Flowers and tributes hung on the fence of the Botanic Gardens (Photo: Carl Court/Getty Images)
Flowers and tributes hung on the fence of the Botanic Gardens (Photo: Carl Court/Getty Images)

The BulletinMarch 15, 2021

The Bulletin: Muslim community to privately mark attack anniversary

Flowers and tributes hung on the fence of the Botanic Gardens (Photo: Carl Court/Getty Images)
Flowers and tributes hung on the fence of the Botanic Gardens (Photo: Carl Court/Getty Images)

Good morning and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: It’s two years on from the Christchurch mosque attack, the spotlight is on commercial radio after sexual harassment claims, and Aucklanders have enjoyed their first weekend back at alert level one.

Today marks the two year anniversary of “one of New Zealand’s darkest days”On March 15 in 2019, 51 people were killed while they worshipped in two Christchurch mosques. The terrorist, a white supremacist, injured 40 others. The perpetrator was last year sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Today, Christchurch’s Muslim community will hold private prayers. As RNZ reports, The imam of Masjid An-Nur Gamal Fouda said today’s prayers will be held at both the Linwood and Al-Noor mosques to remember those who lost their lives. “Families will remember their loved ones in different ways, many will pay their respects today by visiting the graves of those who died,” he said.

A public commemoration was held on Saturday, attended by about 1000 people. Jacinda Ardern was among the long list of speakers. She told the crowd: “Much has been said, but words, despite their healing power, will never change what happened that day. Words will not bring back those men, women and children who gathered at their place of worship, quietly and peacefully when they were taken in an act of terror.”

To mark today’s anniversary, Newshub has spoken to a number of survivors from the attack. Temel Atacocugu – who was shot nine times by the terrorist – is back playing football; one of the things he loves the most. “Because this is the most thing I loved to do in my life and I don’t think, myself, I can be without football,” he told reporter Juliet Speedy. Siham Alsalfiti, whose husband Abdul Qasem was killed on March 15 while protecting his injured friends, found this weekend’s anniversary service healing. “I found it very helpful, it made me feel that we are not alone and I’m really proud [that] the government keeps acknowledging the loss of 51 innocent Shahids [martyrs],” she says. Read more extraordinary stories here.

Finally, Newsroom has followed a story from last week on the continuing calls for the government to amend ACC to allow it to provide support to uninjured witnesses of the March 15 attack. It comes after a fiery interview between Andrew Little and RNZ’s Susie Ferguson, that you can listen to here. Wellington lawyer Warren Forster told Newsroom that minister Little was right to say witnesses not physically injured but suffering mental injury aren’t covered by ACC. But: “there’s a separate question of, should they?” Read more on that, here.


MediaWorks has launched an internal review following a Stuff investigation into alleged sexual harassment at The Rock. Responding to questions from Alison Mau – who helms Stuff’s #MeTooNZ project – a MediaWorks spokesperson said the company would hire an independent investigator to conduct “a thorough review of historic events and our current workplace culture and practices”.

One worker told Stuff the employee at the centre of the allegations had made sexualised comments to her on numerous occasions. She said she remained “terrified” of potential repercussions from speaking out, calling The Rock station “a tornado of toxic masculinity”. Another employee claimed the worker’s alleged behaviour was well known.

The allegations stem from anonymous comments posted on an Instagram account dedicated to exposing alleged incidents of this nature. The post included “four different accounts of the same radio station and its [employee]”. One of those alleged employee “XXXX” had been “forever creeping people out”. Another accuses the man of saying “some really sexually aggressive things to me” and that she “would not be comfortable being alone with him”.

And, if you’re interested to learn more about Alison Mau’s history reporting on sexual harassment in New Zealand – I recommend listening to The Fold. Last month, The Spinoff’s Duncan Greive chatted to Mau following her investigation into harassment claims within the local music industry.


Auckland spent its first weekend back at alert level one with no new community cases of Covid-19. As the Herald reported, yesterday saw one new case in managed isolation. That person flew to New Zealand from the United Arab Emirates and tested positive on day three of their stay. There are currently 87 active cases – but none are in the community.

Yesterday also marked one month since the emergence of what would become the February community cluster. The cluster saw 15 people contract Covid-19 and forced Auckland into a third and fourth lockdown.

