spinofflive
Andrew Falloon at a National Party roading announcement several weeks ago (Radio NZ, Nate McKinnon)
Andrew Falloon at a National Party roading announcement several weeks ago (Radio NZ, Nate McKinnon)

The BulletinJuly 21, 2020

The Bulletin: The Andrew Falloon scandal: what we know so far

Andrew Falloon at a National Party roading announcement several weeks ago (Radio NZ, Nate McKinnon)
Andrew Falloon at a National Party roading announcement several weeks ago (Radio NZ, Nate McKinnon)

Good morning and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: What we know so far about the Andrew Falloon scandal, finance minister shuts purse strings on billions in spending, and Cameron Slater before the courts.

The National party has lost yet another MP to scandal, with the latest casualty being first term representative for Rangitata Andrew Falloon. Multiple outlets have reported that it is because he allegedly sent an unsolicited image of a pornographic nature to a teenage girl in her first year of university – a development first broken by the NZ HeraldRadio NZ also reported that, with the additional information that the pictures are understood to have not been of Falloon himself. Falloon will remain as an MP until the election, at which time he will retire. Stuff has reported that police investigated the matter, but concluded it did not meet the threshold for prosecution.

It is very important to note that the above version of events may not be the correct version. Over the course of the afternoon and evening, significant elements and details of the story changed, or were contested, or turned out to be wrong. One very important change to the story came from this NZ Herald report, in which it was understood that Falloon’s version of events was “that acquaintances at a party sent the offensive message.” In other words, he insisted that he did not personally send the message, but offered his resignation to Collins regardless, and she accepted it.

How did it come to light? Initially, information about the incident was sent to the office of PM Jacinda Ardern on Wednesday last week. At a press conference yesterday, she said that her chief of staff sought the permission of the complainant to send it on to the leader of the opposition Judith Collins. That then took place on Friday. Collins is then understood to have met with Falloon on Monday, at which time it was agreed that he would leave politics at the election. In the intervening time, there was no indication from the party about the news that was about to break, and Falloon continued to attend events in his capacity as Rangitata MP – and he presumably will until the election. As this biography on the Timaru Herald suggests, he was widely regarded as an effective local MP.

Very little of this information was included in the initial press releases, from Falloon and Collins respectively. Those statements focused significantly on mental health issues being faced by Falloon, with his statement also referencing significant grief at the recent suicide of a friend. “I have made a number of mistakes and I apologise to those who have been affected,” was his only reference to what subsequently came to light. “Andrew is suffering from significant mental health issues and his privacy, and that of his family, must be respected,” said Collins in her much briefer statement.

All of that is no doubt true, and mental health issues must be treated with caution and sensitivity. But there has been significant disquiet about the fact that this was the angle taken by National to introduce the issue, rather than discussion of the actual incident that forced the resignation. As Newstalk ZB political editor Barry Soper concluded in his daily column, “to muddy the mental health waters in his way is simply unacceptable.” On Newsroom, political journalist Laura Walters argued that “using one of the country’s biggest social and health issues as a tool for political management further erodes public trust in the party.”

Speaking on the AM Show this morning, Judith Collins said she was personally first notified on Saturday. She also said that Falloon confirmed to her that he had sent it, and said the party had ensured he was receiving professional mental health support. She also said that Falloon had been drinking heavily at the time the incident took place. Collins also suggested that Falloon should resign from parliament immediately.


The Spinoff would like to invite Bulletin readers to a special event with Breast Cancer Foundation NZ. 

The effects of Covid-19 are often hidden from everyday view. Writing on The Spinoff, Breast Cancer NZ ambassador Stacey Morrison spoke to Chloe Irvine about her experience with breast cancer through lockdown.

To support Breast Cancer Foundation NZ’s vital work, The Spinoff is holding a Pink Ribbon Breakfast. Hosted by Stacey Morrison at Kind cafe in Morningside, Auckland, on July 28 from 7.30am, the breakfast will hear from women about their breast cancer journeys and foundation advocates about the work they do.

Limited tickets are available here, including breakfast. If you live outside Auckland or are unable to join us for breakfast we still welcome your support for Breast Cancer Foundation NZ.


Finance minister Grant Robertson has closed the purse strings on $14 billion worth of the Covid recovery fund for the foreseeable future. Initially an envelope of $20bn had been put towards that fund, but he now says that much of it won’t be spent unless needed, to avoid having net debt blow out. More details can be found in our live blog, including the quote that sums it up – “If it’s not needed the money will not be spent. It will not be borrowed and we will have less debt to repay. This is the fiscally prudent thing to do.” He also appeared to take a dig at other parties who appeared to want to spend that money on other projects, saying the fund had been set up for very specific uses.


