spinofflive
Phil Goff and Phil Twyford. Photo: Don Rowe
Phil Goff and Phil Twyford. Photo: Don Rowe

The BulletinApril 27, 2018

The Bulletin: Will this finally fix Auckland’s transport woes?

Phil Goff and Phil Twyford. Photo: Don Rowe
Phil Goff and Phil Twyford. Photo: Don Rowe

Good morning, and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: A huge sack of cash for Auckland’s transport, a damning new child poverty report, and jailhouse snitches in the spotlight.

The government and council will put $28 billion dollars towards a major plan to fix Auckland’s transport woes. Here’s a handy key facts story from Stuff, because there is rather a lot of detail. But the major top line of it is that massive investments will be made in public transport infrastructure, major new roads will be partly paid for by tolls, and the package will take a decade or more to complete.

So what are people saying about it? The NZ Herald‘s Simon Wilson is very keen on the package, saying it shows the government is thinking about transport networks, rather than simply routes or roads. It’s joined up thinking, Wilson says. He also notes the impact policy group Greater Auckland have had – they have also produced a review of the details of the plans. And Stuff‘s Henry Cooke says this is politically a huge win for Phil Twyford, who has ministerial portfolios that basically boil down to fixing Auckland’s greatest problems – transport and housing.

Now if that’s all you read about the transport plans, you’d get the impression everyone loves them. Not so. The NZ Herald reports National says motorists in the Rodney area will get hit with a triple-whammy if they use the Penlink toll road, when combined with a general fuel tax rise and the specific Auckland levy. Gordon Campbell is concerned about the use of a public-private partnership to build those roads, saying such projects have historically been marked by cost blowouts and risks for the government. And Radio NZ has talked to commuters in South Auckland, some of whom say the plans are too little, too late.


A report has confirmed what many will anecdotally already know about poverty in New Zealand – children living in poverty are more than three times more likely to die before adulthood than those living in affluent areas. Newshub reports on the findings of the Child and Youth Mortality Review Committee, which make for grim reading: overcrowded and damp housing, preventable illnesses, and suicide are all listed as causes of the higher death rate.

Government changes to welfare are likely to be formally announced in the next month, reports Radio NZ. The government is yet to reveal just how wide ranging the changes will be.


Name suppression has been lifted on a jailhouse informant, who lied during the murder trial of David Tamihere. The NZ Herald reports Roberto Conchie Harris, himself a murderer, was convicted of perjury for his testimony in the 1990 Tamihere murder trial.

Tamihere, who maintains he did not commit the murders of two Swedish tourists that he spent 20 years behind bars for, spoke to Newstalk ZB after Harris was named, saying it shows the danger of using jailhouse snitches in prosecutions. And on the front page of the NZ Herald today, Andrew Little says there have no been a number of cases, in which jailhouse evidence has been proven to be false, and its time to review their use.


The government is considering suing Fletcher over botched Christchurch earthquake repairs that now need remedial work, reports Newshub. But Fletchers vehemently denies they are the liable party, in either a legal or moral sense. And meanwhile, job cuts loom for the embattled construction company, reports the NZ Herald, relating to extraordinarily heavy losses in the Building and Interiors unit, which suffered severe cost blowouts on projects like the Christchurch Justice Precinct


Vector has suffered a serious data breach through its app, reports Stuff. Names, email addresses, locations and phone numbers of as many as 35,000 customers were accessed by a member of the public through a proxy server, who then tipped off media. Vector disabled the app, and have taken steps recommended by the privacy commissioner to protect customer data.


This is yet another remarkable interactive long-form piece by Stuff‘s Charlie Mitchell, this time he’s covered the dramatic loss of ice on one of New Zealand’s iconic glaciers. Mitchell covers both the ecological and economic effects that will hit the Franz Jozef Glacier when (not if) the ice melts completely. And the story notes that the heavy volume of tourism is having an effect on the retreat of the glacier too.


And here’s a big investigative long-read to dive into over the weekend: Newsroom‘s David Williams reports an oyster-killing parasite, that has seriously affected the aquaculture industry, came out of the largest privately owned science organisation in the country. And moreover, there was a lot the public weren’t told for years. Here’s a teaser paragraph:

“So why was there two years of silence? MPI’s hush-hush approach to the 2015 discovery might be seen as prudent – a Government that didn’t want to unnecessarily spook offshore markets and protect the reputation of one of the country’s top research facilities. But a cynic’s view is it’s a sign of an uncomfortable intimacy between regulator and industry; that the ministry was too close to the industry it was funding and promoting.”