The super city shifted out of level two restrictions once again at midday on Friday. As explained in our live updates, Jacinda Ardern was forced to defend the choice to announce the alert level change on Friday, having made the decision the night before. “Every day when we stand up and say we have no new cases, someone will make an assumption about whether or not we’re going to be in a position to move. There has to be a point where we make the official announcement,” she said.

The prime minister also faced questions about a tweet by her fiancé Clarke Gayford in which he appeared to have advance knowledge of the alert decision. Asked if she could categorically rule out that Gayford had accessed any privileged information, Ardern said: “Of course. I have not seen my partner since [Thursday]. He absolutely has not. I really reject the implication. I think what he has taken off his own bat to rebut is the suggestion that we’ve had a decision that we’ve sat on. That is information we were sharing since yesterday, the process we were following.”


The Dental Association is continuing its push for a sugar tax, saying they work overseas. As reported by RNZ, a new report published in the British Medical Journal found the UK’s tax on sugary drinks resulted in a 10% decrease in peoples’ sugar consumption. “Sugary drinks are the number one source of sugar in New Zealand, and this is the reason why New Zealand Dental Association is calling on the government taking measures to reduce sugary drink consumption,” association spokesperson Rob Beaglehole said.

The problem, however, is that the current government has ruled out introducing any new taxes – including one on sugary drinks. Beaglehole said they should reconsider: “We know that at least 8000 children have a general anaesthetic to have their teeth taken out,” he said. If a tax remained out of the question, the government should focus on marketing and sponsorship advertising restrictions on junk food. “What we’re really calling on is the government to show leadership, and instigate a water-only policy in all schools,” he added.


An uncredited lab is providing Covid-19 saliva testing to Ryman Healthcare. According to BusinessDesk’s Patrick Smellie, the Hamilton-based Hill Laboratories has been accredited to provide “overflow nasal swab testing” for the Manukau DHB since last year – but has recently begun providing voluntary saliva tests to rest home staff in Auckland. BusinessDesk reports that Hill Laboratories will need to get accreditation to conduct saliva testing if it hopes to win government contracts that are set to be offered imminently.


Got some feedback about The Bulletin, or anything in the news? Drop us a line at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz.

Subscribe now to The Bulletin


Ants paintings by AI artist Dribnet (Tom White) (Photo: supplied)

Right now on The Spinoff: Mirjam Guesgen looks at a Wellington art exhibition created entirely from artificial intelligence. Kathy Errington of the Helen Clark Foundation explains what a system of cannabis decriminalisation could look like in New Zealand. Louise Fisher explains the history of “Disappointment Island”. Tara Ward spent an afternoon in the virtual company of Rod Stewart as he “rocked the dock”. And, a lovely comic by Liliana Manetto Quick looks at Wellington’s iconic Midnight Espresso café.


For a feature today, an opinion piece by Gareth Vaughan of Interest.co.nz. He looks at how the National Party and the traditionally Labour-aligned E tū union have recently been in agreement against the government.

Here’s an excerpt:

This unusual event occurred when National called on the government to cover 100% of a worker’s wages or salary when they’re forced to self-isolate.

“The ‘stay home, save lives’ mantra sounds simple enough, but it’s not always that easy for people who can’t afford to not be working,” National leader Judith Collins said.

“The current Leave Support Scheme pays full-time workers $1176.60 and part-time workers $700 as a lump sum for a two-week period, with the money going to their employers. This is well below the minimum wage and below what a full-time worker would earn from sick leave,” added Collins. “We must make it easier for people to stay home when required.”

The E tū union, formed in 2015 through the merger of the Engineering, Printing and Manufacturing Union, the Service and Food Workers Union and the Flight Attendants and Related Services Union, agreed.

“E tū assistant national secretary Annie Newman says workers need to feel confident that they will not be penalised financially should they need to stay home to keep themselves and others safe from the virus,” E tū said in a statement.

“Other organisations are joining the call for 100%, even including the National Party, who are now calling for the government to directly pay workers 100% of their wages when they have to self-isolate,” the union added.

In the midst of a global pandemic and with normal enemies National and a trade union agreeing, you could certainly argue they had a reasonable point.