A fascinating case is currently underway at the High Court regarding posts made by former Whaleoil blogger Cameron Slater. The NZ Herald’s Kirsty Johnston was there to see evidence given by Slater, in which he denied attack posts against public health academics were written in exchange for cash – rather, he contends that they were simply an expression of his political beliefs. The academics in question allege that they were defamed in a series of posts, with lobbyist Carrick Graham accused of arranging payment for the posts from ex-National MP Katherine Rich through her employer the Food and Grocery Council.


Another update in a particularly odd political saga: Stuff reports that NZ First has confirmed it has signed a contract with several political operatives behind the Brexit campaign, to help the party in the upcoming general election. The story was the subject of two pieces on The Spinoff (first this, then this) which prompted an angry attack by Peters against this outlet. As always with these matters, I will leave it entirely up to the reader to determine whether the deputy PM was honest with the public about it.


We had some strong support for the proposed CovidCard last week, as a better technological solution than the government’s contact tracing app. So for balance, here’s a piece that tests the claims made by CovidCard’s backers, and whether they stack up. Writing on The Spinoff, Richard Easther argues that the “brutal truth” about both solutions is that neither will be a miracle solution. An excellent line from the piece: “Like a “self-driving car”, these may be technical innovations that can be described in a couple of words, work well in favourable environments, but are far harder to deploy in ways that are genuinely transformative.”


Seasonal migrant workers who were allegedly abused by their employer are worried that they won’t get justice, reports Newsroom’s Dileepa Fonseka. They have been moved from Hawkes Bay up to Auckland, so won’t be able to see the accused have their day in court. As well as that, there are questions about whether the government acted swiftly enough on the matter – a key audio recording was sent to immigration minister Iain Lees-Galloway almost two weeks before the story broke, but no reply came back.


NZ First leader Winston Peters has been ordered to pay court costs of $320,000 after his failed action regarding his superannuation details being leaked, reports Sam Hurley for the NZ Herald. Peters had been trying to get damages and a declaration against former cabinet ministers Paula Bennett and Anne Tolley, and two top public servants, but the case was dismissed. He has said he’ll appeal against the decision on costs, but Bennett has argued that the costs are “entirely appropriate”. Incidentally, if the payment does go ahead, it would go back to the Crown.


Got some feedback about The Bulletin, or anything in the news? Drop us a line at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz

One big happy family (Photo: Getty Images/Tina Tiller)

Right now on The Spinoff: get angry about a political consensus forming around the idea that returning NZers should pay for managed isolation. Professor Andrew Geddis writes about a case that shows how unjust the three strikes sentencing law can be. Going West’s producer James Littlewood explains why the country’s oldest literary festival is putting its massive back-catalogue online. Catherine Woulfe shares several stories that shows how complex and fraught maternal mental health is. And Linda Burgess goes on a long search for that rarest of political creatures – a middle child who becomes an MP.


For those not following the ongoing situation around protests in the US, there have been some very worrying developments. In the city of Portland especially (but likely others soon) the Federal government has started sending agents in unmarked vans out to arrest non-violent protesters. As vastly experienced security analyst Paul Buchanan writes at Kiwipolitico, such policing has some disturbing precedents. Here’s an excerpt:

For those of us who remember the Argentine “dirty war” and the role of unidentified men in unmarked Ford Falcons in the “disappearance” (desaparicion) of thousands of people, this is a chilling and sinister development. It is particularly so because unlike Argentina there are no armed guerrilla groups seriously challenging government authority in Portland or elsewhere, especially from the Left. For all the rightwing talk of Antifa being a threat, they are neither heavily armed or organised as effective guerrilla fighting units. Instead, what irregular militias exist in the US today are predominately rightwing supporters of the president and his political project who reject government authority because it is ostensibly part of the “Deep State” and who have histories of violence in support of their beliefs.

Here there is another parallel with the Argentine “dirty war.” In the years leading up and then during the early days of the dictatorship that came to be known as the “Process” (Proceso), rightwing death squads roamed the country with impunity, targeting “subversives” and other “undesirables” with murderous vigilante justice. The death squads were both a complement to and a justification for the official repression meted out by the unidentified men in Ford Falcons, whose uniforms were grey suits and black ties. After all, with murderous bands of unidentified armed men stalking the streets, the State needed to step in to restore order.


