Aimee Fisher (left) and Lisa Carrington (Photos by David Balogh and Thomas Lohnes/Getty Images)
Aimee Fisher (left) and Lisa Carrington (Photos by David Balogh and Thomas Lohnes/Getty Images)

SportsAugust 6, 2024

Get ready for the powerhouse Olympics rivalry between two NZ canoe racers

Aimee Fisher (left) and Lisa Carrington (Photos by David Balogh and Thomas Lohnes/Getty Images)
Aimee Fisher (left) and Lisa Carrington (Photos by David Balogh and Thomas Lohnes/Getty Images)

New Zealand has the opportunity to win gold and silver in the same event. 

 A “clash of the titans” is how canoe racing world champion Aimee Fisher recently described her upcoming K1-500 Olympic race against teammate Dame Lisa Carrington. On the water, it will make for quite the spectacle – the duo has gone head to head a lot in the last few years. Fisher pipped former boatmate Carrington in a photo finish to take the title at the World Cup in May but it was Carrington that was on top last year when she claimed the only New Zealand spot at the World Championships. 

Unless you’ve been hiding under a rock, Dame Lisa Carrington is the “face” of canoe racing in Aotearoa. The 35-year-old is New Zealand’s most decorated Olympian with six medals, including five gold. She is currently the second fastest woman in the K1-500 behind 29-year-old Fisher.

Fisher, originally from Hawke’s Bay, first burst onto the international scene in 2013 at the Australian Youth Olympic Festival, where she secured a gold medal in the K2-200 and a silver in the K2-500. She was in the K4-500 boat at the 2016 Rio Olympics, where the team finished fifth, but stepped away from the high performance environment, missing the Tokyo Olympics.

While Carrington might be the “face”, Fisher is the poster athlete for “racing your own race”.

The backstory

Fisher was among a group of women who stepped away from the high-performance canoe racing squad in 2019 and 2020, after welfare concerns were raised. Allegations of bullying, intimidation, and psychological abuse were made public, with some athletes alleging they were left broken, burnt out and dealing with serious mental health issues. 

Canoe Racing NZ (CRNZ) and High Performance Sport NZ (HPSNZ) were criticised for their focus on medals over athlete welfare. When the allegations were made public in 2020, CRNZ strenuously denied a culture of bullying or harassment. Other athletes within the setup said they were well-supported and did not experience what was being alleged.

However, a secret report finally released in 2022, showed High Performance Sport psychologists had serious concerns about the environment. 

Throughout this process it was reported Fisher went through meetings with senior management and mediation with a coach. Ultimately she found support back at her club, the North Shore Canoe Club, under the tutelage of three-time CRNZ coach of the year Gavin Elmiger, who is coaching Samoa at the Paris Olympics. He is known for his “person first” approach where elite athletes train side by side with grassroots paddlers.

The preparation

Centralised programmes are commonplace in the high performance sport world. The likes of rowing and cycling are based in Cambridge, then there’s the HPSNZ headquarters on Auckland’s North Shore. You’ll find swimmers and track and field athletes, among others, there.  

These programmes bring athletes, coaches and support staff together – including physios, doctors and psychologists – along with access to necessary facilities, but, as highlighted in the independent review following the death of Olympic cyclist Olivia Podmore, centralised programmes can have a negative impact on the wellbeing of athletes. It can isolate them from family and support networks.

‘Media is under threat. Help save The Spinoff with an ongoing commitment to support our work.’
Duncan Greive
— Founder

In 2018, a $2.3m high performance canoe racing training centre was opened at Lake Karapiro, near Cambridge, built off the back of Carrington’s success, to help push canoe racing forward. However, she didn’t want to relocate, so the women stayed in a centralised programme in Auckland, with coach Gordon Walker.

But what might work for some, doesn’t work for everyone and that set up did not work for Fisher, or for the five others who stepped away from the programme in 2019/20.

After she left the set-up, it’s understood she established her own training regime and spent time with Elmiger, while also mentoring young club paddlers. In the build up to the games, Fisher has been paddling her own race and since the World Cup in Hungary in May she’s spent time at training camps in Europe, including time in Italy “fine tuning” before the games. 

Is it possible to succeed outside the High Performance Sport NZ set up? Fisher’s already proved she can pip Carrington at the post under the guidance of a different coach, but it’s all about peaking at the right time.

The expectations

Could Aotearoa be in for a gold-silver double in the  K1-500? Heck yea! Carrington already has a bronze from Rio 2016 and gold in Tokyo 2020 for this event, and has topped the podium four times at the World Championships in K1-500. She’s strong and dominant. But Fisher won gold at the 2021 World Champs – following a tough year for her – and currently holds the world record for the fastest time in the discipline. She set a world’s best time of 1:46.19 at the World Champs in May.

The pair will also go head to head in the K2-500, while Carrington will also race in the K4-500.

The rivalry

So is there actually a rivalry? Great question! Carrington follows Fisher on social media, so that’s a  good start and the duo are often photographed hugging post-race. Make of that what you will.

Following her World Cup victory, Fisher had nothing but praise for Carrington, who she beat by just half a second. “What an epic contest… how exciting for the Olympics,” she said.

“On the day, who knows which way it’s going to go … it’s going to be damn good!” 

How to witness it

Racing starts tonight (Tuesday August 6) from 8pm NZ time, with Carrington up first in the K4-500 heats with teammates Alicia Hoskin, Tara Vaughan and Olivia Brett. Later in the evening Carrington and Hoskin pair up for the K2-500, and we’ll get our first chance to see Fisher in action with Lucy Matehaere in the same event.

The “battle of the titans” in the K1-500 starts on Wednesday night. Fisher is up first in heat one, while Carrington is in heat five. Both will be expected to advance for a final showdown.