But Covid-19 Response Minister Chris Hipkins was having none of it.


In sport: It’s been a big weekend for Emirates Team New Zealand – but no racing could take place yesterday evening on the Waitematā Harbour. According to the Herald, cup officials made the decision to postpone racing to tonight as a result of low winds. For racing to take place, the wind must reach an average threshold of 6.5 knots. Low winds in Auckland? Astonishing.

On Saturday, the racing continued to be evenly fought. Both teams won a race, keeping the overall competition levelled at 3-3 in the best of 13 tournament. It’s possible that Team New Zealand was bolstered to that single Saturday evening victory due to the, err, rousing performance of Rod Stewart. It’s also possible that’s why we lost race five – who’s to know. Read more about Sir Rod’s performance from The Spinoff’s Tara Ward.


That’s it for The Bulletin. You’ll be back in the warm and comforting embrace of Alex tomorrow – thanks for letting me fill in. If you want to support the work we do at The Spinoff, please consider becoming a Member.

Keep going!
(Photo: Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)
(Photo: Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)

The BulletinMarch 12, 2021

The Bulletin: Jacinda Ardern already knows if Auckland’s moving to level one

(Photo: Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)
(Photo: Hagen Hopkins/Getty Images)

Good morning and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: Aucklanders are waiting to learn if the city will shift to alert level one, Ashley Bloomfield has apologised for taking free cricket tickets, and high-risk pregnant women from Queenstown are being rejected from hospitals.

The question on all Aucklanders’ minds today: will the city move back down to alert level one in time for the weekend? Cabinet met yesterday to make its decision, with prime minister Jacinda Ardern set to make the announcement at 11.30 this morning in Auckland.

As I said in yesterday’s live updates, it feels a bit weird that the announcement was delayed overnight. I expect there is some kind of contingency plan in place in case Covid comes back this morning, but why not just make the announcement on the same day of the decision? Just asking questions…

I’m not the only one to have that thought. Auckland Business Chamber chief executive Michael Barnett said the government should have announced its decision last night. “Every day counts and the sooner we know the plan, the sooner we can get back to business,” he said in a statement.

Judith Collins isn’t happy about it either. The National Party leader tweeted to say it’s just not good enough. “We are not allowed to know what the decision is… to fit into the PM’s scheduled press conference,” Collins wrote. “Kiwis deserve more respect,” she later said.


You’d have to think there’s a pretty good chance of Auckland moving down alerts, even as soon as tonight. As reported in the Herald, the last community case of Covid-19 was February 28. A week ago, Jacinda Ardern said: “Cabinet will review this decision [alert level] at the end of next week… with a view to moving Auckland to level one at the start of the weekend, if we are in a position to do so.”


Researchers are calling on the Ministry of Health to speed up the delivery of Covid-19 vaccines to at-risk workers. A report on Scimex by Chris Walls, Siobhan Gavaghan, Des Gorman and David McBride expresses concern that a lot of those on the frontline of our Covid-19 response won’t be vaccinated until the second quarter of the year.

In the report, the authors argue for “an accelerated vaccination schedule” for exposed workers in managed isolation and quarantine facilities. They say that, without a faster vaccination roll-out for these workers, employers are unable to fulfil their obligations under the Health and Safety at Work Act to take “reasonable steps” to ensure the safety of employees.

Earlier this week, the government revealed the full extent of its vaccine roll-out. There’s a handy explainer about it on The Spinoff, ICYMI. According to the government, vaccination of MIQ workers started in February and is ongoing; the “vast bulk” are expected to have had at least the first dose by the end of this month.


An official remembrance service for victims of the March 15 terror attacks will take place in Christchurch tomorrow. Ahead of the that, ministers Andrew Little and Priyanca Radhakrishnan have released the first details from a series of 33 hui with Muslim, pan-ethnic and multi-faith communities across New Zealand.

One significant finding from the hui is that communities remain concerned over the Royal Commission’s finding that no individual or specific government agency was at fault for the terrorist attack. Some questioned how effective change could occur if the leadership of agencies remained the same. There was also backing for legislative change to stop hate speech, something that the government is exploring.

In another development, the government has revealed a $1 million fund that will help support the government’s response to the Royal Commission. That money will be available over three years and will prioritise funding for groups most directly affected by the attack. The fund can be used to support individual initiatives, as well as building long-term capability within communities, said Andrew Little.


