property investment concept
Photo: Getty Images

The BulletinNovember 12, 2020

The Bulletin: Housing kingpins safe for now after Reserve Bank changes

property investment concept
Photo: Getty Images

Good morning and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: Property market set for scorching summer after Reserve Bank announcements, National makes big reshuffle, and Auckland Council facing much bigger deficit.

A big day for the Reserve Bank, with a range of announcements on monetary policy, with big implications for the housing market. First of all, the headline official cash rate will be kept at the record low of 0.25% – and as the NZ Herald reports, a new Funding for Lending (FLP) programme will be rolled out to banks. This is effectively what it sounds like – the Reserve Bank would “offer commercial banks a discounted retail rate which would lower their funding costs and enable them to cut mortgage rates further.” The expectation is that it would give banks an incentive to lend money to households and businesses, who would then use it to stimulate the economy.

On those two moves, one part of the economy is certainly likely to stay stimulated – the overheated housing market. That’s certainly the view from National, whose shadow treasurer Andrew Bayly put out a release saying there was little in the RBNZ announcement that would require such lending would go to productive investments, rather than just being parked up in property. In response, I’ll take a quote from journalist Bernard Hickey’s new (very good!) newsletter The Kākā, which noted:

The bank defended the lack of ‘strings’ attached to the lending, although it was clear in the MPS that bank lending since March had focused on housing lending, and had fallen for businesses. The Bank said the lack of business lending was more about a lack of demand than a lack of bank appetite.

Is the housing market spiralling out of control the Reserve Bank’s responsibility? Technically no, explains Stuff’s Thomas Coughlan. The RBNZ has a mandate to keep inflation at about the right level, and set monetary policy at a level that will support maximum sustainable employment. But it’s fair to say their moves have a huge impact on the housing market.

One other announcement means that we can probably expect an absolutely frantic summer of house-buying for those who already own property – Stuff reports loan to value restrictions are likely to be reintroduced next March, ahead of schedule. LVRs are about how much money can be borrowed against a deposit, and the dropping of them earlier this year has been pinpointed as a reason the housing market shot up this year, despite the wider economy being in trouble. Given there’s still a few months left, any property investor with a savvy and ruthless streak will be making the most of the current situation. Finance minister Grant Robertson is clearly concerned by this, and Interest reports he welcomed the move.

One other point worth noting about the Reserve Bank’s move on LVRs – it might be a sound move, but markets might get jittery as a result. As David Hargreaves writes on Interest, there was a clear steer when the changes were made earlier this year that they would last for at least a full year, which now won’t happen. You could argue that events have forced governor Adrian Orr’s hand, but at the same time it also arguably casts doubt on other medium term commitments from the RBNZ. The final lines of Hargreaves article are excellent, and capture the current sense of confusion and anxiety around monetary policy and the housing market:

If the open homes have been frenzied, heated affairs before now, what will they be like this weekend once everybody realises the LVR barrier is coming down again?

To be honest, given that it has done a u-turn anyway, and gone back on its word, I think the RBNZ might in this instance have been better to just simply clamp the LVRs on again straight away.

Maybe it didn’t want to look panicky – but given the circumstances of the timing of this announcement it looks panicky anyway.


National’s caucus reshuffle has provided some surprises, with the finance portfolio being split between two MPs, and two former leaders dropping down the rankings. Stuff has an analysis of who’s up and who’s down, and Justin Giovannetti has picked out 10 details of it all that jump out at him. On that finance split, Business Desk (paywalled) has drilled down into what it will mean to have both Andrew Bayly and Michael Woodhouse responsible for speaking on the topic, and the potential for confusion that creates. Meanwhile, commentator Liam Hehir has written about the elevation of Shane Reti to the deputy leadership, and argues that he could be an important voice of moderation within the party.


Auckland Council’s budget blowout is looking like it could hit a billion dollars, reports Radio NZ. Impacts on revenue from Covid-19 are likely to last longer than initially projected, meaning the Council will have to get by with less money, said mayor Phil Goff. The timing is pretty bad for new projects, with the new 10 year budget coming up for consultation next year. For example, I went out to Waiheke on Tuesday to see the rollout of some new electric buses, and one of the topics that came up in conversation was whether councillors could be convinced to bring them in for the whole city.