Keep going!
Imane Khelif punches Angela Carini at the Olympics (Photo by Richard Pelham/Getty Images)
Imane Khelif punches Angela Carini at the Olympics (Photo by Richard Pelham/Getty Images)

OPINIONMediaAugust 3, 2024

The Weekend: There’s nothing fair about the Olympics

Imane Khelif punches Angela Carini at the Olympics (Photo by Richard Pelham/Getty Images)
Imane Khelif punches Angela Carini at the Olympics (Photo by Richard Pelham/Getty Images)

So why do we keep trying to disqualify the best athletes?

Every four years I get hooked on the Olympics – I research the careers of weightlifters and long jumpers and cry every time an athlete cries on the podium and become more patriotic than I ever thought possible.

And every four years I wait with bated breath for the sore losers to emerge. For over a decade, champion 800m runner Caster Semenya had her gender, legitimacy and very existence questioned. In oversimplified terms, Semenya was assigned female at birth but has elevated testosterone in the male range. As a result, shortly after reaching the top of her event, Semenya was made to take a form of contraceptive that would lower her testosterone levels to an “acceptable” level.

At the time, it was said by an IAAF (athletics governing body) that Semenya’s testosterone levels “makes the competition unequal in a way greater than simple natural talent and dedication”. I’m sorry but if you think the Olympics is a showcase for “natural talent and dedication” then you have unfortunately vacated your senses. After years of scrutiny, abuse and changing international rules, one of the fastest women to ever run retired from track and field having barely been able to run as herself. So much for a celebration of the world’s greatest athletes.

Just this week, with no Semenya at the Games, the issue of supposedly unfair advantage sparked up again. Algeria’s Imane Khelif, who has been competing in top-level boxing tournaments for years, comprehensively beat Italy’s Angela Carini in her opening fight. So far so sane. Khelif is good, and watching the (very short) fight shows that, much like many opening events that pair favourites with low-ranked contenders, the results can be pretty devastating.

Within the first minute, Khelif hit Carini with a straight left to the face. Carini stepped back, retreated to her corner and abandoned the fight. For what it’s worth, I think if you choose to be a boxer, it should not come as a shock when someone punches you hard.

Cue: mania. Social media erupted with calls for Khelif to be disqualified, with the number one poster of inane rubbish (JK Rowling) calling her a man despite Khelif being a cisgendered woman. Why? Because Khelif was controversially disqualified from last year’s world champs by the International Boxing Association. The reason for the disqualification was shrouded in secrecy, and there was no proof of failed standards. Since then, the IOC has decertified IBA and taken over the running of the boxing tournament at the Olympics. It released a statement condemning the abuse thrown at Khelif and reiterating her eligibility to compete.

But no one is really that concerned about fairness. These instances always boil down to the types of female athletes that people will accept success from. Semenya is masculine and powerful. Khelif looked intimidating standing next to the much slighter Carini. And when people who look dominant turn out to be dominant? That’s unfair.

The Olympics is supposed to be an event that lets us witness the greatest physical beings in the world show what human bodies are capable of. And yet when we don’t like the look of some of them (and it’s only ever powerful women) suddenly the parameters for physicality start tightening.

At the same time all of this toxic sludge was spilling out over the internet, I saw a very funny photo of Japan’s Yuki Togashi (1.67m) trying to guard France’s Victor Wembanyama (2.24m) in a basketball game. The photo went viral, with universal good humour, despite Wembenyama’s 80cm height advantage making the match-up “unequal in a way greater than simple natural talent and dedication”.

I have also been enjoying the rowing, equestrian and sailing, but if we wanted to make sure every athlete got a fair shot, perhaps we should put up the family net worth of every athlete as well as the government investment in their sport. Access to training facilities, coaches, expensive equipment and opportunities will account for more than “dedication” in winning Olympic medals.

This is all to say there is nothing fair about the Olympics. We aren’t even watching the best athletes in the world because most will never have the opportunity to dedicate their lives to sport and will have more pressing things to be worrying about. Instead we are simply watching very impressive people – most of whom had the good fortune to be born in the right country and into the right socio-economic environment – doing very impressive things. So why are we constantly trying to disqualify the best of them?

This week’s episode of Behind the Story

This week I’m talking to Spinoff regular contributor Hera Lindsay Bird. Hera has been writing the extremely popular Help Me Hera advice column for over a year now, offering incisive, funny and wise guidance to New Zealand’s biggest and smallest problems. And soon, you’ll be able to hear her talk about that advice at some Spinoff live events. 

I wanted to speak to Hera this week as she’s also an Olympics obsessive and has written about the games, specifically which events should be culled and which should be added. It’s surprisingly reasoned and justified for such a hot take. 

So what have readers spent the most time reading this week?

Comments of the week

“Hera – I think it’s time that some of the gymnastic events reflect the equine-based history of the Olympics. Pommel horse should go back to being on an actual horse. much more interesting than actual equestrian events. what a challenge!”

— feijoafiesta

“So glad this topic came up!! I have tried to have such conversations often, with friends and acquaintance  of similar age (I’m a young boomer). Usually I get a blank look before they carry on talking as though I hadn’t said anything. The latest time I did this, the friend just said they’d prefer to travel than worry about the climate. Would we all! But I agree that while individual actions won’t fix things, influencing more individuals to do actions can.

PS I don’t try too hard with the young ones, because I truly believe travel is great learning and I think some travel in one’s lifetime is acceptable.”

Pick up where this leaves off

Sign up for Madeleine’s weekly Saturday newsletter where I add more handpicked recommended reading and essentially bundle everything up to land in your inbox at 9 a.m.