Ashley Bloomfield has apologised after taking free tickets to watch the Black Caps play over the weekend. As Newshub reported, the director general of health said he believed he had accepted the tickets in a personal capacity – but later realised he is in his job all the time. “I recognise that the invitation was extended to me because I am in that position,” he said in a statement.

The prime minister was quick to defend Bloomfield. Jacinda Ardern told reporters: “I don’t think anyone in New Zealand would want to deny Dr Bloomfield the chance to watch some cricket.” Bloomfield, being the man he is, donated the cost of the tickets to the City Mission.


The Māori Party is calling for a Royal Commission of Inquiry into racial profiling by police. As RNZ reported, this comes off the back of one its own investigations that found some innocent Māori youth – some as young as 14 – were stopped by police in order to be photographed.

Rawiri Waititi, the party’s co-leader, said action is needed. “Our people do not stand a chance against the might of the Crown when they are being intentionally targeted just because they are brown and they definitely don’t stand a chance when the ministry continues to turn a blind eye to systemic racism that is happening right under their nose,” he said.


Staffing shortages at Invercargill and Dunedin hospitals mean high-risk pregnant women from Queenstown are being turned away, reports Isobel Ewing of Crux. According to the report, women often need to transfer from Queenstown due to a lack of adequate services to deal with obstetric and pregnancy emergencies in the Southern Lakes region.

It’s leaving midwives terrified that a tragedy is imminent. Queenstown midwife Keri Mapperson said that by January 3 there had been at least five instances where a midwife in the region had a patient turned away. She complained to the Southern DHB at the time – but doesn’t believe that complaint has been addressed.

Just two weeks ago, it happened again. “I had someone in premature labour who didn’t even plan to birth in this area, she planned to birth in Invercargill,” Mapperson told Crux. “She needed urgent obstetric care outside of what we have [in Queenstown]. “When I called Invercargill they said, ‘we don’t have enough staff to accept you’.”


Have you ever wanted to work for The Spinoff? We’ve got an awesome job up for grabs working across The Spinoff’s social media, as well as helping out with our new agency Daylight Creative. Applications close today.


In news from across the ditch: Australia’s home affairs minister is copping flack for saying Australia was “taking out the trash” by deporting New Zealand citizens. Peter Dutton made the comments on a 9 News report, where a reporter also hounded a deportee as she was boarding a flight to New Zealand.

Dutton’s comments have been met with angry responses from our own MPs. As the Herald reported, foreign affairs Minister Nanaia Mahuta said Dutton’s comments “only serve to trash his own reputation”. While Jacinda Ardern wouldn’t be drawn on the word “trash”, she repeated her view that Australia’s policy of deportation is something she strongly disagrees with.

While also condemning Dutton’s comment, Covid-19 response minister Chris Hipkins found himself briefly embroiled in his own scandal. He told reporters: “this is Australia exporting its garbage to New Zealand”. However, he later admitted he misspoke when he used the word garbage. “I didn’t mean to suggest that, that is Dutton’s way of describing it,” he said.


Got some feedback about The Bulletin, or anything in the news? Drop us a line at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz

Subscribe now to The Bulletin

A house on a blue background with lightning bolts
(Image / Tina Tiller)

Right now on The Spinoff: I write about my experience of pushing back against picky property managers. Justin Latif ranks the teams of the NRL (and reveals some scandal). There’s a new episode of Business is Boring, talking to Bex Rempel of ZeroJet. Guest writer Erica Wilkinson from DoC writes about sea lions. And Justin Latif talks to South Auckland community leaders about the vaccine roll-out plan.


In sport: it’s all about the America’s Cup. As Michael Burgess explains (paywalled) for the NZ Herald, getting “first blood” off the start will continue to be the vital factor in today’s races.

Under alert level two restrictions, racing is isolated to courses A and E in order to discourage large gatherings on the shore. That means the allocation of port entry for the pre-start is vital; the boat that enters on port only needs to do one gybe and then head back, with a timed run to the line.

Races three and four between Team New Zealand and Luna Rossa kick off today at 4.15pm. Fingers crossed we’ll be back to alert level one not long after that.