The Wellington City Council has voted to give the go-ahead for the heavily contested Shelly Bay redevelopment, reports Stuff. The vote is seen as a blow for mayor Andy Foster, and film mogul Peter Jackson, who both heavily opposed it. Councillors thrashed the issue out yesterday after a public consultation, which reading through the story sounds like it was fraught and tense. The redevelopment is still subject to two legal challenges currently before the courts.


Māori Party MPs asked the PM for a meeting about how they can work with the incoming government, reports Newsroom’s Jonathan Milne. They say it was wrong to not hold talks before the special votes were finalised, which resulted in co-leader Debbie Ngarewa-Packer coming in off the list. Meanwhile, the party is calling for recounts in two electorates, on the grounds that some people were allegedly denied the ability to vote on the Māori roll in polling booths – the Whanganui Chronicle’s Ethan Griffiths has an excellent story outlining the implications of the move.


A lot of controversy has been swirling around a deliberately provocative art show involving the heavy use of swastikas at Auckland’s Mercy Pictures. If, like me, you’ve only vaguely dipped into the controversy, this by Amal Samaha is an excellent piece to bring you up to speed. It gets into the details of how the art show came to be, but also looks at a wider irony-drenched culture of the art world, and how that can give people with fascist sympathies an opportunity to seed their messages with plausible deniability.


A new complainant has come forward against former Christchurch creche worker Peter Ellis, who died while trying to have his convictions overturned, reports Martin Van Beynen for Stuff. Ellis always maintained his innocence, despite being convicted on sex charges against seven children. The new complaint refers to an alleged incident that took place before Ellis began working at the Christchurch Civic Creche – the credibility of the evidence has been questioned by Ellis’ lawyer. The Supreme Court is currently hearing an appeal against the convictions.


A correction and apology: I make a fair few spelling mistakes, but yesterday I misspelled the name of my colleague Alice Webb-Liddall. So to Alice, and more importantly Alice’s mother who wrote in to register her strong disapproval, my humble apologies.


Got some feedback about The Bulletin, or anything in the news? Drop us a line at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz

Pikopiko – Monique Fiso likes to preserve it by brining or pickling (Photo: Manja Wachsmuth)

Right now on The Spinoff: Jihee Junn reports on why sharemarkets shot up in the wake of the recent Covid-19 vaccine news. Jonathan Cotton writes about the 500,000 native trees that have gone into the ground as part of the Trees that Count programme. Russell Brown writes about Unilever trying to eliminate carbon from its cleaning products. Brisbane chef Te Tangaroa Turnbull reviews Monique Fiso’s cookbook Hiakai. And we’re announcing a brand new upcoming podcast called Coming Home, about the people in the New Zealand diaspora who have decided to settle down here again.


For a feature today, a look at the misuse of the Official Information Act by a government department. Stuff’s Nikki Macdonald has detailed the attempts by journalists at her organisation to get at data around immunisation rates, which over the course of several years was not provided on various grounds. Then all of a sudden, the Herald asked for the same data, and it was provided. Here’s an excerpt:

But when New Zealand Herald data editor Chris Knox asked, one week after Duff, the information magically became available. Even then, some data was withheld despite top ministry staff admitting there was no legal basis to do so.

You’re thinking this must be about some terrible screw-up the Health Ministry was trying to bury, right? Not so. It’s about four journalists trying to do something worthwhile – to identify areas of New Zealand with low vaccination rates, and to investigate the reasons behind that.

The ministry’s internal communications surrounding the four separate requests – released only after I complained to the Ombudsman – suggest whether or not you get information depends on who you are, and whether you know the right technical password to switch on the data fountain. Both of which are at odds with the Official Information Act’s founding principle – that information should be made available unless there’s good reason to withhold it.