Sign up to The Bulletin





Right now on The Spinoff: Toby Morris has a new Side Eye, this time interviewing a supermarket worker stuck on minimum wage, and how it affects her life. Highly acclaimed TV show The Handmaid’s Tale is back, and Alex Casey has had a watch of it. And Madeleine Chapman investigates the long running war between the two Mt Albert BBQ Noodle House restaurants, which are next door to each other.


And now, a guest post from The Spinoff’s Jihee Junn, who has been in China recently. 

In the last two or three decades, China has undergone the most rapid of transformations, going from being a largely rural, agrarian-based society to a global manufacturing powerhouse. In fact, the China of today prides itself for not only catching up to the rest of the world, but for actually inching ahead the rest of the pack when it comes to industries like tech and innovation. This Wired longread, for example, shows how China – which has long been accused as being chief peddlers of the copycat economy – has gone from being imitators to innovators; from ‘Made in China’ to ‘Designed in China’ as well.

No discussion about China would be complete without mentioning its favourite frenemy: the United States of America. For a long time, the US stood as the world’s lone superpower, but its grip on the world’s political and economic affairs has loosened over the years. The Economist’s March cover story looks at how the two nations now jostle for digital supremacy as America’s technological hegemony comes under serious threat.

Another way this rivalry has materialised is in the realm of healthcare. A New York Times article from earlier this year explains that as companies like Amazon seek to disrupt the healthcare system, it’s important to note that Chinese companies like Alibaba and Tencent already have. So far, it’s tested online medical advice and drug tracking systems, and it’s now looking to a more advanced tool to reach its goals: artificial intelligence.

Lastly, as we’ve learned with Facebook and Google, there’s always a flip side when it comes technological advancement. That’s because while things like facial recognition and voice command have made the everyday lives of Chinese citizens more efficient and convenient, it’s also enabled the Chinese government to evolve into one of the most complex surveillance states in the world. Most notably, as The Atlantic explains, it’s new ‘social credit’ scheme wants to use data collected by modern-day technology to help it examine both a citizen’s online and offline existence and assign with something called a ‘sincerity’ score. Yikes.


The problems the Silver Ferns are currently dealing with could be the tip of the iceberg for netball in New Zealand, if this outstanding column on Newsroom by Taylah Hodson–Tomokino is anything to go by. Once upon a time girls would have no option but to play netball, ensuring a steady production line of talent. But all of that is changing. Girls have plenty of sporting options now, many of which are a better pathway to being a professional athlete.

And Black Sticks star Pippa Hayward has retired from hockey, fresh from winning Commonwealth Games gold, reports Stuff. She says she’s going to focus on finishing her studies in law and arts. Hayward played 158 tests for New Zealand, and coach Mark Hagar says she’ll be missed.


And from our partners, Vector’s Karl Check analyses Australia’s progress when it comes to shifting away from coal and gas fired power plants and onto renewable energy sources.


That’s it for the The Bulletin. If you liked what you read, and know other people who would find it useful, please forward it on and encourage them to sign up here. Thanks for joining us this morning, have a great weekend, and if you’ve made it this far, congratulations on finishing what I’m pretty sure is the longest Bulletin ever.


The Bulletin is brought to you by Vector. If you live in Auckland, they also delivered the power you’re using to read it. And they’re creating a new energy future for all of us, as showcased by the incredible Vector Lights.

Keep going!
Shane Jones (Photo: RNZ)
Shane Jones (Photo: RNZ)

The BulletinApril 26, 2018

The Bulletin: Shane Jones hungry for more ministerial power

Shane Jones (Photo: RNZ)
Shane Jones (Photo: RNZ)

Good morning, and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: Shane Jones wants more power over public servants, NZ banks insist they’re not dodgy, and a former Counties DHB member hits back.

Shane Jones wants ministers to have more control over the public sectorincluding being able to appoint enforcers in top roles, reports Stuff. The regional development minister says public servants needlessly slow down the funding process for projects, and described the system as “treacle ridden.” Jones said it wasn’t government policy, but he intended to campaign on it in future.

This is the same Shane Jones who recently ignored (or forgot about receiving) advice from his officials, that a West Coast waste project he granted $350,000 was a dud – here’s a Radio NZ recap on that blunder which took place less than a month ago. And the Taxpayers Union’s Jordan Williams hit out at Jones’ proposals, saying they would replace a Westminster model of public service neutrality with an American model of cronyism.