In sport, back to back titles for the country’s premier jockey. The NZ Racing Desk newswire (republished on the Stratford Press) reports the TAB is now paying out bets made on Lisa Allpress winning the National Jockeys’ premiership. There’s still a bit of the season left to run, but her lead is now unassailable. It’s the fourth time she’s won the title over a career lasting decades, and her third since the 2015/16 season.


That’s it for The Bulletin. If you want to support the work we do at The Spinoff, please check out our membership programme

Keep going!
A hotel staff worker sanitises the outside of Auckland’s Stamford Plaza on July 10, 2020 (Photo: Hannah Peters/Getty Images)
A hotel staff worker sanitises the outside of Auckland’s Stamford Plaza on July 10, 2020 (Photo: Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

The BulletinJuly 20, 2020

The Bulletin: User-pays managed isolation on its way

A hotel staff worker sanitises the outside of Auckland’s Stamford Plaza on July 10, 2020 (Photo: Hannah Peters/Getty Images)
A hotel staff worker sanitises the outside of Auckland’s Stamford Plaza on July 10, 2020 (Photo: Hannah Peters/Getty Images)

Good morning and welcome to The Bulletin. In today’s edition: National announces its plan to charge returnees $3,000 and the government indicates a policy is coming soon, Judith Collins’ first weekend as National leader, and Northland reels from flood damage.

The days of free hotel stays for all returning New Zealanders appear to be drawing to a close. With taxpayers having already stumped up more than $81 million in managed isolation and quarantine costs, the government is under increasing pressure to introduce some form of user-pays.

Yesterday National announced it planned to charge returnees $3,000 each, with children under three years exempt; those over three would incur a charge of $500. Deputy leader Gerry Brownlee said it all comes down to fairness. “Many Kiwis have only one or two overseas holidays in their lives. National won’t expect taxpayers to pay for other Kiwis returning from high-paying careers or expensive holidays in Europe.”

It’s very clear by now that the government has something similar in mind. Instead of the usual sniping at National’s policy, minister in charge of managed isolation and quarantine Megan Woods simply said it was “encouraging” to see the opposition support “something the government’s been talking about for a number of weeks now”. The prime minister has previously said she wants to charge only those who chose to leave the country after lockdown, and Woods said yesterday the charges should be “fair and equitable”. But last night, Stuff’s Henry Cooke reported a cabinet paper was circulating proposing the exact same charge as National’s policy – $3k. Cabinet is set to discuss it this afternoon, though it’s not clear if an announcement will be made today. Either way, by getting out in front of the government, National is now in a position to claim the moral high ground on the issue.

So does that mean a “fees for returnees” policy will sail through parliament? Not quite, according to Victoria University of Wellington law lecturer Dean Knight. He told Stuff a payment scheme would likely require a new law, carefully calibrated to avoid breaching citizens’ legal rights. While the Bill of Rights protects the right of return to the country, it also allows the government to introduce “reasonable and proportionate constraints” on that right.

Another risk factor is the reaction of those forced to pay up, argued Knight’s Victoria University law colleague Eddie Clark in a tweet thread. “It feels inevitable that a charging regime will increase non-compliance with managed isolation. If people feel fine, are being charged an arm and a leg, and resent their detention, you think that encourages compliance? Yes the current regime is expensive. But with a very few exceptions, it seems to be working.”


The Spinoff would like to invite Bulletin readers to a special event with Breast Cancer Foundation NZ. 

The effects of Covid-19 are often hidden from everyday view. Writing on The Spinoff, Breast Cancer NZ ambassador Stacey Morrison spoke to Chloe Irvine about her experience with breast cancer through lockdown.

To support Breast Cancer Foundation NZ’s vital work, The Spinoff is holding a Pink Ribbon Breakfast. Hosted by Stacey Morrison at Kind cafe in Morningside, Auckland, on July 28 from 7.30am, the breakfast will hear from women about their breast cancer journeys and foundation advocates about the work they do.

Limited tickets are available here, including breakfast. If you live outside Auckland or are unable to join us for breakfast we still welcome your support for Breast Cancer Foundation NZ.


No surprises that Judith Collins’ first weekend as National leader was a busy one – on Saturday morning she appeared on Newshub’s The Nation in typical bullish form about her party’s chances at the election, then headed out to her Papakura electorate to put up hoardings, joking that wielding the electric drill felt like holding a taser.

