Covid-19 to get the public used to “herd control”.

His speech was sharp, and he proved expert at moving the crowd. When he needed them to laugh, he had a joke about the people in the room knowing how to grow food, grow kūmara, and “grow other stuff as well, but we won’t go there”. When he needed them to be angry, he asked questions to which the response was a single roared word – “No.”

A curious aspect of the strident anti-globalism of his platform was that it also embraced multiculturalism, in stark contrast to the similar sorts of populism being seen in the US and Europe. Much of the crowd was Māori, and there were explicit references in Te Kahika’s speech to bringing in New Zealanders from other ethnicities, along with candidates who Te Kahika described as “new New Zealanders”.

The press releases ahead of the event pitched it as a merger of Advance NZ and the NZ Public Party. Jami-Lee Ross, who formed Advance NZ after being kicked out of the National Party, had apparently not brought many of the people along.

But Te Kahika did give a strong shout out to his new co-leader. He had spent weeks talking to minor parties about whether they wanted to work together, and received dismissive responses. But not Jami-Lee Ross. “Out of all of these people, there was only one person who said to me, ‘Billy, I want to help. Billy, I want you to use my party, and I want you to take the number one list position in this party,’” said Te Kahika.

When he did take the stage, he said it was “one of the most exciting days of my political career”, and that he had never before spoken to such a large and excited crowd. He was ready to give the people what they wanted, saying it was time for a new type of politics. “Judith, Jacinda, Winston, it’s all one and the same. Now I don’t know about you, but I’ve had enough of politics as usual down in Wellington.”

Billy Te Kahika speaks (Photo: Alex Braae)

He too called for “more questioning” about “how the Chinese Communist Party has been allowed to wreak so much economic devastation around the world”, referring to the unevidenced theory that Covid-19 is a bioweapon. Within the first three months of the election, Ross promised that the free-trade agreement with China would be suspended, pending a “full investigation”.

It’s a curious stance for an MP who spent years as the National Party’s chief whip. By all accounts, he was politics as usual, until he exploded his own career. “I’ve seen up close how more and more, that party has given up our people to foreign interests,” he said of his former colleagues. He cast it as a case of blowing the whistle on dodgy donations. There were hecklers during his speech saying he needed to address the allegations made by the women, which he said afterwards that he didn’t hear. By the end of his speech, the people were on their feet for Ross too.

Te Kahika will be running in the Māori electorate of Te Tai Tokerau, and while it is a long shot, it is not entirely beyond the realm of possibility that he could win it. The area has long been impoverished, particularly for those who are Māori, and successive changes in representatives hasn’t changed that. Why shouldn’t the voters take a punt on someone offering something very different?

The strategy from here could also give Advance NZ (the party under whose banner the two parties will be running) an outside chance at the 5% MMP threshold. The aim is to create a “centrist version” of the Alliance, which gained significant support to the left of Labour in the 1990s. Ross said that there had been talks with seven other parties, saying they could keep their independence, structure and leadership under the combined banner. “If we ever want to take on the established parties, we must unite together,” said Ross, saying bygones could be bygones.

Ross name checked a list of parties with which they had been talking – the Outdoors Party, the New Conservatives, the Opportunities Party, Social Credit have all been talked to, along with the very newly formed One Party and Heartland Party. Vision NZ and the Tea Party (which has been accused of following a pro-Chinese Communist Party line) were the only ones off the table.

In response, several of those parties immediately ruled it out. New Conservative deputy leader Elliot Ikilei said “we were presented with a proposal that would dissolve our integrity, support and values foundation, therefore have respectfully declined”. Geoff Simmons from the Opportunities Party was more blunt – “no way would I ever stand on a stage and shake hands with those snake oil salesmen”. Ross later claimed that it was a different story when the two parties had a meeting a few weeks ago.

The response from Alan Simmons, co-leader of the Outdoors Party, was particularly interesting. He said their party would have nothing to do with it, after also attending a meeting with Ross and Te Kahika, coming away from that deeply suspicious. “We find it wrong that the Electoral Commission is considering registration of a party of which Jami-Lee Ross is both leader and secretary when he is facing Serious Fraud Office charges of election fraud. Large sums of money have been collected as donations by the NZPP and need to be accounted for under the Electoral Act.”

At the media standup after the speeches, Newshub’s Jenna Lynch asked Ross and Te Kahika a series of questions trying to pin down exactly what they thought about hot-button conspiracy theory topics like 5G and vaccinations. In response, she got a lot of talk about how the party was “just asking questions”, and reflecting what they were hearing back to the people. At one point, Lynch appeared almost frustrated when the pair denied that such talk would be dangerous for the country’s Covid-19 response – “come on Jami-Lee, you’re an intelligent person, you know what asking these questions does”. He wasn’t thrown in the slightest.

There were more people filming the media at the press conference than actual reporters there. The NZ Public Party has built the following it has predominantly online. It is possible that citizen videos of the event will reach as many people through social media as the mainstream outlets that covered it. As the reporters were finishing up, a man muttered at us about the “$50 million for bullshit” bailout that was announced earlier in the year. Leaving the standup, some smiles were returned with hard stares when people saw my camera.

But for the people who turned out, it had been a thrilling day, and they left upbeat. They had come from all parts of the North Island. And over the next weeks, they’ll take that message out far and wide, and in the process probably reach people totally unreachable by other forms of politics and messaging. The results of that could be unlike anything New Zealand has ever seen before.