West Indian cricketers have had training privileges revoked after “repeatedly breaking managed isolation rules”, reports StuffThe incidents happened within the hotel, and involved some mingling being caught on CCTV. While their standard isolation period is going to come to an end soon, it could theoretically be extended if there are concerns. At the moment, the team is scheduled to travel to Queenstown on Friday for warmup matches, ahead of the series proper starting at the end of November.


That’s it for The Bulletin. If you want to support the work we do at The Spinoff, please check out our membership programme

Keep going!
A car trying to get through flooding in Napier (Supplied, K-Ci Williams)
A car trying to get through flooding in Napier (Supplied, K-Ci Williams)

The BulletinNovember 11, 2020

The Bulletin: Rain still falling in hard-hit Napier

A car trying to get through flooding in Napier (Supplied, K-Ci Williams)
A car trying to get through flooding in Napier (Supplied, K-Ci Williams)

Good morning and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: Rain still falling in hard-hit Napier, Covid-19 vaccine news comes with a catch, and government’s books in a better shape than expected.

It’s still raining heavily in Napier, and the flooding damage has got worse in the last 24 hours. As Stuff reports, hundreds of houses experienced a second night without power last night, and some are still in evacuation centres. People in the city are still being urged to limit water use to prevent further pressure on the stormwater system. A state of emergency remains in effect.

The downpour was caused by a convergence of factors, exacerbated by climate change but also sheer unfortunate circumstances. The NZ Herald’s Jamie Morton writes that 463% of the average monthly rainfall came down in the space of a few hours. A set of weather systems collided right over top of Napier, as opposed to out to sea or over a rural area. And as Niwa meteorologist Ben Noll put it, “in a warmer world, we’d expect those systems in 2020 to have the chance to produce more moisture than would have been the case back 50 years. So, while you can’t obviously pin climate change on this one event, you can say this is what we expect to see more of.”

The damage itself is really serious. Stuff has reported on a local artist who came worryingly close to being killed by a landslide hitting the side of his house. Hawke’s Bay Today reported on a woman on Hospital Hill who was buried up to her neck in mud, and had a lucky escape. Radio NZ reports this morning that at least 19 homes are now uninhabitable, amid hundreds more that have been damaged. Fortunately, nobody has been killed in this disaster, but the economic impacts will be serious. Stuff spoke to a furniture store owner whose showroom has now flooded twice in 15 years – he and his staff have a particularly painful few days of work ahead to get it all cleaned up.

Is the infrastructure able to cope with these sorts of events? Napier mayor Kirsten Wise has said the city’s pipes can handle one-in-100 year rainfall, but this was more like one-in-250 years. But I think it’s also worth reading this piece from local blog Napier in Frame, which is a bit more skeptical about the state of the infrastructure, and has the historical context to back that up.


Is this the Covid-19 vaccine we’ve been waiting for? If you didn’t hear the news yesterday, Alice Webb-Liddall has reported on promising signs coming out of Pfizer, which has an agreement with the NZ government to deliver 1.5 million doses once a vaccine has successfully been developed. That is enough for half that number of people, and minister Megan Woods has identified “our most vulnerable population groups, such as older people, disabled people, health workers, essential workers and border staff” as the first in line. Dr Siouxsie Wiles has also written a note of caution – there are some catches to be aware of before we get carried away by this news.


The latest look at the government’s books has shown them to be in better shape than expected, reports Interest’s Jenée Tibshraeny. The deficit is smaller, and the operating balance (OBEGAL) is less negative than what was forecast in the pre-election fiscal update. The finances are being bolstered by stronger than expected spending giving a GST boost, and less than expected being paid out through the wage subsidy. Finance minister Grant Robertson received the news by reiterating the core message of the government – that the best economic response to Covid-19 has been a strong health response.


National’s new deputy leader will be former Whangārei MP Dr Shane Reti, after he was unanimously confirmed by caucus. The NZ Herald reports Judith Collins also held onto her position, with no challengers coming forward for the leadership. The rest of the frontbench will be announced today. Reti, the party’s health spokesperson, has rocketed up the caucus rankings this year, and is arguably one of the few MPs across parliament who emerged from this year with a genuinely enhanced reputation. Once again, because it was an excellent piece, it’s worth going back and reading Justin Giovannetti’s interview with him from September.