While the headshots have been replaced – Todd Muller and Nikki Kaye with Collins and new deputy Gerry Brownlee – the Muller-era slogan (“Strong team. More jobs. Better economy”) remains. National’s supposed stronger team has been a frequent refrain since Collins took the reins on Tuesday and, as The Spinoff’s Toby Manhire hinted at earlier in the week, is a bit of a misnomer given the past week’s exodus of MPs. The Herald’s Audrey Young made the point in an op-ed on Saturday, saying the continual reference to it in Friday’s transport package announcement jarred.

On Sunday morning, an Andrea Vance feature in the Sunday Star-Times provided a fascinating insight into the events that led to Collins taking the reins, painting a picture of indecisiveness, in-fighting and constant leaks. That morning, Collins appeared on TVNZ’s Q+A, previewing the quarantine charging policy that Brownlee announced later, and telling host Jack Tame she thought the economy was this generation’s nuclear-free issue. She also went on Newshub’s The Hui, challenged by host Mihingarangi Forbes on her comments suggesting she was “demonised” for being white. “I will not be told that because I happen to be white I don’t care, I don’t empathise,” Collins said. For more on Collins’ views on diversity and why, to some, they are concerning, read Saturday’s excellent piece by The Spinoff’s Leonie Hayden.


New Zealand First launched its campaign yesterday, with leader Winston Peters rallying against, well, pretty much everything, as The Spinoff’s live updates reported. Alongside introducing the pleasingly whimsical spectre of “woke pixie dust” – thank you for unwittingly providing The Spinoff pub quiz team with a new name, Mr Peters – taxes and immigration seemed to be the main concern. In a report for The Spinoff, Hayden Donnell said the overarching theme was fear.


After two days of torrential rain, the full extent of the damage from the weekend’s floods in Northland is becoming clear. Civil defence minister Peeni Henare, who visited yesterday as the clean-up got under way, described the damage in his hometown of Moerewa as “heartbreaking”, and said a long-term solution was needed. The cost of the damage is still being assessed, but repairs to roads alone is expected to reach $2 million, Far North Council chief executive Shaun Clarke told the Northern Advocate. Acting Far North Civil Defence controller Alastair Wells said an assessment of flooded properties would be completed by the end of Sunday, with work on an assistance package for affected residents due to start today.


Workers at The Warehouse stores across the country are expected to learn their fate this morning. All waged team members across all stores will meet at 8am for “important information about proposed changes”, according to an internal memo reported by Stuff. More than 1,080 jobs are expected to go as part of major restructure across The Warehouse Group that could result in at least six store closures. The company had taken $68 million in wage subsidy payments before announcing the proposed job cuts in June, which angered prime minister Jacinda Ardern.


New Zealand’s emissions reduction target is too low to meet the government’s goal of keeping the average temperature increase to within 1.5 degrees CelsiusStuff’s Eloise Gibson reported over the weekend. Climate change minister James Shaw received advice from the Ministry for the Environment to that extent in February, documents obtained under the OIA show. The emissions reduction target was set by the Key government as part of the Paris Agreement in 2015, while the 1.5C goal was set in last year’s Zero Carbon Act. The target allows around 85 million tonnes more emissions between 2021 and 2030 than would be compatible with a 1.5C goal, reports Stuff, which puts the country over budget by about one year’s current emissions.


Got some feedback about The Bulletin, or anything in the news? Drop us a line at thebulletin@thespinoff.co.nz

 

Right now on The Spinoff: Dirty Politics author Nicky Hager gives five reasons why Judith Collins is unlikely to be the next prime minister, saying she’s the wrong person at the wrong time. Laura O’Connell Rapira says politicians are trying to divide us to win power, and they can’t be allowed to succeed. Liam Hehir warns of the dangers of ideological factionalism within the National Party. Michael Andrew reports on a Te Awamutu sustainable fashion business whose sewing centre in Cambodia provides disadvantaged people with a better life. And Hayden Donnell calls for New Zealand to memorialise its lovesick hero, Nigel the gannet.


For a feature today, Stuff’s Nikki Macdonald explores why New Zealand’s low-wage workers – those doing what are often the most taxing, and most essential, jobs – are paid so poorly. Macdonald speaks to hospital security guards, cleaners, bus drivers unionists and economists to investigate the “hollowing out” – the ravine that has eroded between New Zealand’s best and worst paid.


It was a great weekend for Super Rugby Aotearoa, with two nail-biter matches as the Hurricanes edged the Blues on Saturday and the Highlanders made an incredible comeback to snatch victory from the Chiefs yesterday. Saturday’s match saw the battle of the Barrett brothers: read Liam Napier’s report for the Herald here.


That’s it for The Bulletin. If you want to support the work we do at The Spinoff, please check out our membership programme