The issue of public service neutrality was recently battled out during the Clare Curran/Radio NZ saga, and the union for public servants would likely oppose any moves to increase ministerial power over staffing. In the wake of that story, the PSA’s Glenn Barclay wrote for The Spinoff, saying for public servants maintaining neutrality is a way of maintaining integrity.


Banks in New Zealand have gone on the record saying they can be trusted, amid continuing fallout from the Royal Commission in Australia. Stuff asked our major banks with parent companies in Australia why consumers aren’t facing the same dodgy practices taking place over the ditch. The two markets are repeatedly described as different, but the answers are useful nonetheless, if for no other reason than offering a definitive measuring stick if they’re found to be less than fully truthful.


A former Counties Manukau DHB member is hitting back at claims the board wasn’t up to the job, reports Stuff. That DHB has been under fire recently over serious infrastructure issues at Middlemore Hospital, but Mark Darrow, who was pushed out by minister David Clark, says the board weren’t the ones who dropped the ball.

“Any suggestion that this board didn’t do its job or alert the appropriate authorities is just absolute rubbish. The real question is why the ministry or the Capital Investment Committee did not advise the Minister on the issues that were raised with them in detail on multiple occasions. The briefings and meeting minutes from the DHB are all on file.”


Reading recovery programmes may not actually work, according to a new report covered in today’s NZ Herald. Perhaps unsurprisingly, reading recovery success rates improve the higher the school’s decile, and similar programmes were recently scrapped by New South Wales for being ineffective.


Christchurch is likely to end up with permanently chlorinated water, according to an expert interviewed by Stuff. The issue, in the view of Iain Rabbitts, is unmonitored bores that could pollute the wider water supply. But mayor Lianne Dalziel is dead against permanent chlorination, and that daily monitoring is taking place to prove the water supply was safe.


Local stuntman and instagram star Johnny ‘Danger’ Bennett has died in a motorbike crash. His instagram profile is filling up rapidly with comments from fans mourning his death, and he is being described by friends as being caring and full of life.


Sign up to The Bulletin





Right now on The Spinoff: Guest writer Greer Berry shares what it’s like to be married to someone in the Defence Force. Alex Casey has a deep-dive investigation into whether Bachelor stars Matilda Rice and Art Green now own Jamie Ridge’s former cats. And I went down to the Auckland Domain yesterday for two very different ANZAC Day ceremonies – here‘s my report.


The scientific paper, in both a literal and figurative form, is no longer fit for purpose. At least, that’s the rather intriguing argument made in this long read from The Atlantic. Because of the way the internet has changed and sped up the dissemination of knowledge, having everything written down on a literal piece of paper (or PDF) doesn’t really make sense any more. Here’s a paragraph that sums up the argument:

“This is, of course, the whole problem of scientific communication in a nutshell: Scientific results today are as often as not found with the help of computers. That’s because the ideas are complex, dynamic, hard to grab ahold of in your mind’s eye. And yet by far the most popular tool we have for communicating these results is the PDF—literally a simulation of a piece of paper. Maybe we can do better.”

If any scientists are reading this, what are your thoughts on it? I was studying pretty recently and am keen to know if this view is widespread. Email me – thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz.


In sport, everyone off the bandwagon, the Warriors are terrible again. At least, they were last night, losing 50-10 to an admittedly very good Melbourne Storm team. The NZ Herald has a rundown of where it all went wrong, in particular a softness on defence that hasn’t really been seen all season from the Warriors.

And in Auckland stadium news, there’s serious doubt over plans to turn Western Springs into a multi-use oval, after mayor Phil Goff indicated funding the stadium was not a priority. Newstalk ZB reports that Regional Facilities Auckland wants another $27 million from council over 10 years for the project, but are unlikely to get it because of the cash crunch being faced by the city overall.


And from our partners, Vector’s Karl Check analyses Australia’s progress when it comes to shifting away from coal and gas fired power plants and onto renewal energy sources.


That’s it for the The Bulletin. If you liked what you read, and know other people who would find it useful, please forward it on and encourage them to sign up here. Thanks for joining us this morning.


The Bulletin is brought to you by Vector. If you live in Auckland, they also delivered the power you’re using to read it. And they’re creating a new energy future for all of us, as showcased by the incredible Vector Lights.