University graduates are facing a daunting job market with rising unemployment, reports Radio NZ’s Nadia Amaral. Part of the issue is a change in the predominant type of job listing, from permanent positions to more casual jobs. It may also push some students to stick around and do postgrad study, to try and wait out the downturn.


The Supreme Court has handed down a decision with interesting implications for the personal liability of directors for companies that suffer losses. Because of the legal nature of the article, I’ll quote fairly heavily. Newsroom has got a couple of senior Bell Gully lawyers to comment on what the Debut Homes decision means, which overturned a previous Court of Appeal ruling. It found that the company’s sole director ” had incurred obligations without a reasonable belief that the company would be able to perform them when due”, and ordered a payment of $280,000 “in respect of the company’s net deficit to creditors.” Looking ahead, the decision “confirms that directors may well face personal liability if they allow their company to continue to trade in circumstances where a Court subsequently finds that they should have taken action earlier.”


Some feedback on yesterday’s Bulletin about the government declining to further raise benefit levels before Christmas: Jodie got in touch to say that despite the increase of core benefits by $25, because of other changes she didn’t end up with anything near as much as that in the hand. “So unfortunately it hasn’t really helped a lot at all.” If you want to read more on the topic, the Child Poverty Action Group’s Janet McAllister writes that the call is not for something lavish or luxurious – rather, what the coalition of NGOs and poverty groups are calling for is simply what would be adequate for people to have dignified lives.


We had some gremlins in the system yesterday, and some of you told me you couldn’t preorder The Side Eye annual. So once again, here it is: If you tried yesterday and couldn’t get through, please try again today and it should all work fine.


Got some feedback about The Bulletin, or anything in the news? Drop us a line at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz

What do you spy in this scene? A New Zealand icon.

Right now on The Spinoff: Holly Walker writes about how even small reductions in the number of car trips could reduce deaths and injuries, but transport planning doesn’t seem to be built around making that possible. Florence Dean writes about legislation on referendums for Māori wards at local government level, and why that should go. Stewart Sowman-Lund speaks to David Farrar about what it feels like to have a fairly innocuous politics tweet get dunked on by hundreds of prominent American leftists. Tara Ward reveals that the new season of The Crown has robbed New Zealand of the iconic Prince William Buzzy Bee moment.

And a new documentary from The Spinoff about a town that has put up with an unwelcome guest for years: The Paper Mill focuses on the dangerous ouvea premix stored in Mataura, and the locals who are desperate to see someone take responsibility for removing it.


For a feature today, a deeper look at the practice of crewing deep sea fishing vessels with Russians and Ukrainians. For many people, it only became apparent when there was a large number of Covid cases in an arriving contingent. However, as Business Desk (paywalled) editor Pattrick Smellie reports, it has actually been fairly standard for decades – whether or not that’s a good thing is in the eye of the beholder, but it’s a fair piece that gets into why it has happened. Here’s an excerpt:

For more than 25 years, a significant proportion of NZ deep-sea fishing vessels has been crewed by workers from Russia and Ukraine, brought in from the northern hemisphere on charter flights to spend up to six months at a time at sea.

“If you went back many years ago in New Zealand, pretty much 100 percent of those deep-water species would have been caught by charter vessels with foreign workers,” Sealord chief executive Doug Paulin told BusinessDesk.

“But the industry has moved away from that to vessels they own and are crewed with New Zealanders, as far as we’re able to attract them.”


The Breakers will be heading to Australia in early December, in an attempt to get the jump on the NBL season, reports Stuff. The roster is currently heavily loaded up, and the club sees this as the season to start winning championships again. However, they’ll have to do it (in all likelihood) permanently away from home, playing under the same conditions other NZ franchises in Australian competitions face.


That’s it for The Bulletin. If you want to support the work we do at The Spinoff, please check out our membership programme